Hinckley

Well, if we do have another investigator feeding info to Petey, I would imagine they would've come forward by now. Somebody has to have that night action to have uncovered Ted's file is missing.

I don't list you as a suspect because I believe your story. As you stated, how else would you know that Ted has no file. Perhaps we should try to use that picture we got from Dr. Rajim. Honor him for sacrificing his life by getting to the bottom of the picture his life provided for us...

Is it possible that the investigation results show no file for Sinister? I think it is clear that Ted is, at the very least, neutral. He can't have good intentions for us if that is the case. He says his night action works neither for the Sinister nor the Insane, so he's very clearly out for himself. If we can't reach a decision on any of the other suspicious folks, he's probably our best bet. I'm sure we can't win survive if there's anything but Insane left at the end. Have we forgotten about the blue arm? There are two possibilities left for the blue-armed killer. I don't think "I encouraged everyone to follow Petey's investigation results" is a good defense for Mr. Nowhere anymore. If he was Sinister, of course he would encourage us to vote off the King. Then perhaps he killed Bear that night. Maybe Petey trusted Mr. Nowhere with his night action and in return Mr. Nowhere said "Yahoo! I can use this information to my advantage and get King and Bear killed off. Everybody trusts them, how else could we get rid of them." Blue arm and a perfect position to fake us all out. But, the yellow hand... Nuts. Tim Tam? He could be the killer. Professor Diem has a black arm... Ugh, I hate this. It's all so confusing. I almost don't even want to look at that damn picture anymore...

If it's on the fig, that's fine. Just because it's the angle of the body. I don't want to see anybody putting an entire house on a fig's head. Thanks! Nice adjustment too. Don't forget: the rules state that your first picture posted in the entry thread will be the picture used in the voting thread, so make sure your first pic is what you want! Great work so far, guys. I love the creativity going into these.

They can and have. I just hope they can't do both in one night. I doubt they could. If they could, Salvatore would definitely be their best target. But, can't we find a sinister before assuming Sal is one? It's quite a stretch to go after him until we start finding others. I thought I said I was taking a break.

Traditionally, (metagame on) a Sinister shouldn't be able to kill and convert in the same night. That would give them too much of an advantage (on top of the one they already have) to reduce innocent numbers while increasing their own in one night. (metagame off) Of course, in our case we seem to be doing a fine job reducing our own numbers for them.

Is that better?

The theory is crazy and voted off a verified innocent isn't going to help us. There's been a death every night since Martin investigated Salvatore. They can't have converted Salvatore in that time. We should have a moment of silence for the fallen. Havel Pavlov Poor sad Havel. He must've been so scared being dragged off to his death all alone. He died such a noble death, wishing us luck and hoping we would find the people responsible for this whole situation. It's so unfortunate that we lost such a gentle soul. He will be greatly missed and I hope we get the monsters who are behind all of this. Dr. Rajim He was the best doctor and such a great friend to all of us. He was so helpful, risking his life to follow people at night and boldly show the results. I hope we get the monsters that did this to him. He was a good man and I hope we can avenge his death. Tam Tam Timmers Um...He wasn't much help, was he? Didn't really say much, but losing an innocent is a bad thing. Condolences Tim Tam. Farewell to the fallen...

*bangs head against the wall* Why is everybody something in this game? Yeah, I said game, deal with it. Dr. Blutziegel can we please please please see the camera? Please? Pretty please with non-hospital food on top? Please????? Oh, you are? Why didn't you just say so? OK, never mind. She's Insane everybody, don't vote for her. I need to take a break from this. I'm about to turn over the tables of the money-changers at the temple, if you know what I mean.

I trust Pendleton way more than I trust Ballbricker. It'd be nice to vote out Ballbricker and Pendleton tonight. Dr. Rajim did plan to follow Dr. Ballbricker last night. Why don't we take that camera out of his hand and develop the film??? Dr. Blutzieg! Dr. Blutzieg! We need the camera! Get the camera!!!

Thank you for putting that together for us. For me, it takes away any suspicion. Now, the only thing we have to find out is why Ted can't be ... actioned ... at night. In these games ... of life ... that doesn't necessarily mean he's one allegiance or another. I would assume the reason his file can't be found would be because he's Sinister. Why would an innocent Insane get rid of his file? I'm leaning towards a vote for Ted Tompkins. Thank you Petey for keeping a level head. Without Dr. Rajim, you're our only hope for finding information. I was blocked yet again. I have not been able to use my night action yet. I'm sure the Sinister will go after the two of us in the next two nights. We have to start finding them. I'd rather prove my innocent by surviving to the end and not by being autopsied after being found hung upside down in a closet. Another independent? A serial killer? Are you the one who killed Sparky Trunks?

OK, this is impossible. I have no idea what's going on. I admit going after Petey or Mr. Nowhere is a great idea. But I've been more suspcious of Ted all along and his defense is weak, at best. I'm really tired of sending innocents to their deaths.

Isn't Professor Binns, History of Magic a ghost? Aha, yes. Oops, never mind. Now I've seen Cutlass IZ's entry, I understand Apparition. Duh. Sorry! IZ, you're going to kill me, but those wood tiles are overhang. Sorry, a rule is a rule. Please revise that for the entry to be valid. My name is Hinckley and it's my job to crush creativity.

If it doesn't help us solve anything, it's just talking LEGO. Does it help us solve anything?

The day before it was ThePenguin:

It's been part of the plan all along that people can uproxy at any time. I'm keeping mine for now so we can test Petey's claims. I think that's the only way to make progress. Who would we vote for otherwise at this point? I'm keeping my vote with Havel for now, but encourage anyone who feels differently to vote their conscience.

He got "not insane" for Shadows. Don't freak out, dude... It's not going to help anything.

No, if that was my reason, I would've said so.

Your grammar is what I was correcting. It's not would of, it's would have. Same with wouldn't. It's not wouldn't of, it's wouldn't have...

...would have... And, that's not proof there, professor.

Oh, OK. Never mind then. Thanks for the info.

One other possibility is that Mr. Havel is so convincing because he's being coached by an expert. There was plenty of time between his posts and the first post and the original accusations for him to have coached by a devious and experienced scumbag. Ugh, this is insane...

OK, you guys, we have 15 hours to discuss what we're hearing from Havel. If he's Sinister, he's an amazing persuader. He's right that the Sinister would easily proxy to Sal if we were voting for one of our own. But, they have the advantage and they're playing chicken with us. Defying the plan would out them too easily. Perhaps they are willing to sacrifice one of their number for the proxy plan not to work. But if we take out any of the inactive, who would it be? And if we're wrong, we're back to Petey's ability and if it works or not and we'd have to kill Havel to find that out anyway, which would leave us back where we started. We're kind of stuck testing Petey's ability, just like we were stuck voting for King yesterday to test what Mr. Nowhere was telling us. If we're going to vote somebody else, and go for one of the inactive, who would it be? Dr. Ballbricker (Ricecracker) Ted Nathan Tompkins (Whitefang) 'Tamtam Timmers', Spacetwin #2 (Quarryman) Misty 'Mrs' Monroe (badboytje88) Dudley Eisenhower (MrLegoNinja) Cookie Custer (Roncanator) We've suspected them all before and they all fly pretty well under the radar. They've all escaped the vote or, for the most part, answering for themselves or their lack of activity. As for "having everyone wrapped around my thumb," I'm well aware I'm not likely to live through the night and if we don't start convicting Sinisters soon, to be voted out sooner rather than later. It's not the safest spot I've put myself in here...

Jesus Christ, this will really suck if you're not Sinister. You don't sound sinister, but what else would you say if you were? It's so unfortunate that Petey has claimed he has a power and the only way of testing it is to kill you. I'm so sorry. And I don't blame you for being suspcious of me, I would be too if I were you. I feel we've been sidetracked the last two days by investigation claims. What were we planning on doing before Scouts came around and suggested King and then Petey came around and suggested Havel? It might be a good idea to look back at where we were headed. If it turns out Petey and Mr. Nowhere are lying to us, we should look closely at what they were throwing us off track. No hard feelings Petey and Mr. Nowhere, we have to look at all angles.

No worries. This appears to be your first game...of life...and the type of evidence you're looking for doesn't usually exist unless handed to somebody. So, while they're great points for investigation, they won't come around until someone with a night action uncovers them or maybe not at all. Our job is mostly to discern from behavior who is lying and who is telling the truths and that is what a mafia game life is all about.