Hinckley

It's possible that he thought we wouldn't notice so soon. It's a common mistake when trying to add a clever twist. Sometimes people figure things out faster than a host realizes they will. It's hard to control your players and you shouldn't try. It's possible Bob tried this to be clever and we figured it out immediately.

I meant to leave Mary on there. Thomas, I thought had a Town set because it started with the word "Fire". I suppose a full third of us being Scum isn't logical... We don't know what def's set is...or Rufus for that matter. Whoever they are. We don't know Phil or Barbara's sets either. I'm posting a little too hastily. Sorry this is sloppy. 7 Scum and a serial killer are still possible.

Alice (Passenger) - Played by Rumble Strike - 9491 Geonosian Cannon Barbara (Passenger) - Played by Def - Undisclosed Betty (Passenger) - Played by Waterbrick Down - 5980 Squidman's Pitstop Bill (First Officer) - Played by Capt. Redblade - 3365 Space Moon Buggy Bristol (Lounge Singer) - Played by Peanuts - 3368 Space Centre Diane (Passenger) - Played by TrumpetKing67 - 9468 Vampyre Castle George (Passenger) - Played by The Legonater - 7093 Skeleton Tower Holly (Passenger) - Played by Nightshroud99 - 4210 Coast Guard Platform Jack (Medical Officer) - Played by Piratedave84 - 3182 Airport Jonathan (Passenger) - Played by Hinckley - 4442 Glider Jordan (Passenger) - Played by Tamamono - 4429 Helicopter Rescue Lauren (Lifeguard) - Played by Scubacarrot - 3658 Police Helicopter Mary (Passenger) - Played by TheBoyWonder - 9676 Tie Interceptor and Death Star Matthew (Passenger) - Played by Adam - 4441 Police Dog Van Michael (Passenger) - Played by badboytje88 - 4207 City Garage Paul (Passenger) - Played by Dannylonglegs - 4644 Marina Phil (Passenger) - Played by Rufus - Undisclosed Pierre (Waiter) - Played by CallMePie - 4200 Mining 4x4 Richard (Passenger) - Played by ADHO15 - 6455 Space Simulation Station Scott (Engineer) - Played by CorneliusMurdock - 4201 Loader And Tipper Stacy (Cruise Director) - Played by Sandy - 3648 Police Chase Susan (Passenger) - Played by TinyPiesRUs - 4431 Ambulance Thomas (Passenger) - Captain Genaro - 8188 Fire Blaster Timothy (Passenger) - Played by Palathadric - 7627 Temple of the Crystal Skull Are the Scum valiantly trying to play off the fact that God foolishly designed this game for our numbers to give away our affiliation and it blew up in his face and was uncovered by Day Two? Pearl 2.0? Is this our Scum team and serial killer? Alice (Passenger) - Played by Rumble Strike - 9491 Geonosian Cannon Barbara (Passenger) - Played by Def - Undisclosed Betty (Passenger) - Played by Waterbrick Down - 5980 Squidman's Pitstop Bill (First Officer) - Played by Capt. Redblade - 3365 Space Moon Buggy Diane (Passenger) - Played by TrumpetKing67 - 9468 Vampyre Castle George (Passenger) - Played by The Legonater - 7093 Skeleton Tower Timothy (Passenger) - Played by Palathadric - 7627 Temple of the Crystal Skull

We missed one of the most important clues. Three dead Townies. What set numbers did they have? From Richard's list from yesterday: Jordan (Passenger) - Played by Tamamono - 4429 Helicopter Rescue Matthew (Passenger) - Played by Adam - 4441 Police Dog Van Scott (Engineer) - Played by CorneliusMurdock - 4201 Loader And Tipper All three Town sets. And no building challenge to speak of yet... Hmmmmmm....

You conveniently skipped my questions. What happened to your suspicion of Mary?

Well, there's the person you started the lynch on yesterday. Why is she not a more concrete candidate today? And what about Alice? Alice was also acting really Scummy yesterday. So, how did I rise to the top of your list? And what exactly have you done to prove to everyone how Townie you are and your word should be followed?

I'll answer right to it. I don't feel it and I'm not Scum. He didn't. Where did I say he told me he was the vig? And didn't I clarify that I'm not sure of the MOs? You should be able to guess why I would be suspicious of you.

It's jokes. Any news on the Alice situation. You know, those questions I asked you.

Boy, I typed that too fast. It looks like I'm saying I'm sure of the MOs. I'm not. I said Matthew was the serial killer, but I'm guessing vigilante. I should've read a little more thoroughly before hitting "Post". You can see I referred to him twice as vigilante and once as serial killer. My brain's a little fried lately. Please do forgive. I would have loved to have seen Alice lynched yesterday. I think she's a super Scum-bum. What else did this person say? In what ways did it sound like she knew who was on what side? Any anonymous quotes you can share?

The worst news of all of this is that the Engine Room looks exactly like the Engine Room in Excalibur. That is certainly a shitty start. Hatchet man is a serial killer, neck snapper is the Scum, Matthew was our vigilante. Was he blocked and killed? I'm disappointed that his action didn't go through, if he is in fact the serial killer. A baseball bat could mean blocker as well. If he was the vigilante, was he blocked and killed? That would have to mean he blabbed to the wrong person on Day One. For reasons I shall keep to myself for now, I've got my eyes on Lauren. Who happens to be the only one in the room with me right now. What's up, Lauren? How you doin'? Scott, sorry to see you go. I guess you're Rick now.

Umbrella stand.

Everyone? Is it a requirement? Welcome, Ferrik.

Stand.

I thought so at first, but the diameter appears to be too large.

I thought you changed that, DarkDragon. I must've mistyped it. Roops. I'll fix it.

eBay is not a good source of LEGO history. You can't honestly believe that would be the place to check. Try bricklink maybe? Anyway, the pieces on the left aren't FABULAND, by any stretch of the the imagination. On closer inspection, neither are the ones on the right. Sorry.

Actually, I could see this as Jordan's attitude if he were Town. He's been very bitter towards Mafia recently and that may actually be his mindset: "I'm Town. Screw you guys for suspecting me."

How does the Jordan lynch tell us anything about Alice? Because Alice voted for Mary? If Jordan is innocent, then it doesn't tell us that much, though...

There's certainly enough time to solidify a lynch on one or the other of them, since right now, nobody will be lynched...

Do you think we should change or do you agree we have the most to learn from Mary's lynch?

Lose does not equal loose. Learn the difference please. This is the theory I came up with watching people's reactions to the two candidates. I couldn't have come to it earlier, since it's based on the behavior up to this point. Did I not also offer that we lynch Mary? I need to check my pockets because I don't want to lose my loose change.

Best to leave the indexing to the forum's moderator. If you're going to take his work from him, it may be seen as pretentious or stepping on his toes.

Well, she has come back and made three summarizing posts and then finally placed a vote. She said she wanted to check things out, but mostly just found more reasons to summarize about the two current lynch candidates. I would think that if she was checking things out, as she claimed, she might find something a little more than just more of what everyone else had already been saying. Although I admit I do not know Alice very well, or if she would normally be likely to analyze player behavior, besides what people are telling her to be wary of.

I could agree with this, although Alice is looking the most Scummy to me at this point. I've spoken with both lynch candidates in private and don't think it would really hurt to lose either. By your analysis, Phil-if that is your real name-obviously phony, Mary's affiliation could give us the most to work off of. However, if she turns up Town, how much does that really give us? Maybe the early bandwagoners deserve some scrutiny? Maybe... but we've seen Scum show up all sorts of places. So this is likely to help only if analyzed down the road along with other information we pick up along the way. She turns up Town tomorrow, it doesn't really give us a solid lead for Day Two. If she turns up Scum, that would be more interesting, but I'm not sure that defying a bandwagon on Day One is necessarily a scum-tell, although I'm aware I may be biased since my name is on the list of the scrutinized if she is Scum. I am willing to change my vote to her if we all agree we have the most to learn from her death. What's nice is, say we all change our votes to Alice the Super Scum-meeeeeeh, we still have this original voting pattern to base things off of later, if we remember to keep it in our analysis. I'm not scattering anything. It's explosive. It scatters on its own.

Um......this bandwagon effect is making me uneasy about both lynch candidates here. Oh, did he? Thanks. I've been a bit scattered.