Tamamono

I'm tempted to unvote John and settle for a no-lynch at this point. There are so many different teams I see that I'm not really convinced on anyone right now. Plus, the support for John is starting to reek of scum... Thoughts?

You're literally voting me because you think I've been led astray. Yet being led astray implies that I'm town... Do you want to vote town, Lucy? I sure don't want to vote town, but it seems you do. Want to explain to the rest of us why you want to lynch town?

So I shouldn't act all "buddy buddy" with someone who I think is town? By your logic, I should be constantly paranoid of everyone at every moment. We won't get anything done if we don't give one another at least temporary trust. And I don't see what's so "fishy" about her; I believe that she's the real thing. Plus, if you think the doctor is "fishy", why are you voting for me? I'm not the doctor, I'm just the messenger. Nothing you've said in relation to my affiliation has made any sense whatsoever.

I stated why I changed from Shawna; she towntold. Also, you're obviously not reading anything I've said: if I were scum both the doctor and Andrew would be long gone by now. Read before you vote.

Doctor's actions: Night 1: No action (she didn't have the role yet) Night 2: Protect me (didn't get it in in time ) Night 3: Protect Andrew (Success!) Allison seems town to me for now, I don't think she's a good lynch. Yeah, I'm trying to take the lynch off Andrew because I think it'd be better to wait and see if we can't verify him rather than to lynch him straightup and possibly lose our cop. Unvote: Shawna (Fred Daniel Yam) Vote: John Bender (Antonio) Shawna's last post was a towntell.

She forgot to get her action in Night 2, and claims that she inherited her action from someone who died on Night 1. So, basically, Newton. Or maybe Bud didn't realize doctor was an important action. Either way. As of now I trust her. I'm pretty sure she wouldn't fakeclaim doctor early on as scum, but you never know. I don't think she's scum. I think right now I'm gonna Vote: Shawna (Fred Daniel Yam) As I'm pretty sure she's scum. I don't know what to make of Claire and Andrew, but I honestly think waiting a day on them might have its merits. I don't expect anyone to sheep me, but if you did that'd be cool. It's either this or no lynch, unless everyone in town wants to rise up against Andrew/Claire, which I can't stop, obviously. Power to the people I guess?

See, it's reactions like that that make me think Andrew is town (in addition to the doc save). Honestly, I don't know who to lynch. I'm tempted to let it go to a no lynch, really. Thoughts? Actually, the doctor didn't get her action in on Night 2, so it may very well be that the Success comes every night.

Yeah, I do. The doctor would be 100% dead if I were scum, and there was no kill last night, so either A. blocker blocked, or B. doctor saved. Your suspicion of me is understandable, but largely baseless. I mean like seriously if the blocker got a successful block in then that takes away so much of why Andrew is town.

Honestly, I still don't know what to do. Is a framer too advanced for a school like this? Am I giving two scum a free pass to the conclusion? If there's a town blocker out there, please share who you blocked with me. Everything would add up so much better if we could just discount the doc save.

Two other things to note: 1. Andrew says Ms. Dragonsworth told him not to trust his results 100%. 2. The doctor says she got a result of "success" that she'd not seen before. This implies that Andrew was saved. I'm starting to think there's a framer afoot, but honestly, if there is, Claire basically has to be scum.

Alright, well, I just got confirmation from the town doctor that she saved Andrew last night, for what it's worth. If there's a blocker out there who blocked someone, don't hesitate to come to me (or some other probable town like Adriano... Andrew would even be good, I daresay he's town as well). I agree with Mary that we should leave Claire for another day. More later.

Yeah, I really really really do not think there's a framer in this game (although Simone was apparently the watcher...), so either A. Claire is scum and is passing wrong info to us, and Andrew is also scum (impossible because the investigator wouldn't let a guy he didn't guilty get lynched with people thinking he did guilty him) B. The investigator is scum and so is Claire. Possibly Andrew too. (Likely) C. There's a framer. In this case either he got extremely lucky or his frame or Claire/Andrew is scum and framed the guy they knew was being checked. D. Simone is a scum death-godfather. (less than zero chance) The safest course of action is to lynch Claire. If there really is a framer, it's likely that she framed her knowing she'd be checked.

Uhhh... What...? I honestly have no idea what's going on. Why didn't Simone flip scum? Claire, what's the deal?

Lynch it anyway.

Marvelous. I was really convinced Simone was scum yesterday, but today she seemed to drop some towntells here and there; luckily she flipped scum anyway. Vote: Simone Adamley (Captain Nemo) Because Claire has been consistently town all game. I don't think the investigator would want to go around spilling his role to everyone - much less scummos like you. Oh, and it's not just Claire. The deceased Ricky (rest in pieces ) and I also know who the investigator is and what her results are. Hold up there sugar, you're missing some serious logic here. If you're town, one of the investigator and Claire (probably both) is scum. I know who both are, and will stop at nothing to make sure they're lynched one after another. Since there are only probably ~5 scum, there is no real reason not to lynch you; it's a mislynch and we can afford it. If anything, if you're town, you'll want to selfvote, because it catches two scum for the price of one townie. It's the town thing to do, Simone, vote yourself.

Yeah, I'm really sorry about that. While I did try to prevent Bud's lynch once he started towntelling, the Wendy lynch was 100% my fault, and I'm perfectly willing to take all blame for it. I can confirm that there is a investigator and that he is in contact with Claire.

What am I elaborating on?

That's unfortunate; I really thought Wendy would flip scum. Craig too seemed town to me; hence of course why he was expelled. Interesting that neither I nor Claire have been expelled during the night quite yet. In any case, we may have more to go on a bit later in the day. I'll keep y'all posted.

While I absolutely agree that Simone is likely scum, it'd be optimal for you to vote for Wendy at this point; the last thing we want at this point is a no-lynch.

The lynch is the town's greatest weapon; there's never any reason to not vote.

Again, I don't think Andrew is a good candidate for expulsion today (although his behavior is pretty similar to Simone's, I townread him more for some reason. ) and it goes without saying that I currently townread Claire. Other good lynch targets are Simone/Wendy/Davey. Simone's participation has been spotty, and she generally only shows up to defend herself; Davey's behavior has been completely whacko from the get-go; and Wendy's seemed completely off all game. I almost voted her yesterday, but her sheeping of Ricky's incredibly misguided vote is the scummiest thing I've seen so far in our time here at Aperture Academy. Vote: Wendy Beamish (Wedge09) Simone/Davey are by no means clear, but I feel like Wendy is the optimal lynch for today.

Post of the year. Actually, while I disagree with his vote against Claire, I partially agree with his stance on Andrew. Quiet as he's been, I don't really think Andrew is a priority for today; it's the people who are talking enough to stay out of trouble yet still saying nothing of actual substance that we want to go after. Why are you still basing suspicions off of roleplaying? Ping.

It's not confirmed, but a simple process of elimination leads us to that conclusion. Sloane was seen packing a large wrench into Newton's bag, which means 99% that she was the one who got him expelled. She too was expelled, and turned up Loyal, so she can't be the scum killer or the serial killer (which there probably isn't). This basically means that she was the vigilante, leaving the last figure for scum/sk. Since I don't see the sk going for a metagame kill (plus, there's usually a scum kill on most nights), the black figure is probably Black Mesa. Good eye, Lucy. I feel like you're right there, although I certainly hope you're wrong (the more PRs the better; especially with one already dead). Nice job summarizing what everyone else said, buddy. Got anything else of your own to add?