Jump to content
Eurobricks Forums

Recommended Posts

  • Governor
Posted

Click here for vote tallies

Return of the Classic Pirates Contest
VOTING NOW CLOSED:

pbag09adiv

 

 

Click Here for Voting Tallies

 

Return of the Classic Pirates Contest
Vote for the WINNERS!

Voting will take place between August 28 and September 16.

You may allocate 3-5 votes to entries in both the Main Building Category and Mini Set Building Category for a total of to 6 to 10 votes.

All votes have equal weight (position/order is irrelevant) and you may only assign one vote per entry.

  

How to Vote

  1. Read and understand the complete Voting Rules.
  2. Review all the contest entries
  3. Create a new post in this and in two separate lists, simply name the 3-5 entries from each category you'd like to assign your votes to.

Include both the Entry's Name and the Builder's Name to avoid confusion as some entries have similar names.

And ideally write a heading for each list with the name of the Building Category:

For example:

  Quote

Main Building Category
"Entry Name" 1 by Builder's Name
"Entry Name" 2 by Builder's Name
"Entry Name" 3 by Builder's Name
"Entry Name" 4 by Builder's Name
"Entry Name" 5 by Builder's Name

Mini Set Building Category
"Entry Name 1" by Builder's Name
"Entry Name 2" by Builder's Name
"Entry Name 3" by Builder's Name
"Entry Name 4" by Builder's Name
"Entry Name 5" by Builder's Name

Expand  

 

There are only TWO categories

The Main Building Category and the Mini Set Building Category.

There is NO category distinction as to whether an entry is a new set concept or a remake of an existing set.  That is a builder's creative choice, not a category.
 

How many entries can I vote for?

A minimum of 3 and a maximum of 5 in each category for a total of to 6 to 10 votes over both categories.

 

Please only create one post in this topic

When counting votes we want to ensure the process is efficient and transparent as possible.

So if you:

  • Have a question, feedback or a concern regarding the voting process, please post in the Voting Rules topic.
  • Feel the need to discuss a particular creation, please do so in that creation's entry topic.

 

  • Governor
Posted

Contest Entries Index <- Can be Found HERE

Follow the link above for lists with large thumbnails, entry names and builder names.

divider.png

Or if you prefer a quick visual overview...

 

Main Building Category

New Set Concepts
Click the thumbnails below to view more images of the entry.

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry53142635977_7e8e66c489_c.jpg53143263231_b1bb49fc00_c_d.jpg53142807602_7fe5268926_c.jpg

53143725048_79cabe9f34_c.jpgClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry53143394946_a8f9715bb7_c.jpgClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here to view more imagesClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

 

Classic Set Remakes
Click the thumbnails below to view more images of the entry.

Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images Click here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry53144544808_50bde455e6_h.jpg 53124022173_e3b4bff3a4_c.jpg53139512775_bd69e17175_c.jpg

53022248850_a4f45320c8_b.jpgClick here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry  Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entry

 

Mini Set Building Category

New Set Concepts
Click the thumbnails below to view more images of the entry.

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more imagesClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

 

Classic Set Remakes
Click the thumbnails below to view more images of the entry.

Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry Click here to view more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entryClick here for more images of this entry

Click here to enlarge image Click here for more images of this entry Click here for more images of this entry

 

divider.png

Contest Entries Index <- Can be Found HERE

Posted (edited)

Thanks everyone for all the marvelous entries :pir-huzzah2:

 

Main Building Category

6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers' Tavern by Aanchir
6279 Skull-Island Remake by MyFirstMOC-Hun
The Lizard By CaptainDarkNStormy
Big Kahuna's Atoll by Yatkuu
Forbidden Cove by TomSkippy

Mini Set Building Category

1464 Pirate Lookout Reborn by Elephant Knight
Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch
Failed Raid by SNobleJr
Furtune Idol by Oky

 

 

Edited by Yperio_Bricks
formatting
Posted

A lot of amazing creations!

Main building Category

Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy
Cross Bone Clipper Remake by Elephant Knight
6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4
Short Pork Island by Yoggington
6244 Armada Sentry Remake by Brickshipyard

Mini Set Building Category

Treasure Surprise Remake: Rum Rock by Fraunces
Shark Cart by TomSkippy
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat (Mini Set) by kritch
Treasure Island by Oky
Sloop Windy (Mini Set) by Marooned Marin

Posted

This contest has turned summer-2023 into a grand Pirates celebration :pir-triumph: These were not exactly the easiest of choices to make, given the striking amount of magnificent & competitive entries, but at last here are 10 of my personal favourites from both Categories: 

 

Main Building Category

1. Cutless Reach by LetsBrick

2. 6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate

3. 6260/6257 Pirates - Shipwreck Island/Castaway's Raft Remake by _R_R_

4. Cross Bone Clipper Remake UPDATED! by Elephant Knight

5. Short Pork Island by Yoggington

 

Mini Set Building Category

1. Hidden Cache by LetsBrick

2. 6235 Buried Treasure Remake by Janhansson

3. Fortune Idol by Oky

4. 1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake by Dr3w

5. Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin

Posted

There are too many good ones to pick only 5!

 

Main Building Category
1. Cross Bone Clipper Remake UPDATED! by Elephant Knight
2. 6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4
3. 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern by Aanchir
4. Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy
5 .6271 Imperial Flagship Redux by Elephant Knight

Mini Set Building Category
1. Shark Cart by TomSkippy
2. King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch
3, Treasure Island by Oky
4. Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin
5. 1795 Imperial Cannon Remake by CaptainDarkNStormy

Posted

Boy do I wish I could vote for some more but, :pir-thumb: to everyone who entered and a very special thanks to @Mister Phes for running the contest :pir-huzzah2: Great work :)

Main Building Category
"Skulls Eye Schooner remake "  by Quotenotto
"Saber Island 2023"  by TomSkippy
"6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern"  by Aanchir
"6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake " by Danny_Boy4
"Short Pork Island" by Yogginton

Mini Set Building Category
"Fortune Idol" by Oky
"1464 Pirate Lookout Reborn " by Elephant Knight
"6232 Skeleton Crew Remake " by Jack Sassy
"Treasure Found " by JopieK
"Sloop Windy" by Marooned Marin

Posted

That was a great contest! :pir-huzzah2: Many thanks to all participants for the good builds.

 

Main Building Category:

Caribbean Shipyard by Cincinnati

Sin Island by Marooned Marin

Skulls Eye Schooner remake by Quotenotto

Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383

6262 King Kahuka’s Throne Remake by SevenDeadlyStreamers

 

Mini Set Building Category:

Rum Rock by Fraunces

Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte

Shark Cart by TomSkippy

Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin

6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy

Posted

Main building category:

1. 6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4

2. 6260/6257 Pirates - Shipwreck Island/ Castaway's Raft Remake by _R_R_
 

3. Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy
 

4. 6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern by Aanchir

5. Caribbean Clipper by TomSkippy
 

Mini building category:

1. Treasure Island by Oky
 

2. Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin
 

3. Shark Cart by TomSkippy
 

4. Shipwreck of Avedo by Tayaya
 

5.  Fortune Idol by Oky

Posted (edited)

Main Building category:

6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate

Sin Island by Marooned Marin

6259 Broadsides Brig / 6234 Renegades Raft by TheWatchman

6273 Rock Island Refuge Remake by CollinsAnimationStudio

6281 Pirate's Perilous Pitfall Remake 2023 by Slegengr

 

Mini Set Building category:

Rum Rock by Fraunces

Fortune Idol by Oky

Shark Cart by TomSkippy

Pirate's Dock by Elephant Knight

1795 Imperial Cannon Remake by CaptainDarkNStormy

 

All lovely entries, so had to pick me votes carefully. Glad I could participate in this contest. :pir-thumb:

Edited by Jack Sassy
Accidently voted for 6 entries instead of 5 in the Main Building category
Posted

My voting is based on the original contest post stating "The emphasis is building a creation that could pass as an official LEGO set".
I was amazed at the quality of some of these but I couldn't see them as official Lego Pirates sets. The sets I'm voting for, I could all see on store shelves as actual sets.

Main Building Category
Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy
Big Kahuna's Atoll by Yatkuu
Cutless Reach by LetsBrick
The Hearty Cutlass by Thats No Moon
Le Scorpion by Jansued

Mini Set Building Category
Shark Cart by TomSkippy
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch
Treasure Island by Oky
Hidden Cache by LetsBrick
Treasure Found by JopieK

Posted

Main Building Category

1) The Brick Stop “The Lost Lagoon”

2) OMBY54 “Base Impériale”

3) Rouge Redcoat “6277 Imperial Trading Post Remake”

4)SevenDeadlyStreamers “6262 King Kahuka’s Throne Remake”

5) Tom Skippy “Sabre Island 2023”

Mini Set Building Category 

1) Janhansson “6235 Buried Treasure”

2) SevenDeadlyStreamers “Remake of 6234 Renegade’s Raft”

3) Dr3w “1802 Tidy Treasure Remake”

4) Oky “Treasure Island”

5) Kritch “King Kahuka’s Outrigger Boat”

Posted (edited)

This was very tough to whittle down to just five per category, and there are double-figured amounts of other entries deserving of votes, but here's what I ended up with:

VOTES
Main Set Building Category
6274 Caribbean Clipper Remake by Alexu
Forbidden Cove by TomSkippy
1871 Pirate Canon Battlepack by Jansued
Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383
6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate


Mini Set Building Category
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch
Shark Cart by TomSkippy
Fortune Idol by Oky
1872 Imperial Guard Camp by Thewatchman
Treasure Island by Oky

 

Critic Comments:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

divider.png

 

Edit 8th Sep:

Adding an extra vote in my Main category votes as my Alexu vote no longer counts through their disqualification.

  •  Skulls Eye Schooner remake by Quotenotto

New Critic comment:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

 

Edited by Yoggington
Posted

Thanks to all for theese amazing creations!!!

Main Building Category

-          Caribbean shipyard by Cincinnati

-          6279 Skull Island - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC

-          Imperial Trading Outpost by aex383

-          6267 Lagoon Lock-Up Revisited by CaptainLocke

-          Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy

Mini Set Building Category

-          Shipwrecked Survivor by nyugvo6

-          Captain’s Cabin by MontyMatte

-          Cannibals by Valdeirus

-          Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin

-          1795 Imperial Cannon Remake by CaptainDarkNStormy

Posted

Shoutout to the organizers of this amazing contest and thanks for all the effort put in by the builders! Voting was the hardest thing to do!

Main Building Category

Short Pork Island by Yogginton / 1 point

Armada Fortress by Elephant Knight / 1 point

Saber Island 2023 by TomSkippy / 1 point

6273 Rock Island Refuge Remake by CollinsAnimationStudio / 1 point

6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4 / 1 point

 

Mini Set Building Category

6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy / 1 point

Pirate's Dock by ElephantKnight / 1 point

Pirate Gun Cart Revisited by Vdog / 1 point

Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin / 1 point

1872 Imperial Guard Camp by Thewatchman / 1 point

Posted (edited)

Main Building Category
6278/6292 Enchanted Island by Danny_Boy4
6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern by Aanchir
6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate
6273 Rock Island Refuge by CollinsAnimationStudio
6260/6257 Pirates - Shipwreck Island/ Castaway's Raft by _R_R_

Mini Set Building Category
Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin
Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte
Buried Treasure 6235 by omby54
Treasure Island by Oky
6232 Skeleton Crew by Jack Sassy

 

Edited by Slegengr
Formatting
Posted

Good luck to all participants and thank you for those who supported my entry! My votes cover all categories of the contest which was to build a new set and remake an original set. I've decided to pick sets I could see TLG producing over the really beautiful entries more akin to MOCs but voting was still very hard!

Main Building Category
6278/6292 Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4
Sin Island by Marooned Marin
6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern by Aanchir
The Lost Lagoon by The Brick Stop
Caribbean Clipper by TomSkippy

Mini Set Building Category
Treasure Island by Oky
1802 Tidy Treasure - Remake by Dr3w
Pirate's Dock by ElephantKnight
6232 Skeleton Crew Remake by Jack Sassy
King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch

Posted

Main Building Category
1. Governor Broadside's Garrison by US_Army_Tom
2. Armada Fortress by Spacepolice89
3. 6269 Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate
 

Mini Set Building Category
1. Failed Raid by SNobleJr
2. Ritual Sacrifice by SpacePolice89
3. Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin
 

Posted

This was an excellent contest with many great builds.  Creative critic final words in the spoiler tags.

Main category

Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake by Aanchir

Enchanted Island Remake by Danny_Boy4

Imperial Flagship Redux by Elephant Knight

Rock Island Refuge by CaptainDarkNStormy

SIN ISLAND: Keg & Cutlass Inn by Marooned Marin

  Reveal hidden contents

Mini set category

Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin

King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by kritch

Fortune Idol by Oky

Treasure Island by Oky

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Posted

Also from my side a big "Thank you" to the organizers (Mister Phes & co), the participants, and the reviewers! Great job all of you! :pir-huzzah2: Those were some busy weeks here in the pirates forum.

And wow, very hard decisions to make here, I loved so many of those buildings. How could you guys do this in that short time? Impressive!

Here is my final selection:

Main Building Category

Short Pork Island by Yogginton

The Hearty Cutlass by Thats No Moon

1872 Imperial Guard Camp - Remake 2023 by MyFirstMOC-Hun

Big Kahuna's Atoll by Yatkuu

1795 Imperial Cannon Battlepack by Jansued

 

Mini Set Building Category
Fortune Idol by Oky

King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch

Captain's Cabin by MontyMatte

Sloop Windy by Marooned Marin

Caribbean River Soldiers by Rogue Redocat

Posted

Great stuff, makes it hard to choose:

Main Building Category

Imperial Trading Outpost by AEX383
6267 Lagoon Lock-Up/Soldiers’ Tavern Remake by Aanchir
Sabre Island II  by BrickComm...
6254+6258 "Remastered" - Atolls  by Amedeo
Base impériale by Omby54

Mini Set Building Category

6235 Buried Treasure remake by Janhansson
6300 Treasure Found by Jopiek
6500 A Promiscuous Sailor Captain (Mini Set) by Jopiek

 

  • Mister Phes changed the title to [CONTEST] Vote for the WINNERS! (Yes, you can still vote if you entered the contest)
Posted

After dealing with entries battling over my dreams for days, and then carefully counting contents of all envelopes from Contestants, these are my final choices:

 

MAIN BUILDING CATEGORY:

1. Le Scorpion by Jansued ...................................................... ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

2. Redbeard's Rocky Island Escape by Dilligan ..................... ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

3. Lost Lagoon by Brick Stop ................................................... ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

4. Islander Palace by BrynnOfCastlegate ............................... ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

5. Skull Island Remake by Glowboy .......................................... ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

 

MINI SET BUILDING CATEGORY:

1. Fortune Idol by Oky  ................................................................ ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

2. Renegade's Raft by SevenDeadlyStreamers  ....................... ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

3. King Kahuka's Outrigger Boat by Kritch  ................................ ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

4. Great Pirate Treasure by Xoona .............................................. ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

5. Carribean River Soldiers by Rogue Redcoat  ......................... ( check my final thoughts and reasons behind this vote HERE )

 

And of course the Honorary Oscar goes to Mister Phes for running the whole show :pir-huzzah2:

My reasons behind these selections below:  

  Reveal hidden contents

My finals thoughts on the entire Contest:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...