Scubacarrot

Besides the way I described in the quest, there could also be a third way, First roll the type of attack, then the confused effect, perhaps that would be the best option, Example: roll is damage, player is just damaged by the monster, but if the roll is attack, there is then another roll, to see if the attack is against the enemy or against allies.

Ooc: I think the confused way should be a bit different, i.e. it makes no sense for Knifk to attack Dak, so what I would have done is: odd attack > person > and then I think shield, crit and hit should be played on Knifk, but I do not think the damage or special should be played out, I would treat them as a miss. "I will attack the dog from the front row!"

You start with 16

Remember those surveys you find on the back of the instructions that say you can win something? Turns out they are worth doing, since I won something, I do not know what it is yet, but it should get here in 6 weeks, I am excited .

Thanks for the feedback, I had fun as for my first mafia game :) As to response for your questions: I actually made it way too complicated for myself, on day two, I had told Volcanicpanik that I actually was in contact with the doctor, it was only on day three that I revealed it was me. In retrospective, I would not have contacted the Wife of Darth, it seemed logical at the time, but as it turns out, plans like this do not actually work all that well (sorry Wife of Darth for indirectly getting you killed :/ ).

I got some more Brickforge right after the release of the printed and coloured trans-pieces, but now I wish I had waited for this, I really like the printed centaurs! Oh well, gives me an excuse to place ANOTHER order :))

"Haha! Die, snakes!" Guts switched his attacks to the Demon Bat, remaining in the front row.

What I was wondering, why was I blocked on Night 2, was that just luck on the scum's part, or did you know something?

Do you realise what you have done? Minifigures don't have noses, for good reason!! I had to google things to find out what they were from, but they seem to look pretty well, good job:thumbup: !

I just want to say, thank you very much Def for hosting. I had a ton of fun, and in my inexperienced opinion, it was hosted in a great way. Also, the pictures were great! Also thanks all players, it was a good game ;). This is my role PM: Hello. You are Sir Carrots, The Knight (scubacarrot) - The ideal of a medieval Christian man-at-arms. He has participated in no less than fifteen of the great crusades of his era. Brave, experienced, and prudent. You are Town. You are the town doctor. Each night, you must select one player (not yourself) and protect them from night kills. You can read more about your role here: http://mafiascum.net...hp?title=Doctor Oh, and somewhere along the way, you found this: You may choose to share this or keep it to yourself. It's up to you.

"Snakes, why did it have to be snakes..." Guts gets ready to attack the Green Snake from the front row!

"I say Sorrow should carry the torch, it is not like she is doing anything else, besides telling me to hurry up and make mysterious comments no one understands."

"Good old fashioned bribery." Guts said under his breath. Without saying another word he put his 15 gold in the raised hand of the captain.

Please, Pirelly. Coincidence? At this point, I do not believe in coincidences, neither should you. You say your protection does not need explanation? that makes you someone that does not think about their actions, or someone that has not thought their fake cover through? Second role claim? You forget I was more or less forced to say I was a vanilla by the wife of Darth, I am only saying this because I am more or less forced to do this because apparantly you are telling lies to Voltana. And this is where you go really wrong: You said you did not have the need to try to find allies behind the scenes. That makes you the worst doctor in the history of mafia games. A doctor's job is to protect people that matter, not just anyone (definitely not random people). So one of the things the doctor needs to do is find out who the cop is. That is why I have been in contact with Voltana. This is also the reason I contacted Wife of Darth so early in the game, to help find out who to protect, hell, I couldnt have known she would jump on me like a rabbit in spring. Last thing you say is that you urge people to look at the evidence, I am VERY interested in what evidence you mean. @Chromeknight: I am again very interested in your method for proving me. Last and likely least: I know it will not do very much good: but Voltana, please investigate me tonight: At this point in the game, investigation does not matter that much anyway.

Alright, right of the bat, I wanna say that this a last, very low play by the scum. It is obvious to me now that the scum are Pirelly and Christos. How fortunate that they both voted for me, and now try to frame me ONCE AGAIN. It is almost getting silly. I fear this is a plot to make Pirelly seem innocent and neutralize the real doctor, me. I am the doctor, let there be no doubt about that. I can not give solid evidence (it is in the rules). My protection pattern is the following: First night: I protected Christos Knight, I did not really have much to go on, so I went with the only person I had been talking to (other than the Wife of Darth, obviously), I did not have any suspicion to him at that point. Second night: I tried to protect Lady Cecily, but here is the interesting part: I got blocked. At that point I had been talking to both Voltana and Cecily, hinted at Voltana that I was the doctor and I had told Cecily, taking a risk, admittedly. We both thought that the scum would go for Voltana (It was not too hard to see that she was the cop), but It would not have been too hard for the scum to wait one night and then take her out, leaving us with a dilemma. What we did was giving hints in the day thread that we really wanted the doctor to protect Voltana, making believed so that she was protected. So instead of protecting Voltana, I went with Cecily, the only person I trusted 99% (next to Voltana and Zam). But as we all know, Cecily was killed, despite my (attempted) protection. So either the scum had known I was the doc since then, or they got lucky. I am leaning towards a combination of both. Third night: I protected Voltana, for obvious reasons, I figured it was not unlikely to think that the scum would go for the investigator. Instead, the scum went for Zam, the person that told someone else that HE was the investigator. (Coincidence? I leave that up to you.) For convinience sake I am going to leave the fact that Wully went for Zam as well out of my explanation, he told me in private why he went for him, and I believe it. I hope this explanation has restored some faith. Because I do not think it is unlikely someone to bring this up: I lied to you at the first day. Yes, I did. Deal with it. I am not going to give away my role to scum on the first day, aren't I? I am not happy that I have to come out in the open to say this, but I am kind of forced to. This only benefits the scum. (sure you can figure that one out) Final thing I will say before I go to bed: What about tonight? We know that there is a blocker in the game, I am going to assume it is scum (since the Wife of Darth claimed to be the town's one, remember). I am going to leave it at that, I will respond to any questions in the morning.

"Quiet, woman. Killing these people is not good idea, if word got out that this town is defenseless, it will be days before this place is turned into a pile of burning rubble by bandits."

"Wait, hold on. Are you serious?" Guts did not have the patience to reason with this foolish man, but perhaps it was not such a good idea to wipe out what seemed to be this little town's only form of defense, he hoped Knifk or Nerwen could talk some sense in the guy.

"I am ready to go." Guts's eyes started to burn a little bit at the thought of returning to the fluorescent shop.

Ok, @ Pirelly: Are you STILL doubting that Voltana is the cop? I find that hard to believe. You are 100% sure you say? Do not make claims like that, they make you look like a fool. "Investigate him!" I have no trouble with that, If (we should) we kill one scum tonight, it will only strengthen what I already said, and in that case, investigation is not really helpful anymore anyway, the result will be town. About the subject of Wully, Yes he COULD turn on us (the town ) but at this point, it is much easier for him to side with the town, as we have quite a good thing going on, 4 confirmed townies (confirmed as in what you believe, stop fighting the definition.) and only three suspects left.

Alright, Keeping in mind what has been said before, I will Vote: Pirelly Dabito (Piratedave). He is one of the two people that are most suspicious at this time to me.

I have been in touch with Voltana (and Zam) since day 2, and have known he was the Cop. To those who suspect me: If I were scum, wouldnt he have been killed that night? I think the way to go is to do this: Im pretty sure this has been said above me, but Keeping in mind this: we are with 8: Wully; SK, Me, Voltana, Dragus and Yulie are town. we have 3 people left: Christos, Skip and Pirelly. I think we should lynch one of those 3, and Wully should kill another one. That way, whatever happens, we will kill at least 1 scum, and maybe even both.

Okay some things: I can confirm the investigation. Sorry Yulie, you didnt start the bandwagon, I was confused with something else (and hungover, sorry for my maybe inappropiate post). I would like to remind you that I am in no way obliged to anwser your questions though... Please stop trying to make it look like the results we are bringing are false. It is suspicious, i'd say.

"That? Oh, there were two donkeys that went on a rampage. They had to be put down, you know how it goes. We were happy to lend a hand."

You know what, I am not going to awnser your questions? wanna know why? Everyday so far I have been accused, yet I have not had a single vote against me, wanna know why? Because every time I defend myself and it is obvious I am town. Why should I now defend myself? while the person that is asking is the person that started the bandwagon against the innocent victim of the lynch. The person that yesterday first said she was almost sure I was town, and then in the end accuse me while I had no time left to defend myself that day. If the accusation was serious, why didnt you vote for me? because there was no time. Why bring up the pointless question if there really is a cop. All we know is that there was a cop, at least on day two, because how else could we have known Wully was 'not town'. @dragus Instead answered some other questions? Stop making up things, I believe we have passed that point. If you still do not trust me, then fine, you are either a blind townie or the scum. I have my suspects, I know what I am going to do.

"Nicely done." Guts wondered if the people in the tavern had heard something from the fight, and how they would react if they did. Ooc: I should have 10 gold after the battle, 15 after loot divided, I started with 5, got 5 from the first battle, and now should have 15 :)