Challenge III Voting Thread

[MattTheLegoman]

2) =1 point

10) =1 point

15) =1 point

31)=1 point

32)=1 point

My own judgements

2: NiceMarmot Quest for the Water Crystal

That sand thing is the coolest!

10: lisqr Demon's Pillar

Love the use of pieces here

15: gabe The isle with no name

Love the island, what is its name?

31: rogueang Allora's Quest for the Earth Gem

Best story

32: Kayne The Lich Rises

Inspiring build

Edited May 17, 2012 by MattTheLegoman

[KristofBD]

Some truly amazing builds!

One point goes to:

* 6 - De Gothia

* 25 - Hersbrucker (love the ships)

* 16 - Basiliscus

* 15 - Gabe

* 11 - Cara (love the colours and the non-squareness!!)

Each of them stood out. Love them all!

Edited May 17, 2012 by KristofBD

[bartjuh]

1 point = 7: zcerberus The Keeper's Tomb

1 point = 9: Ecclesiastes Crystal Quest

1 point = 10: lisqr Demon's Pillar

1 point = 11: Cara Above the Clouds

1 point = 33: Tazmaniac Quest for the Fire Crystal

[hellboy]

4: Erynlasqalen Adventure time = 1 Point

7: zcerberus The Keeper's Tomb = 1 Point

11: Cara Above the Clouds = 1 Point

25: Hersbruker The Hidden Land = 1 Point

33: Tazmaniac Quest for the Fire Crystal = 1 Point

Sorry for all without points, but only 5 Points for so many good Mocs.

[Yatkuu]

Good lord, the quality level is insane...

11: Cara Above the Clouds - 3 points (how many swords in that dragon?!)

15: gabe The isle with no name - 2 points (the micro version of the island is genius)

[mrjensmeister]

1 point each

8 rolli

11 cara

25 hersbruker

31 rogueang

33 tazmaniac

Edited May 17, 2012 by mrjensmeister

[prvi svog imena]

My votes are:

19: Angeli 3 votes

22: Zach Mills 1 vote

25: Hersbruker 1 vote

I am sad that yet again I didn't enter :(

[Fat Tony]

31: rogueang Allora's Quest for the Earth Gem- 1 point

15: gabe The isle with no name- 1 point

11: Cara Above the Clouds- 3 points!

[Hersbrucker]

Very hard decision

For Avalonia:

1 Point to Nr. 6 de Gothia Quinn's quest for the Earth element

For Kalaphlin:

1 Point to Nr. 16 Basiliscus Above the Falls

For Mitgardia:

1 Point to Nr. 28 Blaze The search for the Crystal(I think Cara have enough votes for her beatuiful build)

And for Nocturnus:

1 Point to Nr. 33 Tazmaniac Quest for the Fire Crystal

1 Point to Nr. 10 lisqr Demon's Pillar

[Lego Otaku]

Hmmm... that is hard. I liked them all. But only 5 points among 33 entries?

Fortunately there is NO minimum point specified in the rule, only maximum of 3 points so I'll take the easy way out and award as follow:

01) 0.15 points

02) 0.15 points

03) 0.15 points

04) 0.15 points

05) 0.15 points

06) 0.15 points

07) 0.15 points

08) 0.15 points

09) 0.15 points

10) 0.15 points

11) 0.15 points

12) 0.15 points

13) 0.15 points

14) 0.15 points

15) 0.15 points

16) 0.15 points

17) 0.15 points

18) 0.15 points

19) 0.15 points

20) 0.15 points

21) 0.15 points

22) 0.15 points

23) 0.15 points

24) 0.15 points

25) 0.15 points

26) 0.15 points

27) 0.15 points

28) 0.15 points

29) 0.15 points

30) 0.15 points

31) 0.15 points

32) 0.15 points

33) 0.15 points

*whistles*

[Legonardo]

Hmmm... that is hard. I liked them all. But only 5 points among 33 entries?

Fortunately there is NO minimum point specified in the rule, only maximum of 3 points so I'll take the easy way out and award as follow:

>snip<

*whistles*

I'm not entirely sure that's what the rules meant...

Edited May 19, 2012 by Legonardo Davidy

[purpleparadox]

Hmmm... that is hard. I liked them all. But only 5 points among 33 entries?

Fortunately there is NO minimum point specified in the rule, only maximum of 3 points so I'll take the easy way out and award as follow:

*snip*

*whistles*

Usually I don't read voting threads after I've placed my vote, but by chance I did open it, and this made me laugh. I wonder what happens when a mod shows up and reads that....

[Mike S]

01) 0.15 points

02) 0.15 points

03) 0.15 points

04) 0.15 points

05) 0.15 points

06) 0.15 points

07) 0.15 points

08) 0.15 points

09) 0.15 points

10) 0.15 points

11) 0.15 points

12) 0.15 points

13) 0.15 points

14) 0.15 points

15) 0.15 points

16) 0.15 points

17) 0.15 points

18) 0.15 points

19) 0.15 points

20) 0.15 points

21) 0.15 points

22) 0.15 points

23) 0.15 points

24) 0.15 points

25) 0.15 points

26) 0.15 points

27) 0.15 points

28) 0.15 points

29) 0.15 points

30) 0.15 points

31) 0.15 points

32) 0.15 points

33) 0.15 points

*whistles*

There is a rule that you must use all 5 points and you have 0.05 points left... Just saying...

[Basiliscus]

Here are my votes:

2) NiceMarmot, 1 point

3) Robuko, 1 point

5) Christoph, 1 point

19) Angeli, 1 point

25) Hersbruker, 1 point

Some fantastic entries!

[Flint]

7) zcerberus - The Keeper's Tomb: 1 point

9) ecclesiastes - Crystal Quest: 1 point

10) lisqr - Demon's Pillar: 1 point

15) gabe - The isle with no name: 1 point

31) rogueang: Allora's Quest for the Earth Gem: 1 point

[Skalldyr]

04 - 1 Point

07 - 1 Point

08 - 1 Point

10 - 1 Point

11 - 1 Point (My absolute favorite but all the others are so amazing, too!)

Good luck!

[pjschard]

7) 1 point

10) 1 Point

11) 1 point

20) 1 point

31) 1 point

Edited May 21, 2012 by pjschard

[Doornroosje]

6) de Gothia: 1 point

7) Zcerberus: 1 point

11) Cara: 1 point

15) Gabe: 1 point

33) Tazmaniac: 1 point

[robuko]

31 rogueang 1 point for outstanding variety, story and photography

20 Jareth 1 point for for outstanding script, humour, and imagination

19 Angeli 1 point for sheer epic arrogance, and for pulling it off - also for an amazing story

10 lisqr 1 point for stunning technique and vision

5 Christoph 1 point for brilliant technical skill and for imagination

This was very hard to choose - honourable mentions to Erynlasgalen, Cara, gabe, Basiliscus, Jason Cicchini, and Tazmaniac, who were all in my top 5 at some point. Many thanks to the judges for their comments on the builds, I think their comments have been very helpful.

[Maxim I]

11) 1

16) 1

19) 1

31) 1

33) 1

Great entries!!!

Congratz to all!

[Angeli]

Edit: wow, the vote is still on ;) I will wait with this then :)

Edited May 23, 2012 by Angeli

[Savage Sebstian]

7) 1 point

10) 1 point

11) 1 point

16) 1 point

33) 1 point

Wonderful work all guild members!

[SkaForHire]

16 = 2

11 = 2

32 = 1

Damn. Just Damn. Great job everyone.

[Capt.JohnPaul]

No minimum amount of points? Everyone vote negative against Nocturnus!

Really great job guys, it was a pain to decide one over the other, and I hope I'll be able to participate next round.

6) de gothia 1 point

10) lisqr 1 point

11) Care 1 point

15) Gabe 1 point

16) Basillicus 1 point

[Si-MOCs]

I think people have had enough time to vote...

Thanks for everyone who took the time to vote seriously

The winner of the JOUST will be announced with the Challenge 3 scoring.

(like we don't know who that will be )