Hinckley

I'll attest to the fact that Dave worked pretty hard behind the scenes last night.

Yes, I see. I think this is weird. Again, not incriminating but something to keep an eye on. Perhaps she did not have a lunch at the time because she had already eaten it? That's certainly possible. Actually, that would make the most sense.

From Day Two, Cece says: So, unless Cece has used her lunch, she still should have a thief lunch and there's no reason for you to not have been able to steal it from her. If you stole her lunch as she was stealing Penny's...wait are you Penny or Patty? Who the hell am I talking to? You... what the hell? OK, You're Patty. So Cece steals Penny's lunch and you steal Cece's lunch, you should've ended up with Penny's lunch. I know there's no precedence for lunch in these Matilda Dreams, but you should've ended up with Penny's lunch if you targeted Cece on Night One... Stealing doesn't happen during the day, it happens at night. Liar. Strike that. You mean you sent in the Action request during the day. Yes, that is possible. Sorry. I didn't mean to call you a liar. Although, I think you are, but not for what you just said.

Interesting. That is in direct contradiction to a story I heard... When did you try to steal her lunch?

Day One (Patty contributions continued) Have you used your lunch, Patty? Any results? Patty doesn't vote on Day One. Day Two This is an interesting theory. Probably not good for the Townies who have night actions, but I guess we'll see how today plays out. Hasn't been paying attention... I think she's referring to Police Infiltration (whatever that is...). I think it's interesting that she was suspicious of Sara and Wild Dragon, because they didn't do much yesterday. Unless that's the point... Wild Dragon didn't even vote. Did she talk to any of these people in private to back up her suspicions? Commenting on people believing the day deaths are mod-kills: Is the 5th vote for Walter. Day 3 The infamous asterisks post: Ignores other questions directed at her and votes 19th (last) for Shadell. Not damning, but nothing really helfpul either...

Contributions from Patty: Day One Why thank you. This is terrible, seeing my fellow horses die. I don't want to see anymore of this madness, so let's try our best to end it. Finds Heather suspicious, who we now know is a Townie. Staying off of the Townie-lynching bandwagon. It's just that we can't ignore the chance of Trisha actually having this role. Yeah, I know, it's a ridiculous claim, but I don't think we should vote her off just yet. If she really does have a lie-detector role, the scum would jump at the chance to get rid of her. But like I said, I don't completely believe it yet either, I just don't think we should vote her off right away. Called out by Daisy, doesn't mean they can't both be Scum. Oops. I hit Post for some reason. This will be split, obviously. Sorry.

Oh Wow, Fred. You were saving that one.

What events this morning make you not trust me? Sorry, Katie. We cross-posted.

But they could've started one to avoid being detected... Just saying... It's a stretch anyway. Let's analyze Darth Potato's actual contributions.

Penny's contributions: Day One After being accused by Matilda: It's worth noting that Matilda voted for Penny. Penny votes for nobody. Day Two Matilda points out that this isn't very helpful, but focuses more on Mike. That is the end of Penny's contributions. Again, no vote. Day Three And that's the end of her Day Three contribution. No vote again. Haven't heard from her yet today, have we? Not helpful, Penny. You're not even a sheep. Why didn't you clarify this when I first said it? Bold is another form of emphasis. Asterisks make a word bold on a writeboard. It's weird that you used asterisks to emphasize, I'm not used to seeing that... Let's take a look at your contributions next...

Why did you use them? What else have you been up to outside of posting with asterisks?

I bet Fred loves that. Thanks, Sweetums!

She's hanging there and there's blood, but is she dead?

Oh dear! Where is this game going? I'll take responsibility. If Daisy comes up Town, then for some reason God isn't being inconsistent. My death will prove that too and help the Town, so no hard feelings at all. I realize that even with two investigations and two Scum corpses I've helped to deliver, in Matilda Dreams, nobody's character is beyond reproach. If we come to the point where it would benefit the Town to lynch me, fine.

Asterisks! Don't forget Patty the Asterisks Horse. And Penny hasn't voted or posted.

That's up to the day vig.

Daisy is so insistent about not having an Action that I keep checking my PM to verify. It says the result is on Daisy so I wasn't redirected. It says the glasses are black with a bushy mustache attached. I think that means she disguised herself thinking I was going to have her investigated. When Amy and Fred saw the glasses, they were just frames, so maybe she was out framing that night. The other person confirmed had an object that was a direct clue to their Night (or Day) Action. The glasses must mean the same thing. Daisy has an Action. The flavor cop lunch on me didn't show anything and I have a bulletproof vest. Katie is a Sibling and when I used my lunch on her it also showed nothing. The flavor cop lunch doesn't seem to show lunches or passive Actions so Daisy must have an active Night or Day Action that she has an active part in deciding how it's used. If God is being consistent, then Daisy has an Action and is lying to us and has been lying about being Vanilla...

It's funny that my Night Action result specifically says the mustache is "bushy" when you went on and on yesterday about BUCHI...

It's funny that my Night Action result specifically says the mustache is "bushy" when you went on and on yesterday about BUCHI...

You know for a fact that he's not Scum, right? Because you are and he's not on your team... Or maybe you are on the same team. Reverse Psychology... For now I trust Fozzie, though. I've been looking through my communications with Daisy. He tells me one of the reasons he thought Heather was Rowlf was because Heather told him she knew someone who had a way of verifying if he had used a Lunch or used an Action. I'm sure Daisy was afraid of being caught, so another reason I believe she is Scum. Heather basically threatened him that she would be able to see if he had an Action and he thought she was Rowlf. Another Scummy thing Katie did yesterday: She said she was afraid to appear Scummy. Which is an odd thing for a Townie to say. Townies shouldn't worry about "appearing Scummy". If they are telling the truth, it will be proven in the long run and benefit the Town. Interestingly, Penny has never voted and has barely posted.

Daisy's defense in private: "I am not a liar." "I do not have a job." Those aren't exact quotes, by the way. Wouldn't want to break the rules. However, my point is that she isn't giving any other explanation, defying God and not offering any other accusations or cases against what is happening here. Remind anyone of Shadell? Daisy, do you have anything of substance for us? I don't think God would lie to me.

Go ahead and vote for me if you're not convinced at this point, but I did just help Fozzie decide not to kill you since we were afraid we might lose two Townies, since you proved you were the other Sibling. Then I told you immediately when I learned Daisy was the one was lying. So, why do you still suspect me after I've helped you? You're still very strange to me, even if Daisy is Scum. Your behavior has just been off. Potential language barrier aside, you pulled the Scummy "I'm confused about everything" followed by the even Scummier "I'll be right back with in-depth voting and behavior analysis!" that we never saw. Hopefully, we'll have cleared up soon enough anyway. You may just be a weird sibling. I'm not confident doing anything like lynching or vig-killing you until we're absolutely certain you're Scum. You're definitely a Sibling and we'll lose your counterpart if you die. I'm convinced your Sibling is Town, so I don't want you dying unless we know for a fact that you're Scum. Maybe your posts were so Scummy, Daisy decided to bus you. However, how would this Scum team survive with Shadell bussing Matilda and Daisy bussing you? Anyway, keep suspecting me in the mean time. I'm sure that'll get you far. I'll continue to try and help get you verified... Katie, one more thing: How can you doubt Daisy's alignment since he was blatantly lying to you all night, which you said yourself, and his only defense is "I'm not Scum. Oscar is setting me up"? What substance do you see in his argument that gives you any doubt as to his alignment? Especially since you were screaming all night that he was Scum? You were convinced he was Scum but now you're going to wait to see? I don't follow your logic and I haven't followed it almost this whole game. This whole Katie/Daisy thing is just weird.

Oh Gee, thanks for the vote of confidence. Maybe a third town investigation and a fourth Scum corpse will inch you closer to believing me.

Update on the Daisy situation: Sara just used her lunch on a player who had made a roleclaim to me in private. The result that Sara got was a clue to that roleclaim. Therefore, the flavor cop lunch works towards a players Day or Night Action. I am guessing Daisy is the Day Framer to counteract the Day Investigator. It's easy for Daisy to claim vanilla again and again if she wouldn't be seen targeting anyone at night. Daisy: Scum. With that in mind, let's not be so vocal about who we want to investigate during the day. It may be too late to get an accurate reading on Katie... Tammy, what is AtE?

Setting you up? Here's something I hadn't told you. During all of that madness to figure out if it was you or Dr. Teeth lying, I encouraged Fozzie not to kill you. He was so convinced you were lying he had submitted his Action to kill you and I suggested he change it to protect The Inventor. Why? Because we couldn't be sure which one of you was lying and I didn't want to potentially lose Townies who were playing hard. Fozzie and I also decided not to kill Dr. Teeth because if he was telling the truth, we'd lose two Townies. Yes, Dr. Teeth is an insane person who, for some reason, seems super Scummy as well, but the point is, Fozzie and I called off any killing so we could verify our suspicions through other means. I wasn't sure about you, but still thought you were 75% trustable, despite everyone else saying you were probably Scum. Now, at this point, blame God because she was the one who told me about your glasses. That's information we have. We can't ignore it. Even if you've worked super hard, which I agree, we can't take the chance that it doesn't mean something. A true Townie, a true Vanilla Townie would know that this is the way to forward the team. You've been working your megablocks off, I just don't think it's for the Town side. And despite people attacking you as a person. I've had a lot of fun with you in this game. I've really enjoyed our conversation. It's the longest of any other I have going. Sorry, I'm so paranoid that I thought you needed a third lunch on you, but you kept asking for and guessing identities, so I had to have you verified. Had to! I used one lunch on Katie who had no item. Two lunches had been used on you that both showed frames without lenses. Why did Katie have nothing, after she claims to have used her lunch, and you've had two similar items after you've used your lunch? The Town needs to find that out. Yes. I wasn't going to let you know which one we were using so you could have yourself tailored. Maybe that's what you are? A Scum Jack-of-All-Trades. You did use the watcher on Night One, that's how you found Fozzie, who you keep trying to convince me is Scum or Neutral, and maybe you tailored yourself last night, hence the mustache disguise, since you knew I was out to verify you. Your defense isn't a Townie defense, I'm sorry to say. Verify verify verify. I suggest we investigate Katie, since I'm positive Daisy is lying to us and not sure if the whole argument with Katie was some sort of elaborate ruse, so I'd love to see Katie investigated as I think we already know Daisy's alignment. I don't mind the triple verification. I also want to be sure before we send out any huge sausages or flesh eating chickens. If it means anything, I'm really going to miss you.