Captain Braunsfeld

I like this. Congratulations for the frontpage!

"If you were a sail boat, I would sail you to the shore." And this sailboat - a fine creation by @Sebeus I & @Legostone - would certainly fly to the shore in no time. Check out more pictures in the LEGO Pirates Forum!

Well done, congratulations

Behold this fine vessel, created by @MrOutlaw It could be an official set, right? If you want to see more pictures, head on to the LEGO Pirates Forum!

That is a fine creation of yours. Congratulations for being on the frontpage. How will the story continue?

New member @Juhlhaushas created this very dynamic scene with nice forced perspective. There is a storyline and more pictures to go along with it. Check it out in the LEGO Pirates Forum! Quote

Excellent Dark Elf! I only have not figured out where the minifig head is from...?

... it was about time Congratulations! (first time I put a gif on the frontpage, I hope it works out well)

@Marooned Marin has no only created a very fine island (including a monkey) - he has also gifted us with a gif that shows the whole thing! And then he has created an exciting comic-style story around this. Check it out in the LEGO Pirates Forum!

The island is great (and it has a monkey!) and I finally found the time to read your amazing story. Perfect!

Congratulations! I like the two custom-hull ships and the way you have posed them for the picture. Great job!

Two fine ships engaged in action - what more do you want to see? Find out more about @Quotenotto's fine creation in the LEGO Pirates Forum!

That role is fine for me. Correcting people in languages that are foreign to myself is actually great.

The captain has reconsidered (and probably not fully read the rules) and changed his vote

My vote goes to @Mazin for understanding purpose and story of my build. Overall I did not enjoy this "boost for critics"-challenge as most of them kept missing the point of my MOC in a very verbose way...