Scubacarrot

2 things that are wrong with your explanation, you say you will help the town, but why? your winning condition is to be the last man standing? so you will kill town as well. also you are forgetting that we may still have a vigilante killer, that maybe decided not to kill anyone last night (or he just died last night:hmpf_bad:) I am not changing my vote.

Guts mumbled something along the lines of 'fine with me'.

I am going to vote for Wully as well, but I would also like to know who you killed last night, and why? Getting the serial killer out of the way is a good thing, so I Vote: Wully Tintin (Wuntin).

Uhm, Excuse me, This could be me, But WHAT are you saying?? The facts are: 1. Volpana claimed he knows that Wully Tintin is not town. This fact on itself is very bold and a town would have no reason not to believe it unless someone directly contests the claim. Not town could mean two things, scum(witchbreed) or neutral, both of which are ENEMIES OF THE TOWN(!). If this claim would lead to the conviction of Wully Tintin and he would be found innocent, Volpana would without doubt be the next to be convicted, for giving us false information. Everyone agrees so far? 2. Wully Tintin then confirms he is the serial killer. He also states it is not a good idea to lynch him. Again a very bold statement, But us town have NO REASON not to believe this. Ill explain, The serial killer, is an enemy of the town (and the scum), for each night it kills someone, the objective of the serial killer is to kill EVERYONE and be the last man standing. The serial would therefore slowly kill off the town and the scum, so in the process, a lot of town WILL die, and needless to say, the less members of town there are, the better the position of the scum. The best target for a lynch would obviously be a confirmed scum, but a confirmed serial killer is the next best thing.

So basically you are saying, Wully, that you we cannot know if you are scum or the serial killer, but you are defenitly not town, thats no reason not to lynch you. In fact, I say you are absolutely the best candidate for lynching today.

This is megablocks, No one has said this., get your facts straight, I think YOUR behaviour is pretty suspicious, Ill back this up in a while, gonna read back on day 1.

"What exactly is IN the potion? And what is it for?"

all =)

Although I must say Zam's defense was almost non-existant, I do not think he is scum. I would like to point out that a person with penalty votes is an easy target for scum to frame, especially on the first day when no one has solid evidence yet. I think he is being framed by the scum. Also I do not think that his theory of town only getting pieces is too scummy, I think that is more a case of inexperience than anything else. I think that the Wife of Darth is the most suspicious, causing confusion and then claiming it is part of a plan... either you are scum or you messed up. Either way, I think it is best if you would be lynched, therefore I am going to Unvote: Skip Pudding(Skipper) and Vote: Wife of Darth (Darth Nihilus)

Tell us this then, If you know that, why DID you reveal your role?

"It is no problem, Nerwen! If the pegleg thug is dead by the time we get to attack, we automatically switch targets anyway!"

"One down, two to go!" Guts takes his sword out of the defeated thug, quickly wipes most of the blood off on the clothes of the fallen and moves in to attack the Pegleg Thug from the front row.

Hmmm, Very well. I Vote: Skip Pudding,(Skipper), simply because he hasnt said anything meaningful, I want to see if he has anything to say for himself.

Who claims that I am scum? As far as I know, Wife of Darth doesnt anymore. This has been covered before, WHY is it suspicious of me saying im a vanilla townie? I personally think that we should definitley look at the quiet people, laying low is suspicious, in my view.

Lord Shale reporting sir! My workers from the Arkbri Quarry are currently building a watchtower, to protect the precious sandstone from our thieving neighbours! I can also report that we need means of transporting our stone to Petraea and Qarkyr. for the transport to Barqa we use the river, naturally. Also I can report that we have recently aquired a mountain-mummy-mage and a squad of dwarven engineers, they are proving most valuable in the construction of our tower! (pics to follow)

When does the challenge end? I cannot find it anywhere?

Ok here is the deal, at the moment before I contacted Wife of Darth, she seemed innocent to me, so I contacted her, if she really wanted TOWN to contact her (which I am not sure about). I did because I wanted to get some insight in who I can trust and who not. I assumed she has some kind of role that she needs help with from other townies with roles OR she is scum. This is strengthened by her insistence of being investigated by the investigator. I ask, why? It is suspicious to say the least that you want to be investigated so badly. Think about it. A townie would not mind being investigated, sure, for he or she will be found innocent, heck, investigate me if you want, I do not care. But it is not helpful to investigate a person that you know is town, wasting one uncovering of a potential scum. Unless of course Wife of Darth has some kind of role and she needs help of the investigator. The other possibility is that she is the scum godfather and wants to put a false sense of trust in the town. As for the puzzle pieces, I think it is not unlikely to think that someone may have been given the objective to make a complete puzzle, in hindsight revealing my puzzle piece may not have been too smart.

How is stating that you are a normal towny suspicious? It would be the least dangerous role to reveal, as scum would probably go for an investigator or whatever. Also I would like to point the attention to the fact that if the Wife of Darth is investigated and turned out town, there is a possibility she is the scum godfather(mother?).

I wouldnt be surprised if everyone got a piece, From what Ive tried piecing the known pieces together, there are quite a few pieces. (Wow a lot of pieces in one sentence.) Here is my piece, the bottom right corner: I do not see any harm in showing my piece at this time, I suggest everyone else do the same. And Wife of Darth, You keep making the WRONG assumption, you keep saying that only a scum would want to know other's people's role, why would a towny not want to know if he or she can trust others? Basically what you are going for trying to make me suspicious is me wanting to find out your role, but me being scum could not be the reason for that, think about it. Also I would like to point attention that all out accusations like this are probably more in favor of scum, if those accusations have no real base.

Guts had a triomphantic smile on his face as he managed to stab the thug. Once more Guts moved in to attack Female Thug (Cutlass) from the front row.

Look at this reasoning, first he assumes scum will contact him, secondly he says that that would be a stupid thing to do. Why would it be a bad thing for a townie to find another person's role out? Secondly, why would it be stupid to reveal your role as a vanilla towny, you will likely not be a target for scum, if they believe you that is. I think you are trying to bend your reasoning so that people will believe you, I will stand by my statement, in the open this time, I am a vanilla towny, COME AT ME, WITCHES!

Blimey! Witches! In all my time as a knight I have slain saracenes, saved maidens and so forth! But never have I encountered Witches! May God's Fire come down on them I say!

"Barely human? Seems like your eyepatch is on the wrong eye, wench!" Guts casually unsheathed his blade as he moved in to attack Female Thug (Cutlass) from the front row.

I am ready to play.

"So, where is this 'healer' of yours." Guts said sceptically, walking just in front of Sorrow. He was not sure if the punch he gave the man had helped, but it did not matter, at least they had gotten something out of the man. As they walked, he noticed that Sorrow did not make any sound as she walked, he shivered, even the best assassins have footsteps.