Yzalirk

Okay, so I looked back and this is what I found; Day One - Berty voted against Agnes more as a poke to get him to speak up. Then Agnes voted against Berty, which looks like a revenge vote but Berty did claim to be the Miller out of the blue. I don't know whether or not I should believe that claim since it seemed odd to claim that on Day One for no reason. I would have also thought he would have been targeted for that but no, that hasn't happened. I'm not sure what to make of that but it seems rather odd. However, I suspected Larry for quite a while because it seemed like he's defended two people - William and Bobby. It was Day One so why would you stick your neck out for two people and are unaware of what they may be? Vicky was also the first to vote against Alastair and no one has really bothered him him/her so my guess is that a vigilnate may have targeted Vicky. That's just a speculation, nothing else. Day Two - Vicky was the first to vote against Chester. My speculation is a 50/50 here since the vigilante may have killed Vicky because the vigilante may have thought that Vicky could be trying to start a band wagon or that a Maple thought this. More speculation, again. Chester has been suspicious to a few people as well, so that should be taken into consideration, just like Larry. Agnes was the third to vote against Catarina so he could have been a random target for all we know. I still have to look and see if Vicky and Agnes have been clashing against anyone and see if there is a motive there. I'm just not sure of who to vote for though since it's a bit tough for me right now and The Walking Dead's new episode will be on shortly so I'll make up my mind later on.

I'm actually not sure why, to be honest. I'll take a look in a few minutes and see what I find that can help out.

Well that was up to him. what, do you think I magically dictate things for him to say?

What ideas did I even have..? Apart from a little suggestion a made earlier.

I'd like to know too.

That's something. Maybe she wanted you to be dealt with so she attacked you lat night? Maybe that's the simple to find out. Who has Berty been "friendly" with? Maybe a friend of Berty has done the deed for her.

I agree with this. It's certainly not going to give us an answer but it's a good lead for now. Should we see who voted against Vicky and/or Agnes or see who they may have clashed against?

Welcome, LittleJohn, to Kaliphlin! The promos are looking good, Ska! I should also have my new character up sometime next week or weekend since I'll be ordering a bunch on things later on today. Still not sure whether or not to simply go with either the Balin or Dwalin minifig armor for my character. I might buy both instead though.

I might have one or two, Marmot but not until later this month. I believe I have to get them verified by Ska first, right?

Yeah, I don't really understand how exactly it'll work.

That makes me wonder which one(s) could be lying...

Sorry everyone, I missed out on a lot apparently that I need to reread to get caught up. I am aware though that there is voting as well. Hopefully this shouldn't be of surprise. Vote: Catarina Dogwood (adventurer1) I think it's pretty self-explanatory why I vote her but I'll quickly sum up why I vote for her - She has given weak accusations with merely no evidence besides making assumptions and has overall given weak explanations to try try and defend herself. For example: Anyone can say that but how do we know if she really is? I think if she is, she'd have defended herself way better than she has. She is simply lazy and has overall been of no use to the "town". I should also mention she has said this; She says she's fine with being lynched, on Day One, but isn't prepared today... it seems like? Even if she does turn up to be an Oak, then we'll have a bit less fluff posts and aimless accusations from here. She has been flailing about quite a bit it seems like and if she is really an Oak, I think she'd be trying a bit harder to prove her innocence. Like I said, it just seems like she's lazy and what help is a lazy player? Whoops, meant "her", not "here".

Yes, that is true. That was the response I got from asking a question. Did I assume that? Only after that response I got that said it was possible. That isn't a guaranteed yes or no. Unless you can prove otherwise, I'd like to hear since I never suggested it at all. Like I said previously, I don't care whether or not the vigilante exposes them self. I wouldn't be surprised since Berty gave her role out on Day One but had justified the reasoning behind it. Now, I'm not implying that that was an odd claim but it's not uncommon for people to tell their roles. If the vigilante exposes them self, yes, that is pretty unwise, but they can do it via PM, since they could be a great asset to us Oaks or could be our downfall, depending on who the vigilante is working with. I'm just speculating that this could be a possibility since it can happen and it'll probably end up happening. Unless you can disprove this possibility, Waldorf, it's something that we should all be concerned at least a little bit about.

Actually, not that is not even close. Can you find me saying something like this "Vigilante, come out and show yourself, I command thee!" But I will keep in mind the fact that you want to try and create a bandwagon against me when you pretty much have no reason to vote against me besides for conclusions that you cannot prove. Good job there, "Oak".

Catarina, do you even have proof that Alastair was a Maple? We can't prove that so your argument is pretty much useless. I don't know why voting against you makes me instantly scum at all but when you preformed "The Flail" pretty nicely when you had two votes and earlier because you couldn't find evidence, and still can't, that makes you look pretty bad. I think we all have yet to see what evidence you have to show but until then, good job on convincing people over nothing.

That was earlier because that was before Elder Alden announced that Stumps cannot message living tree. And since you know, why bother asking? Again, you are jumping the conclusions without evidence. When did I ever claim to be the vigilante? You are clearly trying to hint at that I could be the vigilante and I'm not sure why. I also get the impression you didn't even read anything I have said but are just basing off what others have said. I asked if either Lauren or Buck could have been attacked by either a Maple or a vigilante. You know what, I'll just make it easier for you since, like I said, I don't think you even from the beginning. I also bolded the part where I asked just so you don't miss it.

Again, you're trying to put words in my mouth. That is entirely up to the vigilante to come out and say who he/she attacked.

I'm not sure what possessed me to think so but when I was told this, That had me thinking it could be possible.

I dunno...

You don't sound so sure and it seems like you want some reassurance from others to help support your claims, am I correct? Truely, I still find you to be a Maple and after you being almost speechless, it's not making it any better for you. You were also squirming quite a bit with two votes against you so if you're an Oak, why do "The Flail"? You are also beginning to do it now as well. A true Oak would stay positive, keep his/her branches up, and actually be of help. That is why I still believe you're a Maple and pointing the finger aimlessly at others without reasoning is quite Maple-y, wouldn't you agree?

Perhaps the Maples could have done so to try and throw us off. Overall, I'm not sure other than to say it could be a clever ruse but it's hard to say.

I don't see why not since it doesn't say anything about not being able to PM...

You are jumping to conclusions which isn't wise as it may throw people off. I questioned if he was Neutral, knowing that it's undetermined now, because it didn't say he was either Oak or Maple. So I was a bit confused on that. I don't intend for a vigilante to come out, unless he/she wants to than sure..? I also completely forgot about the SK as well, whoops!

Wow, so Alastair was Neutral? I'm also not sure what to make of Lauren and Buck becoming stumps. So were both Maple attacks or was one a Vigilante attack? So many questions to be asked... And Berry, I believe the stumps can talk but can't do anything.

It's not like it matters, guys, since the picture will just of a head-shot.