Scubacarrot

Rufus, I did not even realize you were the vigilante, and not that Hinckley was the Protector either. I did not ask, because I felt I did not need to know such things. The only things about roles I paid attention to was the fact that I had figured out Tinypies and Sandy must have been the tracker and the other master criminal, but I did not know who was who at that point, so glad I got that correct, not that that mattered. I am genuinely happy how I did in this game, I wasn't a dick! Woohoo, everybody rejoices, root vegetables for everyone! I think the role I had helped, now I need to learn how to play vanilla and scum I guess. Speaking about my role, it was very powerful, being virtually unstoppable. I investigated Ferrik on the last day because of what he said, and that was the right decision it seemed! Bob, may I suggest that if you use a Godfather, you make the result (vanilla) Innocent/Town, because if there's a result like this, I feel it's always going to be followed up on.

How did that item change so much, I created it.

Isn't the paralyzing venom just a stun? I don't remember, it's too long ago, and I never actually saw it used.

Woo! We won. Thanks a ton for hosting and having me, Bob, I had a lot of fun!

Cursed, Slowed, they're really things that only work on Heroes rather than enemies, and that's all cool, I think.

Don't forget Benji's mysterious reputation gain with the Wolfgang in Quest 44!

"I hope you are right, back to the bar, then."

"You misunderstand, I have every intention of bringing this to a good end, but I don't think we are finding a lost brother, we are hunting a dangerous criminal. We don't have iron clad evidence, but the words of men with no reason to lie. I will follow your judgement Nerwen, and as I said, my suggestion is to head to the Fort, if Reno has left Eubric, we'd need to follow. And if there's anywhere we might find the location of the Weregator's ship, it's there, the Bonaparte probably have records. I have heard those rumours same as you, but that he's not the only one doesn't make it right... You're in charge, Nerwen."

"There are hundreds, perhaps thousands of ships, if we miraculously end up searching at the right side, perhaps we'll find them, otherwise, not likely. The pirates said they served Reno, and that Reno was Jolly Roger, remember. They attacked us after we mentioned Reno. That Reno had set up a safety precaution is worrisome to begin with, but those men had no reason to lie, they outnumbered us 5 to 3, they thought we weren't getting out of this. If we go back to the bar, I bet we'll find that those geezers had enough gold without ever doing anything, they weren't after us for our valuables, and again, they'd have no reason to lie like that, and no reason mentioning Reno would trigger them. The Nord said he killed Jolly Roger. This turns out to be true... That means he didn't kill the real Jolly Roger, or not one at all. I am quite convinced of this, Nerwen."

"I am many things, but not a traitor. Are you?" Guts sheathed his blade, watching the Nord walk off. He was pondering the trouble it would give if he took out one of throwing knives and buried it in the barbarian's skull. It would probably save them all a lot of trouble down the line. He said to Nerwen: "Those Weregators are long gone, if you don't know their ship's name, there's little chance we'll see them again. We should return to the Fort. Nemo Bonaparte will have no choice but to listen to us now."

Quest 52 had some Hexing going on.

Maybe I should rephrase, you shouldn't go out of your way to appear town.

Guts spit on the ground, then said: "You're a bad liar, Nord. I will be reporting this to our employer."

You didn't really defend yourself though.

You're trying hard not to be suspicious. Which is very suspicious.

Guts wiped his blade off on one of the pirates' rags, after striking four of them down in a single blow. "Nord, you got some explaining to do."

So what other reason could there be? And you realise that that's not very good as your only argument?

I'm going to vote: Betty (Ferrik) . If she is the Godfather of the Thieves, there is possibly only one way to get rid of her, a lynch. We know Michael is a thief, and we do know we need to get rid of him, but he wants to get lynched, it seems. Yesterday the Day Investigator was correct, and this result (if I understand it right?) reeks of a scum godfather or something.

He just said though that his winning condition is to outnumber the town as the thieves, that's the same as the normal thieves. Meaning he's one of our targets.

Guts said mockingly, "Leave the poor man be, Nerwen, the girl gave him the crawlies, he´s in pain." If these pirates were by any chance not telling them lies, then the Nord had not told them the truth, and what reason could the pirates have to lie?

Hm.. It seems we have a choice of who to lynch, awesome. Was he blocked in some way or just unable to find anything out? I assume, the second, but still? I don´t think it´s possible to block a day investigator without some kind of day blocker, and I don´t think we´ve seen any reference to any other day roles. (or roles in general, besides thieves, killers and a tracker). If Betty has a weird role that makes her unable to be investigated as you suggest, Stacy, what would it be that would make her not talk about it? I can´t really think of anything besides godfather.

It´s a possibility, but would a scum give up his own life just to kill 1 townie?

Why would you get yourself lynched?

It was made very very very clear by Babs herself that she was a Master Criminal, this statement kind of shows that you haven't been paying attention much. I urge you to take your time and read back on the events on the previous days.

Obvious reference.