Tariq j

Yeah Ford’s Injury might have pushed things along. Plus I think Thor and Dr Strange MOM have also been delayed.

The Philosopher’s Stone (the film that is) was released on the 10th November. So I guess whatever the surprise is will come around then(?) A new video game would be fantastic but seems unlikely. It could be an exclusive figure or maybe an animated film like the Yoda Chronicles or something.

That’s awesome news. I’m guessing it’ll come with the hallway section.

A Yoda’s Hut set for $80? I’m guessing it comes with a mid scale/small X-Wing. The Death Star Battle Scene sounds like it’s could be a vignette like the previous sets.

I like the idea of vignettes - something in the style of the Thor’s New Asgard set. The Pivot scene comes to mind. A Friends CMF would be a dream come true as well.

I can’t say I’m too excited for the Landspeeder - I don’t think it’ll be bad by any means but there are other ships/locations I’d have preferred. The minfigure packs sound really good.

Really excited to hear that the Battle Packs are making a return. I actually don't mind more Hoth.

Thanks for the brilliant game Bob. And Congratulations to the town for their win! Really good job JintaiZ, we really thought there was a blocker who was on to us.

I’d love to seem some more GoF sets as well. We’ve still got the other two challenges plus the Drumstrang ship. I wonder if they might even do the tent from the Quidditch World Cup.

I find this unlikely. Even though the scum are the informed majority wouldn’t it be too much of a risk to try and get the town to lynch themselves? They have no way of knowing what mechanics/PR roles could be problematic. Alternatively, a protector and the traitor could’ve targeted the same person, which in a game this size is not impossible. I have to vote and I have no idea what to think. Vivian has been silent and non committed this whole game and is only speaking up because she’s on the brink of being lynched. But is also withholding who she finds suspicious. I’ve seen this scum behaviour before so I’m going to Vote: Vivian Pierce (Kaanere)

Sorry, I have been busy in RL which is why I haven’t been active this (mafia) day compare to other days. I’ve made my suspicions of Vivian clear on previously in the game. The suggestion that the mafia haven’t killed for the past 3 nights rubs me up the wrong way, maybe it’s because it sounds like she’s trying to push the least likely scenario on us? I don’t know. A quick look in out journals suggests that there is no role that could stop all actions on one night. A mechanic like that feels like it rings a bell. Fishing, restocking the barrels, scrubbin’ the decks and watchin’ out for any sea monsters.

Sorry for being late. I had some activities below deck that needed attending. I agree. Why would the traitors wait since they know who is on their team and who is not. Wouldn’t they start killing anyway? I mean I suppose the scum could have not killed to make the blocker think they’ve got the right person - but for three nights?

Mr Milford’s behaviour is confusing. Trying to place the blame of Wembley’s lynch on Mr Nelson. Wembley wasn’t killed based on his inactivity, he was killed because when he was active he didn’t add anything of substance (and the fact that he was the investigator and didn’t give us a result makes this even more confusing). However I’m also uneasy at the way the votes have built up on Milford. I don’t know. Milford’s behaviour is odd but My gut is saying Vivian. I just can’t believe someone would just come on the upper deck and say “Sorry everyone, I have nothing else to add to the discussion! Bye” And then hide in the lower decks for the next 24 hours. Vote: Vivian Pierce (Kaanere)

I wonder this as well. Mr Wembley must have had one result from Night 1. If we’d known the allegiance of someone it would’ve helped going forwards. As for Vivian, I’ve said it before but activity/inactivity has very little bearing on whether someone is town or scum. However there is this: (bold for emphasis) Maybe I’m reading too much into this because she hasn’t said a lot, but what does Vivian mean by that? Why is she glad that “the bandwagons didn’t lead anywhere?” Is that a Freudian slip? Was one of her scum mates about to be lynched? Or did she just not want a Day One lynch? It’s so hard to tell because she’s said so little.

That’s fair. And I agree on your two points. Not posting much isn’t the issue but the lack of insight and thoughts. We need a lynch today and for me it’s a choice between Vivian and Mr Wembley. Vivian seems to below decks and from the looks of things probably won’t be joining us. For me, Mr Wembley’s unhelpful posts make me think he is scum. So I’m going to: Vote: Douglas Wembley (Darkdragon)

The way I see it is this, Mr Wembley is correct about inactivity - we can't judge a person whether they are town or scum based on it as RL comes first. However, everytime he has been online and posted it's been fluff. Nothing really of substance or useful. Even in his reponse to you, there's no analysis or helpful points, just defensiveness. For Vivian I've explained in my other post why I'm suspicous of her. You mention in your analysis that you think she's made some good points in the discussion but I'm interested to know what they are.

I’d also have to say Gringotts as well since Diagon Alley does feel incomplete without it. I also think it’d be nice to have something depicting the Ministry of Magic. It doesn’t necessarily have to be a giant D2C set but even just a small battle set with a fireplace and a small fountain or something like that.

I'd actually like to hear more from both of them. Especially Vivian. I'm not hugely convinced that Vivian not hammering the bandwagon means she is unlikely to be scum. Her and Mr Nelson being on a scum team could make a lot of sense. Mr Wembley says a lot without saying anything. And I've seen that sort of thing from both scum and town players in the past so I honestly don't know what to think of him.

A couple of thoughts so far: I have mixed thoughts about Vivian. She's posted twice this whole game and one of those posts has amounted to "I don't really have anything to add - sorry!" and then call out another inactive player. Mr Wembley seems to say a lot without saying anything at all.

What did Mr Nelson say that makes you lean town on him?

Wonderful news! As Mr Wembley said, hopefully there is a blocker who could give us something useful today.

Hold on a second there now. That Trenton Monette boy seems highly familiar... What is it about Mr Milford that you be finding suspicious?

But he didn’t give a role or claim, he just said we should be determined to find traitors using “loyal pirate” as a general term. I feel like you’ve read too much into it. Vote: Noah Nelson (JintaiZ)

I don’t know. I feel like in context of his response it made sense. He was merely saying that we should all be determined in finding traitors.

Where did he tell us his identity? Do you mean this?