Jump to content

Hinckley

Root Administrator
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    35,896

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Hinckley

  1. Hinckley
    Didn't you tell me in private that what you said about Sally was "a soft scumtell"? What did you mean by that? Why not Sally? It makes more sense? Do you notice that she was asking everyone to claim to her in the same breath she was casting doubt on the investigator that "verified" her? How does that make sense? Is it because it's been a Town Action in my games? And did Mikatta play one of my games and have that as a one-shot Action?
  2. Hinckley
    Yes.
  3. Hinckley
    Anyone else think that Mikatta is behind the curse?
  4. Hinckley
    Don't you say at first that you don't think he's using it? Then you say "we don't know" when I ask you to clarify? Isn't it true that these two things do not match? Has something been bugging me? Didn't Timmy and I do this on purpose to see if we could gauge reactions? Did we want to see if someone over-reacted or tried to make something out of the curse? Did Derek clarify this with me in PM? Did I tell Kelly that Timmy knew I had been cursed? Isn't it true that I didn't say anything to Kelly about telling Timmy? Didn't I ask Derek if he'd been talking much with Kelly? Wasn't that after he listed people he'd been talking to and didn't mention her? Wasn't this his response? Why does Kelly then know what I said to Derek? Isn't it true that people have been claiming to Derek? Isn't it also true that not everybody has? Is it fair to say that Derek hasn't been very proactive with the information he has received?
  5. Hinckley
    Isn't your argument that he should be pleading to the people leading the lynch? Did he plead to me? Or did I contact him first? Does anybody else feel nervous lynching Bleeb? Isn't this how he behaves in every game? Saying weird things? Is this one of those we have to lynch, though, because we'll keep wondering otherwise?
  6. Hinckley
    Why not? Didn't he use it in his last game with a similar setup? Who contacted who??
  7. Hinckley
    Is this what Bleeb just said to me in private? All these Townie lynches? Haven't we just had one lynch? Is everyone else Sally is accusing a Townie then? Did I just want to make sure I wasn't posting that part of the conversation without your permission? ... should you have maybe checked with the host first before telling the whole story?
  8. Hinckley
    Are you inviting the Scum to kill you or setting me up for suspicion when you and the council decide to kill someone else tonight? What is your point? That I told you when you still didn't even believe Derek to be the investigator? What? Is Pam right about you being a better lynch? No. No. Haven't I been a perfect gentleman in private? Doesn't Kellie just have some sort of temper problem? Is Kelly trying to make something happen with the curse because it didn't have the effect they wanted it to? How would that work when someone else will inevitably be cursed tomorrow? Or is the curser a Townie? Does anyone remember me using this Action as a host? Remember the "only communicating in questions" was my favorite? Is this history repeating itself? Who in my game got this same curse? Why aren't the Faith Healers more suspicious of me? Is that something that bugs me?
  9. Hinckley
    So is an uncontested claim conclusion enough on this issue that has been bugging you so? Is this the PM I was referring to yesterday when just looking for a reaction? Does it look like she was gently nudging people in the direction of continuing to be suspicious of Derek? Or is it just Townie discussion? Didn't the conversation go in a vastly different direction after that? And then did it go in some direction where it seemed more like there was confusion from the way the host worded the role PM? Or did my verification of my role PM setup lead her to making up a silly story? Also, why is there no response to Melinda, the only person who has voted for you?
  10. Hinckley
    Why have you changed your tune? So you can claim to be investigated? Did you just go against the advice of every other player who has discussed revealing who was investigated? Furthermore, did you do an amazing flip-flop of not believing Derek to insisting he's the investigator just so you can get everyone to claim to you? Does anyone else think she's the Godfather? Will she flip-flop on whether she believes Derek is really the investigator or not next time there's a light breeze?? Is this one of the stupidest statements I've ever seen in a Mafia game? Yes. Isn't what makes you suspicious your holier-than-thou attitude and attempt to get everyone to claim to you?
  11. Hinckley
    Maybe! Isn't it distinctive that the "walk-by" vote was the hammer? Why? Where? Is this what I mentioned to several people by PM? Do I like this idea? Do I at least find it intriguing? Wasn't her attempt to get everyone to claim to her weird? Did she ask me why I'm trying to "characterize her as Scum" in private? Isn't she being weird? Why does she want us to think the Scum will be killing her tonight? Or does she want us to think she believes that?
  12. Hinckley
    Wasn't his behavior just as Scummy as the Town blocker in the last game?
  13. Hinckley
    So, why shouldn't you be lynched?
  14. Hinckley
    Do you think the Scum would broadcast who they were going to kill by accusing them?
  15. Hinckley
    All this?
  16. Hinckley
    So what? Is it good or bad that the lurkers are voting for Bleeb?
  17. Hinckley
    Isn't there a difference between going idle and actively lurking? Aren't Peter, Pam and Lacey all kind of just hovering around here? No. No. Do I think I should look that over?
  18. Hinckley
    Hasn't it been 24 hours? Can't we vote now? Does it make sense to Vote: Bleeb (Bob)? Isn't it weird that he hammered Kingsley with little explanation yet tries to blame the whole thing on Timothy today? Doesn't it seem like he wanted a dead townie to try to get Timothy lynched? Why is it so quiet? Haven't a lot of people told me in private they would vote for Bleeb? Why is everyone waiting to vote? Does it bother anyone else that people keep saying the roleclaims we've heard must be real because the Scum wouldn't risk three to save one? If they did risk that haven't they succeeded in keeping all three safe at this point? How do you verify an investigator? Is an un-contested claim enough?
  19. Hinckley
    Aren't you changing what you said? Why are you talking about if people trust you when you clearly were talking about Derek the first time?
  20. Hinckley
    What the difference between believing the claim and trusting him? Isn't your part done? Haven't you claimed your alter ego to everyone?
  21. Hinckley
    What was so frustrating about our private conversation?
  22. Hinckley
    Why am I the only person you've claimed to if you're still acting somewhat dodgy in private?
  23. Hinckley
    Aren't we forgetting something? Don't the Scum already know who the Town are? Isn't soft claiming handing them a target? Haven't we already given them more info that makes them even more informed than we are now? Is it possible that Kellie threw her little "megabluck you" fit yesterday because she's frustrated from having to read the Scum writeboard and all of this and appear Town? Could that be why she was feeling so much pressure that she had to flip out? Is the term "Scum Perspective" really trademarked?
  24. Hinckley
    Shouldn't we have two Faith Healers and no Doctor this time? Maybe.
  25. Hinckley
    Yes!! Isn't she saying she doesn't believe the claimed investigator? Doesn't that mean nobody should be confirmed at this point?
×
×
  • Create New...