getdamonkey Posted May 22, 2014 Unvote: Greg Kennedy (Lego Spy) Vote: Emma Lane (vampyre78) post #108 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Lego Spy Posted May 22, 2014 ok, I wanna get my vote in before everyone else floods in.<strong>Vote: Greg Kennedy (Lego Spy) Why? Well because a few things. While I don't suspect Greg and Isaac were communicating, I do think Greg was quick to bandwagon, this is an easy way for scum to hide because their vote won't stand out. Also, he claims he chose Melinda randomly. That just doesn't add up for me. He had worked through several leads only to randomly vote for someone? Therefore, I am voting for him. First, I had no idea who to vote for on day one, and I've never played a mafia game before (on the internet), leading me to vote earlier in the day. And secondly, it was the first day. No one has any real solid facts, so I had no good leads to vote for anyone. Plus I voted for Melinda because she already had one vote on her, and if I were to make an accusation on someone without any votes, they would have given the typical Day 1 'Why I'm Innocent' speech that I wouldn't have been able to defend my vote against. <strong>Vote: Emma Lane (vampyre78) (I'm going to vote again since it's hard to see. I'm pretty sure these posts will morph together.) VOTE: Emma Lane (vampyre78) (My mobile device doesn't allow me to embolden text.) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vampyre78 Posted May 22, 2014 From my own suspicions after day one's voting which I raised earlier, as well as the reasons Adam raises in post #102 I'm placing my vote for Greg. Emily and Melinda both voted for Greg on day one and ended up dead, and looking back I don't think I paid enough attention to Emily's strong defence of Adam. We need to stand together, and vote together, for the Academy to survive. Vote: Greg Kennedy (Lego Spy) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jluck Posted May 22, 2014 And I'm still not sure why you're voting for me, as I was running out of time, and it was the first day, so [/b]I just randomly chose Melinda.[/b] Who Isaac voted for was completely his own decision. He never said randomly, He said "I'm running out of time, so I'm just going to make a vote." He could be basing his vote off all the facts you discussed, but didn't have time to type every stinking fact up. (Note: I shortened both quotes to emphasize the relavent info) Seriously, just read the quote. He said directly, I voted randomly. It one thing to say that it was a first day mistake, it's another thing to say it didn't happen when he said so himself. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Calanon Posted May 22, 2014 With time running out in the day, I must make a decision. From what we have, Greg is looking the most suspicious. Therefore: Vote: Greg Kennedy (Lego Spy) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Tohst Posted May 22, 2014 While Adam makes some sound reasons to vote for Greg, I must say Willie you have not cleared yourself at all. I never said you joined the bandwagons, I said you started them. There are two things wrong there. I've started exactly one bandwagon. I voiced some suspicions on Jeff too, and then he stepped up and (mostly) squashed those worries. I voiced some suspicions on Greg, but I'm not seeing any sort of bandwagon form there. So, I'm not starting any bandwagons other than the one (hardly a trend) and even if I did, looking through the evidence and voicing suspicions is what Loyalists should do, right? Are you really looking for scummy behavior in this? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Lady K Posted May 22, 2014 There are two things wrong there. I've started exactly one bandwagon. I voiced some suspicions on Jeff too, and then he stepped up and (mostly) squashed those worries. I voiced some suspicions on Greg, but I'm not seeing any sort of bandwagon form there. So, I'm not starting any bandwagons other than the one (hardly a trend) and even if I did, looking through the evidence and voicing suspicions is what Loyalists should do, right? Are you really looking for scummy behavior in this? I'm looking for answers to things I find unusual. I take all info into account before questioning anyone. If I get an acceptable response then I'm satisfied. What I'm not satisfied with is now Warren. Your initial vote for Emma in post 85 quoting posts 78,80 makes no sense. They are someone else's reason and for they actually the same post (one original,one quote of original) . Now you suddenly un vote Emma and vote Adam with post 123 also someone else's reasons. Please state your reason for voting Adam. As Emily pointed out on day 1 with the bandwagon he us probably town. Use your vote wisely because right now you look very very scummy to me. Jeff your sudden change from Greg to Emma makes no sense with the reasons given unless Greg is scum and Emma is town. Here's why; in your post 42 you state Greg is the best suspect based on current evidence.n then in post 79 you say Emma is suspicious but the evidence against Greg is more concrete. Now you switch to Emma saying post 108 as reason and that there are subtle efforts to push the game in a direction. What I don't get are two things. First off your reasons against Emma don't seem as strong in your words as your reasons against Greg. Secondly, you never state why Greg is no longer as suspect with concrete evidence? Care to explain? Incedently this makes you look suspicious? I would like to point out that right now I believe I'm the deciding vote. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
getdamonkey Posted May 22, 2014 You'll have to excuse me, I've spent most of the night repairing a broken exhaust manifold and have only had half a cup of coffee so far Since I've established why it's a bad behavior (essentially works out to a proportional vote against town). Here's the random vote list (correct me if there's others, I am not counting tit-for tats or unstated reasons though). Warren Day 1 #64 Greg Day 1 #199 Melinda Day 1 #201 Greg's vote is declared as random, which as a reminder was then immediately followed by Isaac. That was poorly formatted ... One more for clarity... Warren -- Day 1 #64 Greg -- Day 1 #199 Melinda -- Day 1 #201 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Lady K Posted May 22, 2014 Ok, but why the sudden switch to Emma? Jeff, you have officially lost me. Makes no sense stated that way! Warren, care to weigh in? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
-Horizon- Posted May 22, 2014 Ok, but why the sudden switch to Emma? Jeff, you have officially lost me. Makes no sense stated that way! Warren, care to weigh in? About What? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Lady K Posted May 22, 2014 About What? See post 132. Clarify please. I'm preparing my vote! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
-Horizon- Posted May 22, 2014 See post 132. Clarify please. I'm preparing my vote! To me Adam looks scummy because he's blaming Greg for joining band-wagons when plenty of other players did it. I don't know I just felt that Emma wasn't Scum so I changed my vote. I didn't think it was suspicious to change your vote. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
getdamonkey Posted May 22, 2014 Since I'll be surprised if I make it through night actions, I'm going to leave my probables list My probable scum list is as follows: Tier 1 - Highest Probability Emma - stated Greg - stated Tier 2 - Worth Looking into Warren - Lots of random votes, heavy splintering behavior. Likelihood increases dramatically if Greg is scum. Willie - bit of a Keyser Soze thing going on (If you haven't seen "The Usual Suspects II: Suspects in Space", go watch it) Adam - Enough people have suspected him that just letting things go would be an issue. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Lady K Posted May 22, 2014 To me Adam looks scummy because he's blaming Greg for joining band-wagons when plenty of other players did it. I don't know I just felt that Emma wasn't Scum so I changed my vote. I didn't think it was suspicious to change your vote. Thanks Warren. I believe I understand now. So here is my vote: Vote: Greg Kennedy (Lego Spy) Greg, I have reviewed post from day 1and 2 and your voting from day1 and 2 plus the grouping of names voting the same as you. I find that it looks like due to the bandwagon against Adam that turned on Melinda (town) worked so well, I believe the scum tried it with one of their own this time. I'm not saying Emma is not suspicious just that you are more so and the evidence against you looks worse. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
getdamonkey Posted May 22, 2014 Jeff your sudden change from Greg to Emma makes no sense with the reasons given unless Greg is scum and Emma is town. Here's why; in your post 42 you state Greg is the best suspect based on current evidence.n then in post 79 you say Emma is suspicious but the evidence against Greg is more concrete. Now you switch to Emma saying post 108 as reason and that there are subtle efforts to push the game in a direction. What I don't get are two things. First off your reasons against Emma don't seem as strong in your words as your reasons against Greg. Secondly, you never state why Greg is no longer as suspect with concrete evidence? Care to explain? Incedently this makes you look suspicious? I would like to point out that right now I believe I'm the deciding vote. I'm on the fence between the two. I more switched to prevent a flood of votes against Greg. But now I'm more concerned with preventing a tie. Unvote: Emma Lane (vampyre78) Vote: Greg Kennedy (Lego Spy) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jluck Posted May 22, 2014 I'm on the fence between the two. I more switched to prevent a flood of votes against Greg. But now I'm more concerned with preventing a tie. Unvote: Emma Lane (vampyre78) Vote: Greg Kennedy (Lego Spy) Just curious, why would a tie be so bad? Do they both die? And if that's the case wouldn't you prefer that since you suspect them both? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
getdamonkey Posted May 22, 2014 Just curious, why would a tie be so bad? Do they both die? And if that's the case wouldn't you prefer that since you suspect them both? Pretty sure neither gets lynched if there's a tie Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jluck Posted May 22, 2014 Pretty sure neither gets lynched if there's a tie Gotcha, hopefully bob will clarify for us. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bob Posted May 22, 2014 Vote Count: Greg Kennedy / Lego Spy: 6 (getdamonkey, Tohst, jluckhaupt, vampyre78, Calanon, adventurer1) Emma Lane / vampyre78: 2 (Comrade Commander, Lego Spy) Adam Powers / jluckhaupt: 1 (lego3364) Greg Kennedy / Lego Spy has been lynched. As a note, if there is a tie, the first person who reached the vote will be lynched. A day conclusion and lesson will be up soon. Sorry for the late close! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bob Posted May 22, 2014 "You can't lynch me, I'm a doctor. I can't hurt anybody!" Greg Kennedy / Lego Spy said. But nobody was listening. "This is ridiculous. I'll have you know that I'm going to be filing a formal complaint." Greg was taken out of the lounge to be brought to the detention level. The remaining students were escorted back to their quarters. ~~~ I've decided to hold off on the lesson until tomorrow since there aren't too many more left to give. Remember, send in those night actions! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
