-
Posts
1,643 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by Piratedave84
-
CMF Mafia - Day 3 - The Mermaid's Song
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Tickles hasn't done shit yet point final (at all) To substanciate the above statement, here are Tickle's day 1 posts: An thus ended Day 1 without Tickle casting a valid vote. I see a lot of fluff, zero direct accusation, a lot of summarizing and repeating Day 2's "contributions": Yeah ... still no vote here. -
CMF Mafia - Day 3 - The Mermaid's Song
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
If you are/were so suspicious of me, why did you not vote for me in your last post? Why do you not now put together an accusation instead of copying selected, out of context, posts? Yes, by elliminating one! For the record and in case you don't remember here is your last post which is also the very first time you mention my name; if you were suspicious of me, you sure made it haard for us to tell. -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
How would you not know of Derek's trust in Helen? Helen relayed the result to you, is that not a big enough statement of trust for you? Seriously!? How convenient!! -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Which one? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Which one? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
So you knew of your results, knew of Derek seemingly unwavering trust in Helen and still opted to call out Helen and bicker? Why? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Interesting, very interesting. Since you are just now mentioning this, I'm going to say that it would be your most recent claim; Giovanni's? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
What? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Lete take out the question mark: Who is "we" in the first paragraph!!!! *let me -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Dead? Blocked? Investigated a council member and is unwilling to expose him/herself? Etc ... Why not? The same argument you made above in that there are no counterclaims could empower the scum to be bold and make that risky move. Not just to clear the mess, that's the lesser argument, I'm hoping to clear the cop or catch scum. Yay! Thanks for sharing. Now what can you add to the discussion? What are your thoughts on the lynch candidates? Who are your main suspects? CONTRIBUTE! -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Who is "we" in the first paragraph? It's interesting that you say Melinda is trying to convince you to lynch Kelly; in my conversation he seems somewhat hesitant to re-vote for her. -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
So if we find out that Kelly is town, you still won't trust the cop? What might have prompted Helen to distrust Kelly even though she was 'confirmed' as town? It seems we're missing a piece of the puzzle What if Bleeb turns up to be town? What then, how does that help us more? What I am trying to say is that there is a lack of trust in the investigator/investigation result so we should test the claim. -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Why do you not trust Helen? or rather why would Helen not trust you? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Wouldn't Kelly's lynch also give us half decent results? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Lacey, I have now seen you pop in and out at least 4 times today. Do we need to be worried? What do you think of the current lynch prospects? do we need to accuse you or put you on the block for you to speak up? Scum. -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
I suggested Bob's lynch to Helen, she beat me to the initial vote. I still think we could lynch Bob but I am tired of hearing speculations on Helen, Kelly and Derek's allegiance, we need to settle this once and for all. What other plan do you suggest? How is it counterproductive; what are the possible (negative) repercussions (besides loosing a vanilla)? What if Derek is scum and 'confirming' his scum buddies? What then? Do we wait for them to steamroll us? Our cop is parcticaly invisible, we need to take matters in our own hands and get to the bottom of this. -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Unvote: Bleeb (Bob) Why? Because it does not sit well with me that the vote picked up steam so fast. Let's face it, Bleeb's vote was shit, his justification was very poor and his subsequent deflection of the accusations was sort of scummy. This being said, whomever would have cast that last vote would also be under scrutiny today and would probably have crumbled under the pressure as well. There is also some truth in the fact that Bleeb merely voted whereas Timmy was the one pushing hard, very hard for King's lynch. We know what Bleeb did and if needs be we can re-visit it later or we can ask the vig to whack him tonight. Here is what I am suggesting: We should lynch Kelly Why? Because it would 1) Enable us to 'confirm' our investigator (to an extent) 2) Settle whatever feud exists between Helen and her. Derek seems to trust Helen whom appears to trust him back but Kelly and Helen do not trust each other. Something is amiss here Derek trusted Helen enough to have her relay the information about the investigation result so why would Kelly not trust the person whom indirectly cleared her? The way I see this is win-win; we either lose a vanilla townie but 'confirm' our investigator or catch scum (possible godfather?) I know this is bold and I am more than willing to deal with the Flak resulting from this tomorrow, but we need to settle the Derek/Helen/Kelly thing before we can move on. As such Vote: Kelly Lester (Kristel) sorry darling but your sacrifice is IMO what is best for us at this point. -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Stop with the metagaming, it amounts to zero valid contribution; you're comparing hosts, games and behaviours and it litterally amounts to nothing. You are definitely causing confusion by saying those things. your lack of valid contributions and addiction to metagaming make me very uneasy about you. -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
I'm really starting to feel uneasy about the Bleeb lynch, it seems too easy; unanimous lynches are rarely a good thing. When I told Helen that I intended to vote for Bleeb (beofre voting was open) I did not think it would gather that much steam this quick. I asked Derek and Helen in private but got nowhere, so I will ask here; Derek why did you opt to confirm Kelly via Helen, whos is not confirmed, rather than contact Kelly directly? I find your apporach to have been flawed, can you explain your logic? Does anyone else feel like we should test the investigation result? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
How does this fit in your plan of voting for Helen? obviously the cop trusts Helen as he opted to reveal your investigation result to her instead of to you directly so why are you still holding your vote against Helen? Where are we going? -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
I am getting worried about the lack of contribution from Derek today. LOL he made a very good post on day one, it was actually pertinent and somewhat made sense! -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
No -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Helen is lurking, she has been here for 10 minutes and has not said anything, quick give her grief over it! -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
Nothing, it's just something I stumbled upon, could mean something .. or it could not. Should we not explore leads, small or insignificant as they may be. Correct me if I'm wrong but I thought this was how you catch scum -
CMF Mafia 2 - Day 2 - Special Delivery
Piratedave84 replied to TrumpetKing's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
I'm going to Vote: Bleeb (Bob) for reasons outlined previously. Whilst reviewing the day one thread I also found this: He's the only one to ever mention (from what i could see at a quick glance) Caitie's name and she turned up dead.