Tamamono

Yeah, he's town. Meh. Let's hope Male Lover is scum.

Male Lover is another stellar lynch. Can we get another bandwagon on him?

Weird. I feel like a scummo would stick it out, but since he's getting modkilled there's no reason not to make him our second lynch. Vote: Cultist (Fred Daniel Yam)

Ugh, sorry for my absence. Been busy. Shame that a pill had to be revealed like that, but at least Witch's story adds up. Meh. I like all these lynches, barring Snake Charmer (I've already stated that I feel like he's becoming more town. Cultist/Male Lover are actually my main candidates. Hopefully we can coordinate the votes so that these two (or at least the most suspicious people) get lynched? Maybe we should continue with the fake votes and then make a tally between these people, eventually changing to real votes when the time comes? Unfakevote Jester Fakevote Cultist

Oh..?

I'll take the Pill from the Dickhead Galaxy. I'll give you the part about being gone; that'd be a valid excuse. However, "It was the only case I had been following up to that point, and even then, when I looked back, everyone just seemed to let it drop in favor of the Cultist and the Serial Killer, something I thought was odd." suggests that you did know that SK/Cultist were the main lynches, and yet you still voted for Usurper. What about Cultist do you find "not suspicious"? You say he was the same way as the SK, yet you say the SK had been suspicious... This isn't adding up. This seems forced, especially the first line. Like, I realize the intention of the post, but the way it was phrased came off as super forced. Might just be inexperience, but something to note for the future I guess. Tree stump/Witch would be cool ideas for lynches. Snake Charmer didn't look so good yesterday, but seems a bit more sincere today. Definitely a good point; Male Lover feels off his town game too. He'd be an interesting lynch, although I feel like it might be better to clear/kill him through night action. So far we have Jester/Witch/Stump/Male Lover/Cultist as my main lynch candidates. What does everyone think between these? What I find interesting is that you took the same pill as Cultist took yesterday. Hmm.

Literally the worst possible lynch. Anyways, big news today is two lynches. Guess we'll see how that goes soon, huh. I have someone I'd like to accuse. Take a look at this post: Like I said yesterday, Jester voted for someone who wasn't on the block when it was obviously between Cultist and SK. This is a huge scum move; he got to convict a townie without actually saying anything about it. Plus, this is totally Jester's scumgame. Fakevote: Jester (Pie) I've got more thoughts on others (and thoughts on all your thoughts), but I haven't got time to make a proper wall at the moment. Maybe later.

Also, I love how SK's getting votes for not being here even though Female Lover pretty much made it clear why he was gone. Scum are riding that bandwagon.

Don't split the vote. Serial Killer or Cultist; pick one. (Pro tip: vote Cultist).

You're voting Usurper for saying you're scum?? I don't particularly townread Usurper (and I think he should be checked out sometime soon-ish), but aggressiveness is generally a towntell. I totally could have, that's true. I said it so long-windedly because I was pretty much "thinking out loud", if you will. I got my reads and opinions as I was reading the posts and typing up my own. After rereading, I honestly don't want a Serial Killer lynch - at least not today. Snake Charmer, too, has been getting more and more sincere in his responses as time's gone on. The lynch I'm most comfortable with at this point is Cultist, honestly. I'm going to Vote: Cultist (Fred Daniel Yam) Out of everyone currently being voted for (and not being voted for, even), Cultist is the most forced. Usurper has been more and more town as time's gone on, as has Snake Charmer (as I mentioned before). PGO/Virgin/First Day Lynch aren't exactly screaming town either, but they're playing similarly to how they played in past lives, which makes me want to give them the benefit of the doubt (PGO in particular). I like the Cop lynch, but I've seen him take a fairly passive route as town on at least one occasion as well, so I'm a little wary of voting for him for now.

Alright, thanks for clarifying a few of those things. When it comes down to the justification, it's a matter of playstyle. The voting thing I can definitely believe; not too happy with the fact that you're throwing out those votes, but I can understand and believe it. Meh. There's really no arguing this point either way. However it appeared to you is your deal. Alright. Makes sense. Unfakevote: Usurper (Trumpetking) Still not happy with his general demeanor, but I could be getting tunnel vision. In any case, he's made clear in a fairly good defense his reasons for doing what he did, so there's really no reason to lynch him today just based on a feeling. I hounded him for (what I believe to be) suspicious behavior. There's nothing more to it. Did you read my analysis of Usurper, or are you just pulling this out of your megablocks? I have no problem with the page one banter he's engaged in. I don't have a problem with his "defense" of Snake Charmer, either, as I thought I'd made clear. What I do/did have a problem with, however, is his overjustification of said "defense".

No content in the first three. I can't really get a read from them, though; pretty much everyone was just roleplaying at gamestart (especially me). Again roleplaying. I feel like the way he responded Talking Animal's obvious joke is weird, though. Like, I don't know if I should feel like he's well-meaning town who can't understand written irony or if he's scum defending a partner. Hell, he could even be scum trying to pretend he's town with poor reading comprehension. Still, this should be kept in mind for once information about one or the other surfaces as the game goes on. Roleplaying. I must ask, how could you not tell if he was joking or not? It was the first page of the first day; do you unironically think that there's someone out there who would lynch someone just because it looked like they were giving the camera the finger? You are referring to the SK accusation here, yes? Then why did you react to it as if it was serious...? Explanation of roleplaying, it appears. I don't get this vote. While I don't believe Role Cop told us about the 1 unvote rule at this point, it's still a little weird to vote someone with the intention of unvoting them. This isn't even like the "I'm going to vote for this lurker until they talk" kinda deal; it's just straightup bad play. What on earth were you thinking with this? Uhh. Why do you feel the need to overjustify your serious response to an obvious joke. Like I said, it could be a scumtell, but I honestly can't read it one way or another right now - and I doubt anyone else can either. You're coming off as anxious and fickle. I don't like it. Probably the most protown post he's made. Nothing really scummy here. Sorry if my response wasn't the clearest thing in the world; I was practically thinking out loud. Even now, I'm pretty much just thinking out loud. What I'm saying is that I understand your defense, and it makes sense, and I've been there. However, I mean that just as any townie response is easily faked by scum, so is this. I'm saying I doubt that your wish for the Serial Killer to testify before we do anything is insincere.

I found it, Female Lover! I was implying that his snakes were, in fact, flipping us all off. Bad + forced post. His apology reads weird, but it could easily be low confidence at work; it can't very well be read as one affiliation or another without taking everything else into account. However, the real ping here is his second statement; he quickly defends himself (and for something that was fairly obviously not much of a scumtell, at that), and then jumps on possibly the most prosecuted person here. What's worse is that I don't really see this in your character, Usurper. You're still learning the ropes to an extent, yes, but I see you as a fairly strong player. You have a fairly - I'm not sure how to describe it - towngame. Not aggressive, but it's proactive in a really townie way. You're being fairly proactive here too, but you seem more... reserved, I suppose. I don't like it, honestly. Fake Vote: Usurper (Trumpetking) I'm going to go back and analyze all of Usurper's posts thus far; I feel like it'll help my thought process in relation to his innocence/guilt. I have to admit, I actually like this train of thought. I'd be cool with a Snake Charmer lynch too. While I understand wanting to hear his thoughts first (I, too, usually ask for an explanation before placing a vote), your manner here suggests exactly what Cult Leader said.

Hey, sorry all, been fairly busy. Err, where was that? It may because I can only read out of one eye, but I haven't noticed any direct questions. I'm not sure I follow. This is actually a fairly good point - better than anything thus far. SK, do you have anything to say?

I'll be takin' the Light saber Pill.

You be askin' fr' it, if ya' ask me, matey.

Yarrr, time t' m'ke thos' trait'rs walk th' plank!

Yarr, t'cures men'al illn'ss. What'd ya' 'xpect? Ya'd do w'll t' do y'r res'rch, matey.

Yarr', mateys be walkin' th' plank alr'dy?

What be ya' babblin' on aboot, priv't Shad'wy Figr'!? This har's no game; on th' op'n ocean, it be life 'r death!

Yarrrr, who be the scallywag 'at thinks 'e can be sendin' a man overboar' withou' walkin' the plank!? We'll be a-comin' fr' ya, sonny boy, say yr prayr's!

Should I be insulted or honored?

Actually, you can fix a lot by getting rid of the ducklings/inventors/JOATs.

1. What's mafia? How did I get here? I'm scared. 2. 3. Too night action reliant. We'll see how it goes, though.

Bah, I had a feeling I should have changed to Firuz. Not that it would have made much of a difference, but still, I could get conclusion bragging rights like in Baritones 3. Congrats, scummos! I was pretty sure that some of you were town (Rick/Pandora in particular), so really good job on that. And thanks, Hinck, for a great game! Wonderful setup and story as usual. This is where the anonymity played a big part; if I'd have known it was you, I'd have called your bluff and lynched you. All throughout the game I thought you were some newbie who finally snapped when he saw he was going to lose. In hindsight, "I'm a pioneer. " should have been enough of a tell for me.