Hinckley

I love when hosts do feedback!! Are you going to go back and do it for Ragnarok 2? I actually thought the opposite with his Scum play. I thought he had convincingly (because it was real as he was Town at the time) explained his suspicions about me and then fitting in with the logic of the lynch for the day helped keep suspicion off of him. Having been caught being targeted by Scum wasn't going to be good and if he had voted for me I think it would've been too obvious. And then the decision to stay home to avoid detection was also a good bet. If you look at my tunnel vision suspicions before the vote that day, I was hoping people would want to lynch Pie (aka the 7th Scum of Ragnarok 3 ) Thanks for doing feedback!!! :wub: Yes. I don't respond well to "unjust" accusations. I'm kind of a mule that way. And the tunnel vision on CallMePie was a little crazy. I really thought his suspicion of me was Scummy because it seemed to come out of nowhere, relied on incorrect math and then appeared to be a ploy to win. I was truly convinced he was Scum and they would've won had I been lynched. I was so annoyed when he flipped Town. I do love that this game had me arguing like a mad man with two people I consider friends and it was all left in the game. Yes, great job. Thank you.

Pfffft. What, I'm supposed to read the whole thing and identify it is as a joke? Sheesh...

Ming the Merciless

Heh heh. This planet has got the munchies, man. Hey, is this in the same neighborhood as LV–426? I hear there are some nasty natives there, man. Or not natives or whatever. Nasty either way.

Hi! I'm Seamus Aaron. I'm a man, don't let the hair fool ya.

What was your win condition?

This, yes.

38 minutes!

What the hell was that?

There could be a subforum where only the "Gamer" group could post but then staff who are playing would still have the issue. Or...maybe I could limit staff posting too... I think I could... Hmmmmm...

1. I've played Mafia Sometimes I'm Scum, sometimes Town I don't always Oink 2. No, but I'll neglect my life's responsibilities to obsess over it 3. Firefly, Robinson Crusoe 4. g=0 fuc=k 4=5374 5. No

I've done it twice. I create anonymous accounts for every player. Pay attention.

Attaboy! No dinner before Mafia!

Yet we were discussing them and you didn't have knowledge of roles to avoid killing. Trust me, it's different. Yes, I see now it was a in the first post followed by the explanation and then a in the next post. Obviously, I was totally surprised you would target anyone we hadn't talked about. It didn't cross my mind until that point that you didn't trust me. When you don't trust me you try to get me lynched.

And don't worry about pulling from the Ragnarok discussion. You should leave the sign–ups open for about a week so that will give us a chance to get that crazy game out of our system and heal our brains. My MRI is scheduled for tomorrow.

I thought of you as I typed that.

Don't you mean JJ Abrams?

Where are the sign–ups????? This is something you'll have to put up with, impatient Hinck. Where???????? Coincidentally, waiting for the conclusion I sent a PM to TPRU that just said "When????". I also sent him several new theories about the game mechanics.

I also think it's hilarious that the shapeshifting role warned Pandora that she had killed the investigator. One ping was that her reaction to killing the investigator was a little insincere. "Oooops. Sorry. " Maybe she did this too but it wasn't enough. She was almost lynched for that. Hindsight is 20/20. I think what I went to Pie about at that point was that it felt like she wasn't exercising enough caution to be the vig. I understand the thinking that I'm protecting a friend but killing that person is a harsh test. She could've just as easily have been reading me protecting a PR. If only I had worded things that way on Day 12! Well, we won anyway, but that would've been a really good point! I liked reading the dead board about how people felt about our arguments. Little ego boosts. I know. I was also imagining the time between finding out and lynching Pandora. 96 hours to theorize about two Scum teams and where the vig went. And then she would flip Neutral...and my mind would literally explode...

You have certainly raised the bar. No, that's not necessary. I'll find him wherever he goes. Dangerous! How would the Town figure that out? That was the best coincidence ever. I laughed so hard. I requested that she kill one of the giants...or a random Viking if there were no enemies available. Who was it? Reading the dead board, hadn't he planned on redirecting Pandora onto Adam? Which he knew was the right thing to do since Pie outed all of the roles. But didn't TrumpetKing choose to stay home to avoid detection? The Night Action spreadsheet says "kill no one". TPRU, If Danny had investigated Pandora on Night Three (which was the other option we discussed) would she have come up as Scum since she was shapeshifting Darkdragon as the Miller?

TPRU, would you have let them convert Adam? Would he have still been a bomb?

Thank you. Although it was hard to prove Dar was my doing. Also, to be fair, any game where I survive past Day Three, I end up being scrutinized. This is a true Ragnarok miracle that I survived until the end, as Town and won. If the Scum had been killing or the Serial Killer didn't have me believing she was the vig for so long, I probably wouldn't have made it.

Except I would've seen you targeting Adam. I don't remember why I targeted you either. I really didn't think there'd be another day so I almost didn't even turn an Action in. I was really annoyed there was another day and then clearly even more annoyed that you were dead. Pandora, why did you choose Chromeknight to kill over me? Was it because you still thought I was Scum? Oh, that must be it. If so, then how did you decide to go after me to lynch? Was it because I was so Scummy? Or would you have tried to get me to lynch Adam had I not posted first that you were a lying Serial Killer?

One contact would've seemed less like a carnival. My first thought when seeing that two of you were pretending to be female was that there were no women on the Scum team. If only I had stuck with that five minutes later.

Some of it was trying too hard and really more of a l33t speaker, but...yes? Mencot was in everyone's crosshairs already and the first night we didn't see a Scum kill he was blocked, so naturally that had to be tested. So, good work there...but he was Scum so... And I didn't think you guys meant the kill had been blocked since you blamed it on things I had said. When I first read it I thought "So, the person blocked isn't Scum" because why would someone scream "Our kill was blocked!"? Even if they are a moron. The "your misleading comments" part of the block statement just totally confused me. So, not sure if it really matters so much how successful the Mencot–speak was or not. Since more than one person was doing it, I would say it was the weakest reason he was lynched. After he flipped Scum I thought at least one of the people had been him. I almost thought that two people were doing it to hide the fact that it was him. But that was also after he flipped Scum.