Jump to content

Hinckley

Root Administrator
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    35,896

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Hinckley

  1. Hinckley
    I think we should stop posting host names in our signatures...
  2. Hinckley
    It's a smorgasbord of votes. If all 9 remaining non-voters vote for the same person, we'll have a lynch.
  3. Hinckley
    It's not an Action, it was a joke that someone made. My speculation is why would someone choose the two of us. Just forget it. Don't think about it again. You might hurt yourself.
  4. Hinckley
    These are your words now. That's you repeating what Ender said. This is your own theory, as you state, based on your own experience. No, I'm looking for clues as to why someone chose (even as a joke) to switch my clothes with yours. That's not in the pictures, that is a message from God. Every time you repeat yourself, the meaning seems to change. If I were going to vote for you, I already would have. What are you basing this on?
  5. Hinckley
    You spent a lot of time talking about your side–dish. Who is your appetizer and main course? Dessert?
  6. Hinckley
    I'm not saying she's on the level. I'm saying I'm inclined to believe her as I see it as a difficult Scum gambit. Your reaction to Minga's vote analysis has you close to the top of my list, too.
  7. Hinckley
    Claw is almost more obsessed with me than Clem. Let's take a wee look at all of his flappin's: Blatantly trying to implicate Minga in Ender's death. Not that he's saying Minga is Scum and killed Ender. He's just asking. Why me, exactly? Maybe someone was going to kill anyone and was blocked or the target protected. So, now Claw is giving us another book report on things that have happened. Apparently this is "analyzing" the things that Ender contributed. Here, I'm mentioned again by Claw, whose theory of Minga buddying up to a Townie has me playing the Townie. It seems the Claw knows I'm a Townie. Why am I wearing your clothes anyway? I know someone was knobbing around for a cheeky time but it is interesting that it was the Claw and I who changed clothes. Unless that was a host joke to make me Zero–suit. And the prankster just wanted to see me in my skivvies. But, that's all besides the point. I gotta stop the rambling... Here, I'm mentioned again. The Claw just canny help itself! And it's announced that I should be investigated. It bugs me I receive so much metagamey focus but this bugged me for more that I couldn't pinpoint at the time. But now it seems like "If people want to claim, let's have Seamus investigated...so we can frame his megablocks. " Here I am again, this time killing power roles therefore I must be the Godfather. Not just plain old Scum or tailored Scum or somebody else in the Town block is Scum but it has to be me, again. Is my point that the Claw is stalking me? I would like to speak with the Cap'n about how restraining orders are handled. But with all the discussion about not claiming to people until they're verified there certainly is a lot of talk from the Claw about me heading up a Town block. Are you trying to buddy up to a Townie or is that something only Clementine would be guilty of? And why doesn't this one start with me being investigated? Just go claim to Seamus and if a bunch of you die, then he's the Godfather. What the hell is going on? People who were implicated by Minga's voting analysis really don't think it's a good analysis. So Scum killed Ender to frame Minga and what did Minga do on Day One that they wanted to take him out? Is Minga the only person Ender suspected? I'm sorry that you are at odds with your gut. Here's another plea for me to be investigated along with the sage advice not to claim to me if I'm Scum. Where would we be without you? "I don't analyze anything, I just repeat them in a concise summary." I don't know if it's weird to constantly mention me and repeatedly tell people to claim to me and push for me to be investigated. But it is weird the Claw can't seem to make up his mind or his gut about Minga being suspicious and Minga makes good points about his vote (along with Paul and Laura). I was getting ready to vote for Paul but now that I see more from the Claw and look back at its contributions today, I think I might be voting for it... I need to think about it.
  8. Hinckley
    Sorry, mate. I assumed you were answering the question I just asked about why you seem to be changing what you're saying.
  9. Hinckley
    Me? When did you ever mention me as suspect? And when did Ender?
  10. Hinckley
    So you didn't suspect Minga because Ender suspected him?
  11. Hinckley
    If you would like to share your creation, you can do so in the Special Themes forum but we do not allow people to post only to promote themselves, their products or IDEAS projects. Sorry. I hope you find what you are looking for in our community, otherwise. We're more than happy to have you here sharing your creations. We allow people to link to their IDEAS project page, but blatantly campaigning for your project will not be allowed. Thank you. Phred has edited the title and I edited the content of your post. Please feel free to edit back in details about your actual MOC but we don't allow people to ask for support in such a blatant manner. Please visit the Site Guidelines posted in my signature. Thank you for your understanding and patience.
  12. Hinckley
    I disagree with the way Clem has handled her role too, but I think you're making it more dire than it actually is. This is all assuming Clem is on the level, of course. I don't think a backup vig without the Scum having prior knowledge would confuse the hell out of them. I think they'd say "Aw, nuts. A backup." And move on. This may have actually saved the vig's life if they role copped him/her on Night One. Because now they might need to reconfigure their tactics if they know the vig will just be replaced anyway and try to kill a less powerful role if they can figure one out. And the Town now has the information that we have a backup and the Town getting info, which is hard to come by in this game, is a way to strengthen the Town. I don't think everybody should claim publicly. No no no. But the more info we have to go forward on, the more confident we can be as a collective Town. We also know that the second highest vote–getter from yesterday should not be lynched today and we should take the time to let that claim play out and focus on other players' slip–ups. So, while I don't think Clem handled her (claimed) role the best way, I think you should stop berating her when it appears that you are only skimming what has been said anyway. As someone else was craikin' earlier, Minga's vote analysis is the most substance we've seen all day. He took the time to check what everyone had said before voting started in order to separate those who appeared to put a lot of thought into their vote and those who seemed to just jump on the bandwagon. I wonder where Paul and Laura show up in that analysis, considering their opinion of it is eerily similar. Is the conversation you had about it on the writeboard spilling over into the day thread, Scummy Scummos? Interesting. Yar looking like the wee hens who never layed away if you know what I mean.
  13. Hinckley
    What's wrong with Minga's vote analysis and where's your better one?
  14. Hinckley
    Yes, I think because Harriet had already thoroughly analyzed his low activity. To totally metagame, Major Dave always plays this way and is always one to be careful of.
  15. Hinckley
    Aye, it's no approval, mate.
  16. Hinckley
    Ah, but that defense is as circumstantial as my suspicion. So... carry on, then.
  17. Hinckley
    Let's be equal opportunity about those flying under the radar. Those posting low on both days (so far) are: Bock Pathos Diamond Dodd Hannah Ford Laura Starbucks Nathan Mallard Paul Harkonnen Rip Sewer Vazquez Rodriguez Rip and Diamond have made the most memorable contributions from their low number of posts. The others blend in which is always where some of the Scum try to end up, in my recent memory, the most dangerous and hardest to catch. Because somebody will make an accurate accusation and they will be able to easily explain it away since there isn't a lot of content to base a stronger case off of. I know that's a lot of people but those are the ones I see as under the radar currently. Zipzop could be there as well if it weren't for his slightly higher post content from Day One. I understood it well the first time. Except for the part about vanillas claiming vanilla. But what are people supposed to say to others? "I'm claiming to Clem" but not take the extra safety of saying what the claim is? If people were to claim and tell two other people would they just say "I'm claiming to Clem" to the other two people. And yes, I still understand what a bad idea you're saying what you're giving us detailed instructions to follow is. Forgive me for metagaming but the last time you came up with an elaborate plan for the Town you were Scum trying to confuse us.
  18. Hinckley
    Whoa man, like I didn't require the repetition. It's written down I could've gone back and read it. I also didn't need the in–depth scenario. It made sense both times and looks the same both times: Don't claim to Clem, but here's a highly detailed plan if we want to all claim to Clem. Talk about being confusing to noobs. Not to mention your plan requires people to lie which is another good place for Scum to hide. "I claimed to Clem with a false roleclaim like I was told". And two other people would be able to backup that false claiming was part of the plan. This seems like you're trying to confuse.
  19. Hinckley
    I admit to finding Claw's way of expressing themselves confounding on a metagaming basis, but I agree with your assessment. Claw's statement have rubbed me against the grain at least a wee bit, dudes... I still don't like this. Claw, if you reckon everyone was expecting it, why aren't you questioning those who voted for him? Why would you be OK with people voting for him who didn't think he was Scum? I really didn't like this when I read it and I couldn't pinpoint why. Is this what the Scum chose to kill Ender for? To incriminate Minga? This is a sloppy way to incriminate someone, if so but. Or I'm Scum and was blocked. Where's that possibility? I agree with this analysis, 4 of 2. However, irrelevant as it is, I have never known Scum to have a watcher. But, what I find odd about this analysis is that Clementine started yesterday by flipping out that 4 of 2 was trying to get people to claim to me. But now 4 of 2 seems to be encouraging people to claim to her? And have some lie about it? This sounds all very difficult to manage. But then he reverses and tells us all not to claim to Clem...
  20. Hinckley
    This is a different explanation from what you told us yesterday for why you didn't post your suspicions.
  21. Hinckley
    I'm so chuffed someone did the arithmetic for me.
  22. Hinckley
    Weird, mate. I thought your name was 4 of 2. Must be all the drugs in my napper. Thanks for the answer, Rip Sewer. It's a sarcastic ending to my postulation. Since she blurted (seemingly) out of nowhere, her role. Sorry my humor is too sophisticated for you. I'll try to communicate at a more daft level, brother.
  23. Hinckley
    Your language is a wee oaf too, though. You say the blocker is the protector and that the Scum will suspect Clementine. Why would anyone be a suspect to the Scum, exactly? I don't follow. And everyone saying that Clementine revealing being the backup (assuming it's true) takes away the Scum's ability to false claim are every bit as silly as Clementine for thinking she is the barometer for all PR deaths. She is (if she is indeed the backup) the barometer for exactly one Town PR and the Scum will be free to false claim once she's announced to everyone that she has taken over a role.
  24. Hinckley
    There is something more about the language tha' is bunching me knickers up. Something about the need for protection since the protector won't know yet who the vig or investigator are. Something I can't quite put my finger on. It is sound logic. The possibility of the protector and any other role connecting on Day Two is slim. I also don't think this would be a great Scum strategy to claim "backup". It could be quite easy to debunk once a Town block does start forming. For it to be a successful Scum claim Clementine would have to be on a team that has already role–copped the vig. Then if they are to kill the vig, he could claim to be the vig, but then the Scum kill would mysteriously disappear. So, although I disagree with the way she has handled it and her attitude, I am leaning Town on Clementine. If she is telling the truth, then we lost three vanilla Townies last night. Unless it is a gambit to get them all to claim to her...
  25. Hinckley
    This is a remnant of April Fool's Day. This is because there was speculation that one of the three dead Townies could be our vig. And Godfather because she freaked out yesterday that 4 of 2 could be trying to get everyone to claim to me when today she seems to be trying to form a town block around herself. Her fear yesterday was that 4 wanted people to claim to me because she was afraid I could be the Godfather after reading a game I wasn't in that gave her nightmares about me.
×
×
  • Create New...