Kadabra

I believe it was said to be an arbitrary vote to avoid penalties. I'm slightly offended, but whatever. However, if she had suspicions, why would she need to vote arbitrarily in the first place? Jessica, please explain.

Great content, lots of thought put into this here post. What are your thoughts on Day 1 and 2? Any suspects? I'll tell you my suspect for today - you, Mr. fluffy Metagamer.

The Rainbow Dash to Jetrax99's Fluttershy? Gerald and Flora should make out.

But why bother bringing it up? Esurient's account was already set to private before the game, and other people have private but you aren't scrutinizing them. It was just really bad logic.

Wat. Srsly? I'm so frustrated by this that I just devolved into textspeak. I'm going to go stab myself while feeling completely justified in hounding Esther these past two days.

I'm going to have to go with the Esther vote, because like I've said, townies don't softclaim. Vote: Esther Thompson (esurient)

Guys, since she literally already claimed a PR, it doesn't matter which one, the scum have all the info they need already - that is, she's a target. NOT revealing the rest of her role would be like kicking the town in the balls right now, because she's given scum everything they need without giving Town any useful information. If she doesn't reveal her role and is town, then the scum can pick her off without us getting any useful information from her whatsoever and we won't know what PRs are available to us because she could have been any of them. If she doesn't reveal and is scum, then she gets a lynch pass and probably free doc protection while we can't judge that she's lying because there are no counterclaims. So AYE.

The obvious conclusion: because Esther is scum.

Hero Factory builds can easily be more complex and unique than Technic ones just because of all the different ways you can use the same set of simple, non-specialize pieces.

As I said yesterday, real town never softclaims, it gives scum a target and Town nothing new to work with. I'd bet she's scum - why wouldn't the scum target her last night (being the only claimed PR) if they knew she was town?

Razar and Rizzo are actually really bad army builders, I think - anyone heard of an army that has every member missing a hand? Or one where everyone lost the same leg and same eye?

It's funny that you call me an ignorant lurker who never answers questions when you're probably worse. It's incredibly stupid to have a list of reads that includes concrete "scum" on Day freaking One. Also, I would like you to point out exactly where I have been 'ignorant'? And whose questions I have not answered? I'd be happy to address them if there are any. I think the actual reason behind your vote on me is something along the lines of OMFGUS. And now you're fishing for an investigation on you, when we just talked about not publicly discussing PR plans? Now if the cop does check you the scum will for sure have a watcher or something if they have one on you, and one of our best PRs will be dead. A lot of people read you as confused Townie just because of how flail-y you are, but I'm going to stick with tentative scum because A. A real Townie never softclaims (it only hurts the Town) B. The flailing is a good way to cover up Scumminess ("his scum buddies would never let him post that" is one of the biggest reasons I've heard to not lynch a scummy person throughout my admittedly short mafia career, I would be surprised if scum didn't use the flailing=townie link to their advantage) C. You're fishing for an investigation, which would leave our Cop vulnerable.

OK, seriously? This is the post we're talking about, right? Let me break it down for you, because it's obvious you don't get it. I'm not sure who's that managed to confuse you because it was pretty simple. The only mistake Liz made was not understanding how Framers worked, why on Earth should that be a reason for being Scum? Esther, on the other hand, is accusing somebody of fishing for PRs because he was roleplaying... In the confirmation thread. Big time flawed logic. Makes sense now?

I'd like you to clarify where I questioned Liz's logic. The post that I quoted had her state that a framer might screw with rolecopping. I corrected her. I then questioned Esther's logic and proceeded to vote her. Care to explain the purposeful misreading of my post?

Would have preferred a more hunched look and a staff as a weapon. Great MoC, it just doesn't look like a Rahkshi.

No, Framer screws with alignment. Role Cop turns up your role. (A vig or the scum killer would both read 'killer', a Rolecop that is town OR scum would read 'rolecop', etc.) Anyway, I'm definitely in agreement with Clay in that Michael and Sheridan doing this sort of buddy-ish thing is confusing, but I want to wit for the rolecop's results, if we have one. So I'll lay the first vote on Esther for her over analysis and repeatedly flawed logic. Please clarify your thought processes, Esther, unless 'causing confusion' is the only reason you have for your bad logic. Vote: Esther Thompson (esurient) I thought we were playing a Western game, not a ninja themed one.

I understand roleplaying but it is getting hard to understand your posts and to distinguish roleplaying from actual content from you. When you make a whole post (supposedly roleplaying) dedicated entirely to how .michael couldn't be scum, it looks like a defense. Now I seems like you're back pedaling, any chance you could reduce the roleplaying levels any time soon? I'd love to be able to read what you post without being hopelessly confused,

I mentioned Michael buddying and Sheridan defending him earlier. Please talk, you two.

I have to echo everyone and say that it feels more like I'm looking at an OoMN member than a Hero but ignoring style, this is freaking amazing.

Wait, seriously? I have to agree with this. Calling a guy out on role playing and insinuating that it's a grab for PR claims is kind of wacky. Could you get in here and explain your thought process, because this is scummiest than pond water.

Ha, that's funny. Last time I was in a situation similar to this one we have here, someone soft-defended someone else an the first day. He got called out for it but it was sort f dropped, and they both turned out scummy. So my question to you is: Why are you defending this guy on Day 1? You don't know his alignment so why are you stating that he would never be a Coyote?

Woo-ee, starting the day with a bang, huh Sheridan? I would say that move would require some big brass balls for a Scum to pull and you appear to be a lady, so, tentative Town read here.

Well, you got opportunity in your community, folks. I'm Kane and I'm here to help you weed out those nasty varmints.

Love the MLP reference to the best pony. Other than that, very creative use of the exo force arms to create a flower motif on the shield and them in tandem with the core clamp chest pieces to make the same motif on the shoulders and shins. I personally like the butterflies even beyond the Flutters reference because, y'know, insects pollinate flowers and stuff, so they're her equivalent of Furno's flames or Surge's lightning or Stringer's speakers or whatever. It's very "set-ish", if you know what I mean. One thing I would have done is either gone for a pure yellow/pink color scheme (for simplicity's sake) or a yellow/pink/green color scheme to emphasize the plant theme. I feel like gold and yellow clash too much to be used as primary/secondary and are not contrasting enough to be used as primary/tertiary (accent). All in all, amazing MOC.

Gonna win this one. Maybe. Please? 1. Bedtime Story, Jedi Temple, Harriet Slutter, Mafia Mafia 2. Totes available. High school teachers get summer off, too, not just students. (Well, lesson planning aside, but screw that) 3. My favorite role that I've been so far is Scum JOAT. I like being in the know, and Scum puts you there right from Day 1. I also liked being the cop in Bedtime Story for the same reason.