Hinckley

There's so many ways to try and discuss things. If you really work on it, there's ways to discuss without potentially giving away that it is your pill. Did you even consider that? Yes, great points about a person being unkillable and unlynchable, but this early in the game, the Scum may really not want that powerful pill to fall in their hands twice. Perhaps you meant for the Scum to stay away from it but then lazy-pants Snake Charmer couldn't muster the energy to pick a pill, so he got stuck with it. And my point remains: where was your help in getting us two solid lynches? Your only contribution was defending yourself and then slinking back into the grey baseplate.

The Cultist died with a Downer. I will check your spreadsheet against mine when I get a chance. Nice work compiling all of that. I have The Riot Pill down as a Placebo. I forget how I knew that... How does it not give them an unfair advantage? Did you discuss the decision with anyone and did you actively help us try to reach two good lynched that day? That's probably the most damning thing against you and the way you used the God Pill. You forced us to lynch two players and then did nothing to voice any opinion about who should be lynched or even attempt to achieve some clarity on the lynch candidates. You kind of just sat back and watched and only answered to accusations aimed at you. Scummy... Or it's what you want us to believe. Anyone here can read Bloodbrick II where the Scum team tried to keep pills amongst themselves and failed and that took out half of the team. I doubt the Scum team, who must have at least one experienced player, would allow that to happen again.

Because none of those rules are good for the Town. And you picked the worst one. Even if we couldn't come up with two lynch candidates, what if we had a situation where it was a Scumbag's word against a Townie's word? Some people would agree with one and other people the other and even if the truth came out, both would've been lynched. Besides that, you wouldn't want the God Pill back in Scum hands because once the Town figured out what it did, the pattern would be easily seen.

Caught that. Thanks.

No, I was right. It's already gone. Why would you want that specific pill? Did you even check the list that the werewolf posted?

What? That's why I'm fake voting. We need a solid candidate though. If we lynch Darth Potato, we're guaranteed a Scum. Even removing the lifesaver pill, that's worth it, because we know we won't lose a Townie and The Serious Roleplayer is protected for the night. If we're 100% on someone else being Scum, by all means, let's lynch someone else, let The Snake Charmer invent something he won't be able to give out the following night and keep the lifesaver pill in play. The Snake Charmer can't pick The Fairy Tale Pill again tomorrow and the God Pill can't be lynched out, so, yes. I like the plan, as I already stated. I just don't hear any other solid cases just yet.

I appreciate your viewpoint. It would be a gutsy Scum to blatantly question the plan. The Cult Leader questioned it too and it's pretty obvious he's Town. A devil's advocate is necessary for a plan like this. This doesn't make you definite Town, but you're not Scum for questioning the plan. The plan is a bit reckless and needed to be talked through. Damn it. I have in my list that that pill died with The Jester. Something must be off. This game is time-consuming. Your defense, however, was noted and it isn't a solid defense. The Scum, especially those with prior experience, would be likely to advise each other to not obviously take all the good pills so that a pattern would not emerge. So... sorry.

I missed this earlier. Male Lover contacted Vanilla Townie by PM when she expressed that she was suspicious of him in thread.

It's First Day Lynch. At least that's what my spreadsheet told me. Then I realized that I had accidentally written his Day One vote in the role column. But, eery, isn't it? If he were the Serial Killer, I'd want to shake his hand for doing a great job being undetected. Sorry if that's not really helpful. I just woke up. Yes, we know your religion. Double, double, toil and trouble, eye of newt and all that. I'll be doing something equally morally upstanding, saving orphans from a fire or something. What a weird post. I'm finally taking some time to go over these pills in my own spreadsheet. The other Upper is missing. Whoever is not revealing their pills is Scum. Chances are the Scum know which it is and I'm really afraid that either their blocker or killer have it. We have to figure out who has the pill they're not revealing so our Town blocker knows who to target.

Male Lover voted for The Stump on Day One as well...

Doesn't that get under your skin? I didn't like it either. I doubt the Scum would be dumb enough to try and keep pills amongst themselves, but it's not pretty. To be fair, Cult Leader accuse and voted for Snake Charmer on Day One for defending The Serial Killer. Obviously, it was a good call. Naturally, he would try to get the same pill Snake Charmer took the next day to see if he was up to something or could've done something with it. The Male Lover was probably trying to pick a new pill and stay outside of the group as not to incriminate others. As it stands, Cult Leader is our Town Inventor.

I was just reminded that The Goon originally proposed the idea I brought up today. I didn't remember him saying that and I swear it all entered my brain organically. Sorry, Goon. You know I think you're a genius.

Congratulations, Talking Animal. The Snake Charmer was trying to get the pistol recipient to either kill me or you. We're so Scummy finding Scum. The pistol recipient should just reveal his damn self since the Scum know who he is anyway. How does anyone feel about lynching: The Tree Stump The Witch Anyone else who has been Scummy that I'm missing?

Stop using acronyms please. It's already enough to try to remember who's who and the pills, etc... How hard is it to type Snake Charmer? My brain is a bit taxed... fakevote: Snake Charmer (DarthPotato) Fake in case we decide to try and save that lifesaver pill.

We have a common enemy. Let's try to get him to stop killing Townies in the mean time. The Snake Charmer, via Potato, originally told me that he chose the 75% majority lynch rule so that we could easily lynch The Paranoid Gun Owner. Make of that what you will. But he loses if the Scum win. They have to outnumber him to win...which they already do.

My pill was what The Jester told me was one of The Uppers. Just wanted to keep it out of Scum hands.

Let's kill The Snake Charmer and take out the lifesaver. Easy as that. Scum, you have to lynch your own today. Unless you just want to hand your names over right now. Which you can. Unkillable Serial Killer, we want to work with you. I'm going to go balls out and say contact me. I'll make sure you have a fair shot at winning. I'm a good sport. I like the game. Let's work together. We could really use your help. You know you want to! Come on. Do something different. Have some fun. I don't see that yet, but I like the confidence level.

Wait! Doi oi oi oi oi oi oi oi! We can lynch The Snake Charmer!! Are the Scum going to save him just by exposing themselves? The only way to save him from the lynch is for the Scum team not to vote. Then all we have to do is pick off the people who don't vote for him. There, I feel better now.

Good for you. Of course you chose the rule that made a lynch of a Scum impossible. Any lynch at this point would be impossible. Unless we find one and you guys try to bluff us into unvoting by voting for him or her too. So, werewolf, one of the God rules makes a lynch of a Scum impossible, huh? So, what do we do with the rest of the day?

I thought only Town had Universal Backup and the Scum could swap their Action for the Action of the lynched or night-killed jerk. I mean Scum. I'm starting to think this way too. How do we get 12 votes with 10 - 5 - 1 ?

Tells us nothing because The Snake Charmer never votes. Would the Scum try to stop 75% majority vote for The Snake Charmer? That would really make things obvious. Well, the Scum know who has the pistol. Wonder when we should try to ask him to use that.

We can't let Rufus have lunch? That doesn't sound fair, but it is something to consider. Do you guys want to lose the lifesaver pill? They'll probably steal the God pill from us tomorrow. Time to take time to update a spreadsheet here. And let's look at those voting patterns again.

We don't lynch Cult Leader, he's probably the Town Inventor. It's a safe claim since he's bulletproof, so his bristliness is probably true annoyance, sorry to say. Unless the pistol recipient, Snake Charmer and Cult Leader are all Scum, I think it's safe to say that Cult Leader is our Town inventor. As far as not lynching Snake Charmer, I just posted that above.

Well, if you are the Inventor, all you can do tonight is make an invention anyway, so we won't even have to waste a block on you. We'll get you tomorrow, don't worry. We'll get one of your Scum buddies today. Way to try to suck up to somewhat of an inexperienced Townie with your Invention. Nice try.

Infectious Pill Pistol Recipient says that Snake Charmer claimed Inventor.