Hinckley

No Night Actions? So the Scum don't have a kill? So, we need to vote to lynch one another instead of taking a trip down to sick bay to retrieve our tricorders? Whatever the hell they are.

Hi! Lieutenant Commander Scott reporting for duty! Romulans, eh? No clues anywhere, huh? Well, well. Looks like I read the rules.

I'll give it a (quick) shot. I'm hilarious.

I get it, too. I'm just incapable of it...purposely, anyway. I'm always the Scummiest when I'm Town somehow.

That Scum Board is fantastic. You guys were having a ton of fun. @Khscarymovie4, your Scum game was solid. If @Trekkie99 hadn't played his tracker role perfectly ( ) you would've had a solid shot at winning. Trekkie, you claimed at the right time. That was a gutsy move but it was pro-Town and informative and I was impressed with how you played your cards. Well done. Well done, everyone. Even @KotZ ! And no hard feelings at all. I was shocked to learn I had been lynched when I got home from the bars that night. Just drunk and angry about it. I did curse your name...and your soul. It's my fault, in the long run. I missed the vote on Day One. As I said in the confirmation thread, I wouldn't be very active. It was during Brickworld Chicago...which I just bought (also, )...but I should've remember to at least place a joke vote. And then I insulted @Sir Stig. So, all things I can learn from. @Sandy's vote? Whatever. He's always always Scum. No regrets there.

Go Town!! Great game, Kintobor. Thanks for letting me play. @Sir Stig Sorry if I hurt your feelings. I was only referring to a conversation we had during The Forest 3 where you mentioned you needed to brush up or weren't used to something or were out of practice, or I don't know. But I based whatever I said off of a feeling I got from your own analysis of your game. I hate being lynched as Town! Stupid penalty votes. Stupid life getting in the way. Stupid @KotZ! I still think @Sandy is Scum.

Mystery games should not take months. Some of them just did. The key is hosting. I did two rambling mysteries. If I had setup the map and the puzzles better, they would've run more smoothly. I used a different type of informed minority game for the second game. In my opinion, mystery games should run like escape rooms, but be a series of rooms instead of a series of puzzles in one room. There's no reason it shouldn't take the same amount of time as a Mafia game if the players invest a bit of time to solve each puzzle or series of clues.

Are you guys not able to quote from locked topics? @Kintobor, I can unlock the previous day threads, if that's the case.

Thank you for letting me play, @Kintobor! Go, whichever team I am on!

In a game this small, we may all be vanilla Townies. Except the Scum, of course. Here are my reasons for voting for Kylo again: 1. Speaking from the Scum perspective on why Daphne was killed. Yes, not a smart move, but we've seen a slip like that before. When LEGODad killed def in the Tree Mafia, I think. 2. He said a lot without really adding anything to the conversation–a typical Scum tactic. 3. He voted for me for being aggressive when I wasn't, things like this are magnified when you're in Scum mode. 4. He, along with Raphael, who is also being super susp, are taking advantage of the penalty votes on me Reasons against lynching Kylo: 1. I swear I've said all these things before about him, in previous games, and he's turned out to be Town. So, that's metagaming, but his Town game is typically Scummy.

There is evidence out there, if you're not too dense to find it, that I predicted I wouldn't be around much on Day One. Even if you're not illiterate you may find me giving an explicit explanation for my absence in this very thread. Your vote is stupid. My vote may also be stupid. Who can tell? I don't feel confident leaving you in a hammerable position. I know I shouldn't be either, but let's pay attention who took advantage of my penalty votes. Ah shit, you're one of them. I was going to unvote you. Ugh. I don't know. Maybe you are the best candidate. If I get hammered, which would be lame, and only the third time I was lynched as a Townie, but you would–as Kylo also claims–only be losing a vanilla Townie. And I'm not sure how helpful I've really been anyway. But remember, the choice to lynch me would lay on 3 people only, which again, is super lame. My bet would be that at least one of them is Scum. But would it be the hammer? Or are the Scum usually afraid to hammer. Your WIFOM has been served prematurely. Choke on it.

Sorry, Admiral Piett, but I'm not rallying anyone, anywhere. For the record, I'm unconvinced you're the best vote. But, there isn't a solid case on anyone, only gut feelings to go around. I don't feel confident about my vote, at all, and I would not encourage anybody to follow my lead at the moment.

Dude, sweet. I get two votes! And all the votes against Black Canary don't count. What crazy game mechanics!

Um...no... What's with the Russian Roulette voting? I know you don't have a lot of Mafia experience, but this behavior isn't helping anyone. unvote: Egon Spangler (Bob) but I'm not sure which of the current candidates I feel have the best case against them. I was leaning towards Kylo Ren because he has weak-ass reasons for voting for me. Don't want it to look like an OMGUS, though. Eh, what the hell? Vote: Kylo Ren (Sandy) for knowing the Scum motivation for killing Daphne and for voting for me...because I'm aggressive? When I haven't even begun to aggress yet. Plus, I was easy to vote for since I already have two penalty votes. At least I think so if @Kintobor would post a vote tally for us!

Can a gal get a vote tally, please? @Kintobor

Oh no!!!! Whatever will I do?? I'm on Raphael's deflection radar!!! Someone help!

Where's @Bob?

Ah, I see. You think I'm pulling a "Scubacarrot."

I just realized that Daphne meant she's a detective in cosplay. Still, and again, it wasn't her reaction I was worried about. It was the weird fishing expedition from Bobbo that pinged me. And as far as you being damned if you speak and damned if you don't... what? First of all, I'd be much happier if you didn't speak, because you never say anything. Your Town game is always Scummy, but voting for someone because "You're damned if you speak and damned if you don't..." how would that make me Scum exactly? Annoying you doesn't make someone Scummy. Voldemort or Sirius Black or whoever the hell Sandy is, because his signature still says Admiral Piett, is pinging me twice today now. First, she gives us reasoning for why the Scum killed Daphne, now she's placed a vote because...she doesn't like my questions? Not that I'm Scummy, but that my behavior is obnoxious. Doesn't seem pro-Town...however, I've gotten him lynched in the past for similar behavior and he's turned up Town. I usually find the more aggressive players Scummy, too. Wait, no I don't. And what have I done that's so "aggressive?" Questioned you? Gee, sorry I'm such a tyrant. That's more sarcasm, in case you wondered.

I never said Chromeknight softclaimed, nor would I ever suggest he would be stupid. What I'm saying is the Scum may have flown off their handles about him responding to the word detective. I've found Trekkie's behavior weird, I think Sandy always plays Scummy, and yes that's metagaming but the odd way Bob got to saying "detective" in the first place, a weird and almost forced list of three in order to say the word of a known Mafia role leads me to suspect him the most. Maybe that's dumb, so maybe I'm dumb. Vote: Egon Spangler (Bob)

Please, tell us more about why the Scum killed Daphne. Sounds like you've got a pretty good idea about what they might have been thinking.

We don't even have new names to learn... A magical post: there are words spoken, but nothing is really said.

I'm only saying maybe the comment got her killed. The mention of detective twice caught my attention.

So, I was wrong. It wasn't @jimmynick who responded to Bob's mention of detective, it was Chromeknight. And then Chromeknight ended up dead, after voting for Trekkie. So, there's all of that... Perhaps the Scum thought Chromeknight was mentioning detective to connect with Bob, or I don't know, that seems dumb, but it did stand out to me. Here are the posts I'm referring to: I wish I would've looked those up and posted them before accusing @jimmynick

Thanks! I like not being lynched. My second guess was right. So, looking for the vig?