Hinckley

When???

Where's the new day??

He could scare them back in their room so they don't use their Action.

Than not then.

Go for it. You're still assuming I meant you. Your defensiveness is very telling. By all means, reveal. By the way, when people say "I wasn't trying to get someone lynched, I was just explaining why I thought the way they did" I never really find that argument valid because someone who was trying to get someone lynched would, obviously, not try to be obvious about it. That would be bad gameplay. If Kellie was trying to get me to keep my vote on Derek, I would easily give her credit to be smart enough to be coy. I would never expect her, or any Scum, to just PM and say "You should vote for ______. Goodbye now." I mean, duh, darlings.

I was definitely looking for a reaction, which you've provided, darling. Well, Kellie is here and she doesn't seem to think he's as Scummy as Caitie, though she hasn't voted for Caitie either.

Why is that so important to you?

Scum do have a tendency to get jumpy. What the hell are you even talking about? As a side note, of course the apology is accepted. Sorry if I did anything to annoy you.

Why are Timothy, Kelly and Peter just hovering around staring at us??

With as many CMFs as there are, I highly doubt we would have a double claim. I think it would help the Town more than the Scum. The Scum know enough. The more we know, the better. Random thought, probably the wine again, I don't like when people try to convince me to lynch someone in private and don't bring up the same reasoning in public. That bugs me. It "sticks in my craw." Is that a term? La la la. Wine is yummy, darlings. I'm going to unscrew another box.

Blocker is a Scummy claim? Don't Town have a blocker...99% of the time? Good point, but neither of the Faith Healers necessarily make sense with Faith Healers. They're not the Monster Angel and the Monster Preacher. Well, there's not a CMF angel...but there's that...bible salesman...and the preacher's wife. Right?

So, if I tell everyone what CMF the Faith Healers are...that helps the Scum? Something is bugging me about you this time. And a certain Scum team won in Ragnarok 2, sowing doubt by accusing each other throughout the whole thing.

My point is that Scarecrow is 10 times more monstery than what the Faith Healers have claimed. But, I'm not sure monsteriness is even worth focusing on. It just gives us all something to discuss and react to.

That's the only risk you have left if you're going to be lynched. If you're Town, you would take that risk. This is the weirdest "defense" I've seen in a while. "I can claim my role, but the Scum will probably counterclaim it and that person will be believed over me." Bull. Is there any reason to not reveal the "non-monsters" of the Faith Healers?

I have a Cyclops claim. Anyone want to counter that?

Vote: Kingsley of the Starfish (KingoftheZempk) He's pinged me and generated enough suspicion from others. Sorry if we're wrong, although I'm not sure we'll achieve a lynch today at this point.

So I have good reason but those reason don't apply to you? Maybe I'm biased because it's my reasoning, but doesn't the information presented give everyone enough reason to unvote Derek? Good reasons for one of us...should be good reasons for all of us, right? Maybe I have tunnel thinking...

Bear with me... Yes, the many plates of being Scum and appearing Town can be hard, darling. This is why I think it's safe to not have a lynch today. We do have a voting pattern to analyze. I know Caitie has been busy with Aikido, but this is also the way she played last time she was Scum. Which also closely resembles her Town game. megablocking metagaming. Pardon the French, loves. It's the wine talking. I still agree if we want to test this theory. We have three Monster roleclaims, all with non-monster Monsters. Shall I reveal the other alter egos? It might give the Scum easier fake claims. However, knowledge only helps the Town in the long run, I believe. More on that later. If we're going to lynch a bandwagoner, I feel more comfortable going with your first choice of Sally, but I'll get to that in a bit. Yes, this is noted from Melinda. I find quite the opposite. I'm not saying we should all reveal right before the Scum get to block and kill, but the sooner the Town has info to work with the more they can use it to their advantage. In a game of an informed minority, the more information the uninformed majority can glean, the better. Revealing our alter egos would do this: show who has roles and who are vanilla. Then it would be up to the Town to figure out which roles are Scum and which are Town. It may cause us to lose a few of our PRs but it also gives us a good chance of protecting and blocking the right people and giving the Scum a really hard time along the way. I actually would love to see how this would play out. Think of Bloodbrick II, Imhotep and EB Mafia II. Those were all situations that once the Town had the setup revealed the Scum couldn't get a foothold even though they were killing Masons and PRs. How gently you put it now after calling it insane ramblings earlier. It's clear what you were doing if you are Scum trying to set me up for a lynch. If you're just being rude, well then, have some coffee and maybe I'll see you at my next get together. Maybe this is how a more experienced player would react, but perhaps this is his tactic and the way he knows how to respond. If he is Town, he just has a different way of defending himself and looking for discovery than more seasoned players. That is a possibility...as well as being a lying Scum. If there's a Monster investigator out there that hasn't come forward to make sure we lynch Derek, hopefully they'll find a Monster tonight that they feel comfortable claiming to tomorrow. Right now, the risk is too big that Derek actually is our investigator. This will cause problems for him, yes. But at least he won't be dying at our hands if he is who he says he is. It's only day one, darling, but you've done plenty to set off my Scumdar. Your voting "pole position" notwithstanding, you've also started PMing me before the day was even to a full page. This means you are either Scum or Vanilla Town as I doubt a PR would put their neck out like that. You claimed you were going to be PMing a lot of people to stir things up. I hope a PR wouldn't draw that much attention to themselves. Your Scummy play coupled with the fact that if you're Town I'd imagine you're vanilla makes you a very good lynch for Day One. Even if you're a Townie and we lose you, the Scum won't be able to manipulate your polarizing game play the way they did in the last game. Great. There was also a witch doctor that resurrected the dead instead of a protector. I doubt our host played this game in college dorms, the way we did. The little Millenial was probably born in the internet age. Yes, there are lurkers hovering over the day's vote. I can hear the drool over losing a Town PR... At the same time, her character's role is "Forest Witch" so there's no telling what she meant when she "claimed". But you've been here for a long time. Following... Darling, you used a forward slash. You need to use the back slash. Darling, don't become the jerk Timothy again. Nobody likes that Timothy. Lovely, you've made me clutch my pearls. I'm not endorsing this. I already have the two Faith Healers claiming to me. I can help coordinate them. I don't advocate people claiming to one person on Day One especially since I'm not verified right now. I am a Monster, I'm not saying I'm not, but what if all the PRs come claim to me and the Scum have a conversion at their disposal? Why do you keep advocating the Town PRs claiming to someone? I concur with this. As for the other stuff you said, another cop claim would get us to definitely lynch a Scum, if not today then tomorrow. I do not think the investigator will be killed, if it's Derek or someone else who claims. There are other PRs around to stop specific players from being killed. I doubt the Scum would risk their kill for even a 50% chance of the target being protected. Ping. Yes, oops. It's always difficult when you forget to delete the part that makes you look Scummy, dear. Darling, the first time it is mentioned it is linked to a page describing it in full. So fill yourself in, love. Also, I can't tell you how much easier it would be for us to understand you, even though your are clearly posting from your phone, if you used proper punctuation and spacing. Also, try to form your thoughts into readable paragraphs like everyone else. It's hard to tell your single sentence witch "jokes" from what you actually want us to read.

What does it matter what it looks like if you are doing it for the right reasons.

I'm trying to catch up on the day, but think it's worth mentioning that both Faith Healers have alter egos that are human. They're in line with a fortune teller. So unless the Scum are risking three to save one, our Monster PRs are not very monstery, at least the three we're supposedly hearing about. Of course, there are other options than all three of them being Monsters...

Lacey, that radar will only skip you for so long. Is it bad in this situation?

I'm in a rush, but I think perhaps unvoting Derek is a good idea. Unvote: Derek Polanes (Darth Potato) I'd rather have a no lynch than vote for our investigator. If Derek is Town we have enough of a voting pattern to follow, particularly the eight people who were waiting to see what happened and not placing their vote at all. There are two faith healers, if I'm to believe the claims being made in private.

Darling, I agree with your read on Sally, but it's appallingly rude to blame this situation on me. I didn't blab a Power Role and desperately roleclaim. I've brought a viable solution to the table which has been duly ignored. You all apparently believe we are likely to have two faith healers. I would never say anything harsh to you dear, but I'm brewing coffee instead of offering you another glass of wine.

And Timothy has gone from telling us to rush to claim to Derek to saying that he could know the roles are tied to alter egos because he is actually Scum. A lot has happened today and I think those who are Town should be willing to test the information that is being discussed. Those who are gliding under the radar while this is all being discussed should be duly noted as well, darlings.