Donut

I like the numbered bags, you don't have to worry about losing pieces if you can't build the set in one sitting. It looks to be the general consensus. I however wish the instruction manual came together as 1 book.

What an intimidating pose by that dragon. Such an awesome MOC, I am a big fan of your dragon MOCs.

I agree, so we need to take this day to think slowly - and consider all the possibilities. Do you care sharing that info here or with me in private?

Skillful editing, the grey bar at the bottom doesn't even show up. Be careful of this guy in the next mafia game!

Hey you've got good eyes! It does seem like there is a carrot on top of Puss in Boot's head.

Getting one scum, two, or three doesn't matter. If the town can't get all them, the game is over. We cannot think about short term goals. Here you again with mishearing stuff, please provide the evidence. Thanks!

I have received some new information from my close confidant Mickey Mouse so for right now I am going to Unvote: Aladdin (palathadric).

Since no one is refuting the evidence, I Vote: Aladdin (palathadric).

So here the 2 stories don't add up. Last night (night 2), one of you claims no investigation while the other claims Rabbit was investigated. Little Red Riding Hood (LRRH), who did you plan on investigating on night 2? You're not sure but then you're confident that LRRH is the scum cop. Which is it?! As for the second part, it seems impossible for the scum to know the identity of our vigilante and town cop on the same night. Oh for the italicized portion, from the way it's presented, are you suggesting that the scum role cop was blocked? You left it opened ended for interpretation.

What unbelievably bad luck. Cindy's scumdar was definetely broken, but her efforts for the town should be remembered. I agree with Ariel (mermaid), we need to take this slowly. The town cannot make anymore mistakes.

That's what I said earlier, and I'll explain more below in reference to Jack. Do you have proof that she didn't make it up? I don't see anyone presenting evidence to support or refute the claim. In fact this is the only piece of "evidence" that we're working with right now. What I KNOW for certain is that the scums are very intelligent and well organized. If they were able to coordinate such a surgically precise attack (last night), it wouldn't be a stretch of the imagination if they came up with elaborate charade. Charming your thoughts? I would also like to hear from the others who have been absent, particularly Little Red Riding Hood (LRRH).

I was hoping someone else would enlighten us with their findings. For the time being I'll have to believe your story (about this MJ) is accurate given that we have absolutely no other leads.

Thanks for taking the time to put this wonderful review up!

There's also the possibility that the Mara Jade person does not exist. We have no way of knowing is the events actually took place, could be a figment of her imagination. On the flip side, if the events were true, this Mara Jade has left itself (don't know the sex) in a pretty bad position. With only 4 individuals of knowing the plan, and one of them being dead (it) has no way of escaping. That would be a pretty bad infiltration, trading identity for a townie on the first night. Something just doesn't add up.

Voting?! It's a little too early to even be thinking of that! What we need is the find the correct suspect first.

@Peanuts/palathadric You guys are wearing the same hat

Really now? Come on any name is fine, we all have our suspicions. Maybe you're afraid to throw them out because you know who the good/bad guys are? As Goldilocks explained: Wolf (town vanilla) gets killed by Vigilante Bear who literally gets axed from the scum. Either the scum is really lucky in eliminating one of the town's power role, or the bear has entrusted his role to the scum. Chances are the latter is more probable, but hey I am a witch and deal with magic not probability. Now if you want someone to name the most obvious choice would be Cindy, who spearheaded the movement against Pinocchio. Wasn't the main reason something about a color? Baloney. And what about taking that big sacrifice, she seemed to have made it out ok. It looks like the scum wasn't even interested in dealing with her, maybe because she's allied with them? Lastly, from this exchange it clear to me that Snow White and Cindy are allies. How deep is this friendship (allies of town?), I don't know either. Nothing useful to add to the discussion as well.

If it's of any comfort, I lost 3 characters yesterday. Pretty bad runs overall.

I too miss the old box, especially the setting sun (yellow background) for the castle lines. I also miss the little catalog booklet that comes in with every medium-large set purchase.

Yep that looks like the Guarded Inn, that was my reaction before reading your description. Great job on paying homage to an awesome classic set.

It isn't a party without you!

Just wanted to thank Skipper for hooking me up with some items after I died from computer lag.

Good to see you on, better now than never! I also have pretty bad allergies, and find washing your face helps alleviate some of the sneezing and itching symptoms.

Little mermaid, you've finally made it! *Clap clap. Now we are just missing one other person. You have made some insightful comments and share some of the same sentiments. For someone who was micro-managing all the conversation throughout yesterday, I do find it bizarre that she is absent today (aside from the voting). Similarly, Pinocchio's inaction (failure to show up to defend) is a strange matter on its own.

Still not correct and please don't edit your statements! Wait a minute, Sleeping Beauty has called you out and your response is to whisper back to her? I would like to hear your defense, please address it here. Thanks! No that's not good of a reasoning, because everyone is doing it so shall I. I don't want to see townies blindly lead like lost sheep. We should slow down, discuss, and look at other possible candidates. Don't let the one person guide you to a decision.