Hinckley

It was Barry.

As an expert on the things I say, you're misrepresenting what I've said.

They?

William, your memory sure is convenient: You said to me in private that I'm Scummy because I said you were undermining me and that I'm lying about my suspicions. This is how me saying you undermined me came up: That's the order the posts happened in. I said it in direct response to you saying I was trying to discredit you. If we want William dead, there are other ways to kill him besides lynch if we're worried that he's a vengeful Scum.

So maybe not all fishing is done by Scum. Think about it, Lauren. They are afraid of being Daved. Wasn't a list of vanillas sent by Lauren to the Scum yesterday, giving them a smaller pool to choose Night kills from? It'd help if we could trust the Stumps. Are you going to be here every day? I did send codes.

Barry was definitely not the vig. I'm fine with the deal, William. People I've talked to know your dramatic fit in private and confidence in your role made me question my suspicions but your involvement with a liar make me feel more confident about my suspicions again.

Again, so accurate, William.

Did you ask the other stumps at the time? Are you PMing each other?

Did you notice at the time that it wasn't a code from the list he had sent you?

Did you point that out to anyone yesterday?

You can see killing a Townie who's been confirmed by the investigator.

I'm trying things. Maybe there's something to figure out that we're missing. I checked the pictures too for clues to what weapon was used like Sammy suggested yesterday. A hatchet and saw were used again. I love the fire in your belly! Yes, you are stuck riding down the center in my memory. Perhaps I'm wrong. Sorry. Glad to hear you're working hard. You left him off of your list of active people who might be Scum. And maybe you missed the part of him making a deal with the claimed "neutral bomb who converts to a killer after day four and only needs to kill one person to win" to kill me. You think that's Oak play? Stumps... We already told you what we heard about Barry and William working together. What else do you want to know?

Jack is the definition of flying under the radar. What do you think of William? Did jluck ever claim a code to you guys in private? I know some were confused about if they could PM you. He told everyone to send codes but it doesn't look like he ever did himself.

Alder, don't just stare at what we're saying, answer your PM, please. All due respect, sorry. Are the stumps that are removed Maples? Is that why they're removed? Please help us.

This is the weirdest thing I have ever heard. William, why would you believe such a claim? A neutral bomb that converts to a killer on Day Four and only has to kill one person to live??? What the tree bark? (Sorry I'm late to the pun brigade.) No, the construction men used dynamite to remove the stump so he couldn't come back, right? It looks to me like the janitor strikes again. Or, could it be as simple as we just need to figure out that the trees that don't remain stumps are Maples? They did replant Alastair in the sun. That was their chief complaint. No light. Now he has what he wanted, he's a maple? Maybe? Should we PM the host and ask him and then maybe the "janitoring" if that's even what it is will stop. I'll give it a shot. Is William around? This neutral bomb story is crazy. I'd like to hear an explanation from him. Oh wait, I guess that which has been dynamited can not be replanted.

Where is it?

Two real-life days. not Mafia days. I haven't lied about anything. You tried to blame an Oak lynch on me like you had been trying to stop the Town from lynching her. Yes, William, you are Catrina's champion. You've been fishing for info all (game) day, trying to undermine me and Bruce, which is a 180 degree flip from you running to Bruce and claiming your role when I first announced he was a confirmed Oak. You changed your mind because I was confirmed last night? And why did you feel the need to tell so many people random info about your role? Why was that necessary? You have spent a lot of time today trying to undermine me and Bruce and yet you don't vote for one of us until the end of the day. Why did you spend so much time questioning us (really, fishing) if you were just going to vote for Bobby? It's suspicious that you reveal private info Bruce gave you, fish for investigator info all day, scrutinizing us like we're lying and then don't make a case for anybody else and just vote for Bobby. You get caught lying about your view of the Catarina lynch to try to discredit me and you try to avoid answering for it by throwing an OMGUS vote. Scum. Where have I ever defended Hazel?

I concur. I believe I said earlier that it came up in context of the conversation. It wasn't a random message about how to play Miller. I think that might've pinged me.

Many. Trust me. I've been grilled about it many times as well. Lassie is thorough. Jack. I haven't felt great about him or his involvement in the weird bickering with Catarina and Alastair on Day One. He hasn't done anything to instill confidence. I will look over all his posts when I get the time. I think you may be onto something with your read of him. He hasn't brought up many suspicions but he did go out of his way to tell me to stop bringing up suspicions. That could be similar to the tactic I've noticed from the Three Scum Stooges, Nash, William and Sammy. Trying to encourage people not to listen to me. I made it about myself again. I think your read is worth looking into.

You, Sammy and Nash trying to discredit me for two days is suspicious. You have all three been heavily fishing about the investigator, Sammy going as far as to fish, in-thread, if I'm the investigator. What Townies would do what you three are doing? And you blatantly contradicted yourself for everyone to see. You can't edit it. You agree with Catrina's lynch when it's convenient for you, but then say you said it was BS the whole time, trying to discredit me. Desperately trying to undermine the formation of a Town block and encouraging people not to trust me, when I'm not even asking for claims myself, is super Scummy. Lying, fishing, misrepresenting things I say: Scum. Period.

The halt in conversation here is telling.

That's not what you said. You said the lynch itself was BS. And this is all you have to say to all of the things I said about you. I feel Oak William would be more belligerent and arrogant, metagaming that may be... Scum.

It's striking that you're not voting for the person you find to be "more scummy".