Donut

Let's suppose both Mistress Kupp and I are townies. By investigating me, you would have kept a more logical and helpful townie alive. It just doesn't make sense to me as to why you chose this route.

Don't listen to this! We are burning up too many witness cards, save the cards to use against the scum for a later date!

I said relatively strong player, as in in comparison to you. As to my alliance it is to the town. I encourage everyone who is very suspicious of me to take a look of what I said during the previous day. Mistress Kupp, I wouldn't call your situation lucky because there was no luck involved. The scum knows that losing another member of their party would be devastating. You were saved to keep their population afloat. And yes, I am very suspicious of both Mistress Kuup and Professor Flutwuk.

It's only day 2 and it's far to early to dispel the notion that the mafia are not communicating. It strikes as very odd that you investigated Mistress Kupp instead of me. No offense to Mistress Kupp as she herself admitted that she was a confused player. So why not do the town a favor and keep a relatively stronger player alive? You have put the pressure on me.

Is this some sort of confession? I rest my case.

Mistress Kupp, I find if very odd that you have resigned your post very early on. A loyal townie would defend her honor to the very last minute. With that said, my offer yesterday still stands. Whoever has the card investigate me, I have nothing to hide.

Point taken. I was very surprised to find her real identity as even during the final hour I was very reluctant to vote against her. Sure, by all means investigate me. I have nothing to hide. My loyalties are to the town from day 1.

I trust myself as well, so I suppose the woman in question is Mistress Kupp. I can't believe you're pointing fingers at me. I sacrificed everything (all my cards) to bring you this valuable information and yet you think I am guilty?

So I've learned that the killer leaving the crime scene definitely had hair. So that eliminates all the ladies who are wearing some sort of head gear. Unfortunately that also leaves me in the mix. Womanikin Skywalker - Housewife/Wife of Mugg Kupp (Badboytje88) Donena Buena - Jeweler (Donut) Bananakin Skywalker - Town bicycle (Brickdoctor) Mrs. Le Goninja - Pub owner/Wife of Ram Strut (Mrlegoninja) Mistress Kupp - Hostess (Jedi Master Brick)

I would like to investigate the murder of Eskipo Land. My apologies for using a confusing word. I want learn more about the murder of Eskipo by receiving a clue. Thank you!

No worries Robanakin, I just wanted to hear your side of the story. I trust the validity of your clue.

She has already conceded... but wow this is some harsh language and resentful remark (jokingly or not).

Please read post #102. For the time being, I am not going to pursue this any further. And to Eskipo, might I ask what did your witness card say? I just want to know for book keeping purposes. Thanks!

Thanks for the images grogall! It is a very neat set for the holiday, it'll compliment the two other winter sets very well. Do you happen to know what the shaded brick means? Is it some kind of rating system?

There's also the possibility that he got the same response because he simply copied Carly's clue.

I am reluctant to do this as it still doesn't make sense to me why Carly would incriminate herself by coming out and bringing us the clue. Based on the most concrete evidence we have so far, I will have to with the majority of the votes here. So with great reluctance and for the sake of voting, Vote: Carly Vikera/Kartoffelviking

Agreed, though I hope no one is talking in private. I am a bit suspicious of Robanakin as the format of his clue does not match the clues we have seen thus far.

Most likely not as Carly and Camanakin received the same clue.

Eskipo, your entire post contradicts itself. If you do not trust the clues that have been provided to you, then why are you voting against Camanakin (by the way: you spelled his name wrong). Furthermore, I don't understand why you would use a card provided that Camanakin had already demonstrated there are no more new clues. Great going Bananakin, at least now we'll have some concrete evidence.

I am glad to see that the discussions were lively while I slept, but I hope to hear opinions from the other townies who have remained silent. I am a bit confused by this clue. Wedding rings? I didn't know that we could wear wedding rings, wrist rings might be more plausible. It's interesting that your clue mentioned *they* while the rest of the clues simply referred to the scum as *the killer*. Furthermore, first letter of a sentence should be capitalized. I am not trying to correct grammar, but I am simply pointing out the inconsistency of this clue with the rest of them. Jokingly or not, I disagree with this advice. We should not be using anymore witness cards as I believe we have a sufficient amount of clues to work with. Asking someone else to use their card will neither prove your innocence nor Carly's (as you both had the same clue). With that being said, I think you have built a weak case against Carly. 1. Timing - The timing of your contribution came at a point when you were on defense. Compared to the timing of Carly's card play, you move seems to be very selfish. She played the card to help the town find the scum while your motive was to prove your innocence. 2. Veracity - Since both clues are the same, this leads me to trust the clues. Going a step further, I trust Carly a bit more because there is truth in her original words. Furthermore there are 3 different clues out, so the odds are against you to draw the same clue as Carly's. Incidentally, this is also the most relevant clue in separating between you and Carly. It seems to me you're trying to hammer in the fact that she is smiling so therefore she must be the killer. 3. Photo - The photo verification is perhaps the least important clue for me. I am aware Carly is holding something, but that was apparent before she revealed the photo. From the group shots, you can clearly see the members of the town brandishing weapons associated with their profession. So Carly holding a weapon is not something we didn't know about. 4. Quick to vote - From the momentum of where the discussions were going, you could have waited to hear feedback from the other members of the town. Why were you so quick to cast a vote?

Being the owner of the pub, I am sure you can have that arranged! I think we should reserve our accusations until we have heard back from Carly.

Certainly, the clue I received is this: Dressed mostly in black. I assume by this that hair color does not matter.

I like your style Carly! I say let the cards do the talking.

Does everyone realize that this MOC was uploaded in 2008? The original contest thread can be found here

Burrito, it looks like one of your horses got loose.