Donut

Thank you Scotty. I am pressed for time now, so this will be my last post. From the looks of things, I will most likely die tonight. No doubt the supreme being will impose extra votes on me since I have disobeyed his wishes. That's OK though, because things are going as I planned. I have quickly used up my witness cards to help the town. Essentially, I won't be much help to you guys later in the game. I have furiously tried to clear my name in hopes that you will see the dichotomy between me and the other two. Now I will do one last favor for the town by asking you to sentence me to death. I hope my passing can reveal the identities of these two scum. A tearful goodbye and with love, Donena Buena. P.S. I'll leave my jewerly store to Womanikin.

Scotty, I am saddened to see you turn against me. I guess you're going to diverge from your initial plan of disarming the scum. Since that's the case, I will stick to my plan. I Unvote: Professor Flutwuck / Professor Flitwick Vote: Mistress Kupp/Jedi master brick That must have occurred before the time frame that is in question. So it is out of scope.

Look if you can't defend your actions, don't go around saying that I don't have common sense. And if you want to talk about common sense: Proxy vote are designed for players who can't make the deadlines. You were present and misused that privilege. Now admittedly, that's not a big deal - but the entire exchange between you and Carly yesterday looks staged to me. Post #153: You said: " Really? Well, yes I am smiling, but a black turban does not make my red-and-white outfit 'mostly black'. And I haven't tried to fly under the radar; I've posted where necessary, by pointing out flaw in my husbands' argument, and leaving my vote in the hands of someone doing the most progressive thing to find the murderer. I've only tried to help where I can, and try and prove the innocence of my name. " Post #154: She said " Bummer, my addition skills are seriously challenged I think I will have to concede that my numbers are truly up, which deeply saddens me, because I'm a true townie who would do nothing to harm the town Now if you'll excuse me, I'd like to spend my last hours with some kittens and a box of nails. " Carly believed what you said and conceded quickly, frankly I see no substance in your defense. Then as planned, she cast her vote against Camanakin to cover your tracks.

Read onto the next page as well. Everything looks so staged as Carly easily gave up and then tried to turn the tables of Camanakin to mask Flutwuck.

I see that now, good move by you. By giving Bananakin the ability to proxy vote for you, I assume you had to leave for the rest of the day. But you conveniently came back right after Carly pointed fingers at you. The timing of this is too coincidental. Furthermore, since you were back, you didn't un-proxy your vote from Banakin. So essentially you never voted for Carly, even when you had the opportunity to do so. How strange! evidence is here Post #147-148.

When did she proxy the vote? During that time was it definite that Carly was going to be voted out?

The entire Carly situation was a conundrum for me. She tried to dupe us by helping out the town. Keep in mind that the accusation of Flutwuck came around the end day (when she was going to be axed). Perhaps this was a set-up by the mafia to pass one of their agents (Flutwuck) as innocent, knowing that you'll draw upon this relationship.

Don't take my quotes out of context as this thread is evolving at such a rapid pace. Scotty presented a better alternative strategy than the ones I have proposed. I like the idea of disarming a potential scum and in the end, the truth of our identities will be revealed. If you're truly a townie than you should have nothing to hide.

No problem, I like your plan the best. I am innocent and I have nothing to worry about. Vote: Professor Flutwuck/Professor Flitwick

As you said things are not going to be easy, but are things what they appear? Are you willing to take in the information at face value? I have to admit, it is very hard for me to prove my innocence when there is an investigation that proved the other suspect to be "innocent". All I can do is fight on and hopefully persuade to people that I am innocent.

New note: Scotty, I like your new reasoning. For the town to survive, we have to minimize our loss.

Of course not, but apparently Flutwuk was using this as support for her claims. I am was merely telling her that it has not been resolved. And to Scotty, I agree with everything you said. I didn't expect anything less from a university student.

Voting was closed early, so let's not hold it against him.

Nope the voting issue has not been resolved. The "village elder" did not neither agreed nor refuted your claims. You were penalized for quoting, no biggy as you're not in any danger today. Reread my strategies again, I explained everything clearly. Take home message: Voting for me, does not confirm your allegiance to the town (unless I turn out to be scum). So the most logical method is to pick one of you, preferably Mistress Kupp. You prove to be a more helpful ally (provided your town) than her.

I don't trust your investigation period. We still haven't resolved that typo issue. Your initial reluctance to post the investigation and the mistake that Camanakin found makes me very suspicious of you.

Of course, the clues lead to only one killer. But that doesn't make you innocent. And the clue says a woman with hair, not head gear. You should be fighting for yourself. If Mistress Kupp turns out to be scum or if I turn out to be a townie, you're in the wrong here. You should have investigated me as that was the popular viewpoint. You chose to go against the mainstream - that to me smells fishy.

And if I turn out to be the town? You will agree that you're guilty right? I'd be more than happy to become the martyr if I can bring out two scums! Bring it on! In all seriousness, there's a slight possibility that all three of us are innocent. This is why I choose the second route.

No it doesn't work like that. Here's an analogy, there are three variables X, Y, and Z. And we know that X and Y are on the same side (you and Mistress Kupp) and on the other side Z (me). If you eliminate Z (me), what new information have you gained? You still know that X and Y are friends, but are they allies with the town? On the other hand, if you eliminate either X or Y (preferably Y, Mistress Kupp). Option A: She is scum, then from the relationship X (Flutwuk) must be scum too. Option B: Same relationship, but opposite results. The better option is clearly the second route.

Like I said my original post was wrong because I misread Banakin and Mistress Kupp. As to my second post, I see that the new information you have provided was posted shortly after Mugg's. So it makes sense as to why he voted for me. Mugg, you don't even need to post a response to my question. I spoke too fast this time. New information: Mugg why are you meta-gaming? These are two different instances and the variables are subjected to change. Leave the dreams and whatnot out of your decision making.

To my above post to Mugg, I made a mistake in my response to the quotation, sorry. It's obvious that Bananakin is trustworthy, but between Mistress Kupp and I - you prefer to lynch me instead of her? Something is fishy here, so please explain to me your behavior.

Come on your a logical person, what has she said that makes you trust her more than me? Good eye Camanakin! It seems to be a copy paste version of Banakin's investigation on you. Post #118 everyone, the clue is more evident than ever. If you mean investigation as in Witness cards, then please everyone: Don't play anymore witness cards. We have enough clues to work with already!

Right now it's your words against mine. Telling everyone that I am scum does not help your cause. How can you be so sure I am scum? Is there something that you know about me that even I don't know? So far, I am not entirely sure that you're the scum, but your actions are very suspicious. You have dodged my comments for far too long. Previously you have predicted that I will be the target tomorrow, but you didn't specify from which faction. Are you saying that the scums are going to come after me?

Agreed. If we lynch Mistress Kupp, we can also confirm the identity of Professor Flutwut.

Yes, but scums will also have cards, perhaps even more than townies. How will the townies know what clues to trust? I am not against anyone double checking, but I am one of the prime suspect because of these clues. I know it'll be a waste for a townie to spend their cards on today's investigation.

Hehe, I don't need you tell me that I am on my last legs. But is this is a threat from a scum? Anyways, I have unintentionally incurred the wrath of the supreme being. No doubt I will have some sort of penalty placed upon me. If it all works well in the end, I will be taking you down with me.