Hinckley

When I host, I don't give info to roles that died during the Night. That's just me, though. And again, if they have ways of finding info (rolecop, tracker) then they can get info that we wouldn't know. So it's possible the Stumps claiming could benefit us. That's a possibility. Where's our in-depth analysis of who Alastair was in cahoots with?

And if the Scum have a rolecop, then they know who they're killing and we don't. What do you think of that?

Same type of flag I got for you subtly undermining the Alastair vote. It's a fair suspicion. Let's tell everyone: I feel that Bruce is an Oak. Feel better? Correct. As mentioned, it may only last one game day or have other limitations.

How?

Gut instinct.

I believe Bruce is an Oak. And I never cast doubt on people when I have strong evidence. When I have strong evidence I write a play and reveal it in dramatic, narcissistic fashion.

You don't know how to spell "too". And it's not too complicated. It's perfectly reasonable. There are many other situations where the stumps might not be aware of who is claiming what behind the scenes. And if the vig came to me right now, I wouldn't come right out and say it. There are many factors involved in handling claims. Sorry, I didn't realize you were such an expert in the "so easy" ways of catching Scum, but I don't think you've thought that idea all the way through. Your resistance to the option of them claiming is suspect. Where???? Read it again, Sammy! Either you're looking too far into it or manipulating it purposely. I wasn't convinced of anything. If it seemed that way, you're either putting it on there yourself or I'm not very good at explaining myself. If that's the case, I apologize. But look at my first two pages of posts again. I have no idea why you think I was "pushing for" or "convinced" of anything.

I am pretty sure you are Scum. Many posts? Look back. Everybody, look at my posts. I had two posts about the possibility of janitor. You're not even building an accurate case, Scummy-pants. You can't lie when the truth is still there in black and white. I talked about the janitor for two posts and all of my conclusions are if-based, possibilities. The rest I am talking about deaths and speculating about who killed who and well, go look. You can all see for yourselves. Scum PerspectiveTM magnifies everything and our Scummy Sycamaple has succumbed to the pressures. So sad you revealed yourself this way. I didn't even accuse you with my janitor speculation. It's a pretty solid, "if this is the case, Sammy might be Scum" but your OMGUS reaction to that makes me think I was onto something.

Meaning they could've janitored Alastair to make us unsure about his alignment (or even think he's an Oak, which Sammy Scumamore seems to want us to believe) which would keep the suspicion on Bruce. That's a possibility to consider. Not something I'm pushing for.

YEs, good point! And maybe, assuming Bruce is Town, they wanted to try to get him lynched since there was some momentum towards that yesterday. Good thinking, Jack Pine.

So Oaks don't want to know if we've lost any power roles?? Let's say Loren or Buck were the investigator. Then the Scum came to one of us pretending to be the investigator and we had no way of knowing they were Scum and they infiltrated a Town block and killed off all of our power roles. Doesn't the information about what roles they might've had benefit us more than the Maples? I remember a super smart Scum who did just that in a forest called Valhalla. He was devilishly handsome and he killed everybody. Really really really smart guy. And devilishly handsome. And really really really smart.

Aren't you an Oak? (pronoun tell: he should've said "us" ) But what makes you think it's "probably false"?

Where did I "push hard" Mr. Scum-so-everything-is-magnified. I wondered about you but now I'm feeling I'm onto something with as strongly as you're reacting. If you're Town, I'm insulted you think my Scum game would be to blatantly contradict myself to get rid of the power-player-Catrina. An Oak's job is to weigh all options. Maples would probably like us not to weigh all options. Did you slip by pushing too hard and now you have to stick to it? Luke!?

I don't know Scummy Sycamore. This doesn't sound conclusive to me: Sounds like it was still speculation. Maybe you were hoping you could get me lynched with it, but I'm pretty sure I was still weighing all options, while leaning towards one. Well hell, I know that's what I was thinking. Anything more, Mr. Maple? Just as I was speculating about your alignment, which is why I was still sending you potatoes.

Didn't I? So, what are you suggesting? You think I'm a Maple because I weighed all of my options...(cue dramatic music)...after two pages? *oh2*

Maybe they thought he was likely to be protected. You tell me, Maple! I'm sorry I'm considering all options. Does that annoy you, Scummy? Bristle bristle bristle bristle. You co-hosted it. yourself.

I might be so why are you laughing?

I would definitely wait to talk to the elder. I have to admit...this tree stump thing might make it really hard for the Maples. Yes, yes, we all hate the Maples, but we want a fair game. I should not comment on game mechanics, sorry. This went quiet really fast and there are a lot of people lurking...

Hi Maple! Where's your helpful analysis?

By all means, help. I'm very eager to hear your research and analysis into who Alastair aligned himself with on Day One.

Yet, you clearly understood the result. Maybe your Scum buddies janitored the Town Alastair because you went too far to try to accuse him and his alignment reveal would've incriminated you too much! Everyone said it would be very interesting to see what he flipped considering how hard you went after him. It's really convenient that it tells us nothing about you now, isn't it?

Why don't you get on that for us? A little eager to go with one solution, huh? Trying to force us to find leads that aren't true because you and your Maple buddies janitored an Oak? And don't forget, I said Sammy was trying to undermine my confidence in the Alastair vote in private. If Alastair is Scum, doesn't that make Sammy highly suspicious, Catarina? Catarina is out new Oak expert. She's so anti-Maple.

You're going down too, you Scummy megablocks-kisser. I already said all that. Trying too hard to not understand a janitor. Also Scum. This is getting too easy. Scum are lining up to reveal themselves here.

But, why are you even considering a possibility other than janitor? You are trying way too hard to appear like an Oak, you scummy Maple. You're going down.

After looking at their posts from yesterday, neither one did very much of anything. Lauren rallied a lynch of Alastair. I think that is literally his only contribution outside of telling Buck to vote. And Buck made like 4 posts. If the vig did kill, I would assume they killed Buck and the Scum killed Lauren...for rallying people to lynch Alastair...who was Scum...then they janitored him. I see no other reason to kill Lauren. Unless the vig or a serial killer killed Lauren and the Scum were blocked or their target protected. I'm doing that speculate about every possibility of kill thing. Lauren would even make more sense as a neutral kill because he wasn't likely to be watched or protected. And maybe Buck was killed by a vigilante who prefers to weed out the low posters. Or there's a serial killer taking out low posters. Or Buck or Lauren said something to Scum in private that made them the kill target. Or something to the vig in private that made them think they were Scum I always yell at people for doing this... My point is, Chester, you seem to be more concerned about the vig. Do you know something we don't? Perhaps you are Scum and you know the Scum killed one of those two and you're trying to figure out if there's a neutral. That's what you sound like to me. Plus, after Day One, you're on my Scum list.