bbqqq

Best way to find Ideal / best angle in LDD

23 posts in this topic

To find an ideal / best angle or distance (2D or 3D).

I draw a quick sketch on a drawing software then let computer do the calculation.

This method get better result than just use auto hinge align tools in many case.

Make LDD model as perfect as possible. (fix all un-want but LDD allow slightly stud offset or slightly bricks collisions, gaps)

It fix all errors and collisions in my update version of 10196 Grand Carousel.(work in progress).

Make 10221 Super Star Destroyer much easier to assembly.

I would like to help anyone if you don't have this kind of software.

Of course if you good in mathematics, you can calculate by a scientific calculator or even just by pen and paper! :tongue:

Thanks to 'Bojan Pavsic's information:

"LDD works with more then 2 decimals... It only displays/rounds to 2 of them."

6162101718_2a99c6573f_z.jpg

bbqqqbbqqq_110911a by Nachapon S., on Flickr

V23RL.gif

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just complete LDD 10196 Grand Carousel with less errors (no decals, wrong roof)

This is so far the most difficult set I built by LDD.

10030 Imperial Star Destroyer is more difficult here

Harder than 10179 Ultimate Collector's Millennium Falcon.(year ago I built both set use LDD 3.x without unlock universal mode.here)

why? please see the 2nd pic.

LXF

6159106519_f0bbcccba3_z.jpg

find_bbqqqbbqqq_at_youtube_grand by Nachapon S., on Flickr

Three structure dimension are not ideal studs distance(have decimals): 14.x 25.x 35.x

This is ok to build with real brick, but you will get assembly problem in LDD when connect all of them together.

6161533475_c803ffef98_b.jpg

gran dim by Nachapon S., on Flickr

I forgot to -1 when count the studs so I correct it.

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Crikey! :wacko:

It would be good to be able to “fix” certain bricks in place and then allow other hinged parts to move freely (a FEMS implementation). Not trivial though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just complete LDD 10196 Grand Carousel with less errors (no decals, wrong roof)

This is so far the most difficult set I built by LDD.

Harder than 10179 Ultimate Collector's Millennium Falcon.(year ago I built both set use LDD 3.x without unlock universal mode.)

why? please see the 2nd pic.

LXF

6159106519_f0bbcccba3_z.jpg

find_bbqqqbbqqq_at_youtube_grand by Nachapon S., on Flickr

Three structure dimension are not ideal studs distance(have decimals)

5.0273xx 40.2187xx and 16.8995xx

This is ok to build with real brick, but you will get assembly problem in LDD when connect all of them together.

6149662650_ac082cc33e_b.jpg

grand by Nachapon S., on Flickr

I am not sure how build all those angles, if you made some calculation in advance on paper or something like that. I usually do it in tha way which is not natural with real bricks, but works easily with LDD. I mark a center of such circle. Put the a one stud brick (either 1x1 plate or 2x2 tile with stud in center) this serves as a center of rotation for hinge tool. Then I put leftmost and rightmost brick, connect them by beam accross center of rotation and rotate using hinge and by entering exact number of degrees (step is 360/number of angles - 22.5 for your largest circle). This way the result is easier to calculate and more accurate then specifying angles between neighbouring bricks (which is natural build order when working with real bricks).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Crikey! :wacko:

It would be good to be able to “fix” certain bricks in place and then allow other hinged parts to move freely (a FEMS implementation). Not trivial though.

Thanks for your comment and good idea.

I wish LDD5 will have som of these functions: http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=58396&view=findpost&p=1073211'>http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=58396&view=findpost&p=1073211

@bbbqqq: I moved your post with wanted features to this topic: http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=58396

Thanks Superkalle, I forgot that I can just make a link for what I already posted. http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=58396&view=findpost&p=1073211'>http://www.eurobricks.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=58396&view=findpost&p=1073211

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not sure how build all those angles, if you made some calculation in advance on paper or something like that. I usually do it in tha way which is not natural with real bricks, but works easily with LDD. I mark a center of such circle. Put the a one stud brick (either 1x1 plate or 2x2 tile with stud in center) this serves as a center of rotation for hinge tool. Then I put leftmost and rightmost brick, connect them by beam accross center of rotation and rotate using hinge and by entering exact number of degrees (step is 360/number of angles - 22.5 for your largest circle). This way the result is easier to calculate and more accurate then specifying angles between neighbouring bricks (which is natural build order when working with real bricks).

Thanks for your comment and share your good mathod (same way I use before). I just draw the sketch and use dimension tools to mark the angle and distances I need. The polygons one is not for to know the angles (this case angle are fixed by the parts), but for check the ideal distances. I didn't use any data on the left side for build this. We know that big structure of real brick always much more flexible than than LDD one.

In this case how to place "leftmost and rightmost" brick with a 35.1914 studs apart? Could you try to make just all main supporting structures and try to put all of them together? I found the answer: To build a fine trim/adjust-able bow compass. Then use Precision move method HERE to adjust the redious to 17.5957(35.1914 /2) Meybe I just over do this. Anyway, I think this sketch method can use in most cases not just for polygons type (sometimes no center point, different length of hinge arms).

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice topic. This method was how I made my models here, except that I did the trigonometry on paper+calculator and/or in Microsoft Excel. (Actually I've never tried the hinge align tool!) Given any right triangle, it was easy to find a triangle with all sides ~= integers by copy/pasting equations until they would yield a size that fit (<0.05 stud error).

In cases where I couldn't calculate the angle beforehand, I would rotate the side of a polyhedron until it would collide in either direction, then average the two collision angles, manually input the predicted angle (trial and error), then take the average of the two most extreme angles that LDD would accept. A completed polyhedron with no errors (doublecheck by saving, closing LDD, and reopening the file) was always a good reason to celebrate.

At other times, LDD errors could be overcome (manipulated) by adding connected hinges+plates of polygons in different sequences. The update from LDD3 to LDD4 solved a lot of the leeway though; LDD is more accurate now than it had been.

Edited by RoxYourBlox

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice topic. This method was how I made my models here, except that I did the trigonometry on paper+calculator and/or in Microsoft Excel. (Actually I've never tried the hinge align tool!) Given any right triangle, it was easy to find a triangle with all sides ~= integers by copy/pasting equations until they would yield a size that fit (<0.05 stud error).

In cases where I couldn't calculate the angle beforehand, I would rotate the side of a polyhedron until it would collide in either direction, then average the two collision angles, manually input the predicted angle (trial and error), then take the average of the two most extreme angles that LDD would accept. A completed polyhedron with no errors (doublecheck by saving, closing LDD, and reopening the file) was always a good reason to celebrate.

At other times, LDD errors could be overcome (manipulated) by adding connected hinges+plates of polygons in different sequences. The update from LDD3 to LDD4 solved a lot of the leeway though; LDD is more accurate now than it had been.

Thanks 'RoxYourBlox' for sharing you useful method and amazing works. I download them all when I saw it on the first page. They are so creative and very very impressive. I agree that the good creation not have to be most accurate.

The sketch method also work in 3D. I plan to build a LDD diamond model with standard ideal Brilliant(diamond cut)WiKi Link. I draw it to a solid model before so I can check all the angles and distances. I already post how to move LDD brick to any decimal distance in any direction x/y/z here.

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hi erm simple question :D i have plotted out and try manually calculating the angles but i got no where :( what was the computer program that you used to calculate this ? :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hi erm simple question :D i have plotted out and try manually calculating the angles but i got no where :( what was the computer program that you used to calculate this ? :D

You can use windows's calculator.

Choose View->Scientific mode.

For example the 34.92°

click [3][/][10][=] ->0.3 (3 & 10 are studs length)

then click botton [inv] then [sin^-1] = 17.457603123722092290246045792445

17.457603123722092290246045792445 x2 = 34.91520624744418458049209158489°

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

haha thanks for the prompt reply...

here's my problem >.<

i'm trying to build the super star destroyer.......

397306_10151226078216696_1491744292_n.jpg

i could work half of the angle 1 / 10 inv tan = 5.71 but couldn't work out the rest ahaha... i sucked at math :(

You can use windows's calculator.

Choose View->Scientific mode.

For example the 34.92°

click [3][/][10][=] ->0.3 (3 & 10 are studs length)

then click botton [inv] then [sin^-1] = 17.457603123722092290246045792445

17.457603123722092290246045792445 x2 = 34.91520624744418458049209158489°

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

haha thanks for the prompt reply...

here's my problem >.<

i'm trying to build the super star destroyer.......

i could work half of the angle 1 / 10 inv tan = 5.71 but couldn't work out the rest ahaha... i sucked at math :(

How long is the right edge? Angles will change with the length of it.

Could you post LDD file or pic?

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ops i forget the right edge... the value is 1.. :D

i will post an LDD image tonite once i get home :D thanks again for the reply

Edited by kcoon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ops i forget the right edge... the value is 1.. :D

i will post an LDD image tonite once i get home :D thanks again for the reply

Please try 9.52728338° & 80.47271662° (sum=90°)

This case only two free edges, so can use hinge align tool to make the angles, too.

ablqJ3.PNG

Edited by bbqqq

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the help, i still spent like 4 hours to figured it out as if i used the values provided, the front still colided ... so i read most of your tips then finally understood what you said..... manual adjusted the angles to compensate the front to the back... end up with the following values :D

https://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn1/46505_10151226719581696_392455092_n.jpg

should work now and i hope there are no more challenges to complete it ahaha :D

once again thanks

Edited by Calabar
Oversized image converted in text link (maximum size allowed is 800x600).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

Sorry to bump this topic, but I didn't want to start a new topic. Superkalle, slap me in the face if this isn't the right topic :wink:

I am designing a modular building in LDD. I run into some troubles when I want to determine the right angle (and right parts) to make an awning/porch. What's the best approach to determine the right parts (which hinges/clips etc) and the right angle? I know there are standard angles but I am not totally sure how to proceed. Any hints/tips are welcome.

22386714855_cc4a83e0a9_o.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Superkalle, slap me in the face if this isn't the right topic :wink:

Surly he would not do that,he would probably just lock you up inside one of his Ikea flat-pack wendy houses while force feeding you swedish meatballs. :laugh:

About your problem,when I "bend" parts I like to start from one side and work towards the other.

Rather that fitting a piece to the face of another part I find it easier to place them on top.

I don't know if this will help you,since I used a jumper plate to offset the connection.

th_jim_zpsynjj17rz.png

Download file

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hehe

Thanks Alasdair! That sure helps!

Did you determine the right angle by trial and error? Or are there some rules to follow?

In this case, it seems like brick building is easier to prototype.

PS your example has 4 studs between the pilars, mine has 5. How can I determine my setup?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Stupid question: do you have to connect the awning both on the wall and the pilars?

Just having it hang from the wall and stand/rest on the pilars would be simpler, easier, and would allow any width for the awning.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Silvain

I'v thought about that and it would indeed be an option to make it like a real awning.

But that feels like avoiding the problem, so I think it's better to also connect to the pilars. This would probably be the case in real life too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.