Kadabra

Which is why I shall Vote: Boris Wheeler (TheBoyWonder).

Been trying to get y'all to notice that for a while. Shoulda just copy/pasted all his posts, huh?

This is defensive. The 'that's all' especially is sort of passive-aggressive.

The timing of the kills is indicative of jack, guys. Seriously? Have none of you read this? No matter who the poisoner was we wouldn't have seen poison kills until we did. And furthermore, no, our blocker did not get lucky last night. Our blocker got lucky one or two nights ago, or the poisoner didn't feel like killing one or two nights ago, or there will be a day kill today. So Mencot is not proven to be the poisoner, unless someone can confirm that he was blocked one or two days ago. When you're analyzing a role for information, make sure you understand how the role works. Come on, guys.

I'd love to hear our role cop's results as well. Also, why so defensive, Boris? Nervous now that your team is down one?

My condolences. We can wait as long as you need, this is way more important than a game.

The first is Flash and the third is Superman, right? I think I sort of get what's going on but I'm not quite sure. (The blue fire as the lightning that transforms Barty Allen threw me off, I thought it was a character who had ice powers or something! )

No, the host usually decides one way or another before the game and sticks with it. It just felt to me like some of you were assuming Kenneth=poisoner because there wern't poisoner kills, then there were poisoner kills after fhomess subbed in. I'm just saying that we wouldn't have seen poisoner kills until Night 2/Day 3 regardless of who the poisoner was, theday kill is still very irregular and should be looked into.

Poisoner kills are time delayed. Even if Kenneth was sending in actions, we wouldn't have seen them. Poisoner kills occur either during the next night or during the day after that night, depending on if the host wants the poisoned to be able to perform another NA. i.e. Poisoner targets Person A on N1. D2, Person A is fine. N2, Person A sends in action and it goes through. D3, Person A dies. Or Poisoner targets Person A on N1. D2, Person A is fine. N2, Person A dies, rendering his/her action meaningless.

With a post that doesn't amount to jackshit?

You want us to Bieber you?

Well crud nuggets. If Tristan is telling the truth, then we're missing a vig and an investigator. Considering that I think Boris is scummiest t right now and that Tristan's game has been very pro-town until this fiasco today, I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt. It'd be nice to get the role cop to investigate you, Tristan, so if you come up "Janitor" or "Killer" or something we could know for sure you're scum (since the town killer is apparently dead, the only remaining killers should be the poisoner and the scum! ). Although Rolecop is far inferior to cop when it comes to determining allegiance, it's at least better than nothing.

I'd like more than "slight scumread" if you're going to cast suspicion on me, Molly, because as it is I can't defend myself. Anyways, due to the fact that Boris has failed to defend himself adequately, Vote: Boris Wheeler (TheBoyWonder)

Which group of six are you keeping a close eye on? People differ between the lists. Or do you just mean Prudence, Ienneth, and Abigail? You were called out for bad logic (private mode = scummy, despite the facts that a) he was on private before the game even started and b) there are other people also on private yet you didn't call them out) that metagaming happened to be a part of. Everyone else is calling you out on behavioral analysis that happens to span multiple games. Metagaming in and of itself, while not quite in the spirit of the game, is not scummy. The way you used it was.

Wow, heavy stuff going on here. Losing the investigator is a big deal, especially since we haven't gotten to utilize her to the best of her abilities prior to the unfortunate death. Knowing that Jessica was the investigator actually makes me think Boris being scum is even more likely. He probably saw me accusing her, then jumped on in the hopes that a bandwagon against the investigator would take her out for him, then jumped off when either his scumbuddies reeled him back in or he realized on his own that a bandwagon wasn't going to form.

I find it highly likely that the Poisoner is the SK, so I'd love to hear suspicions on who he is. SKs are sneaky little buggers that are very much underestimated by the town (Remember Harriet Slutter? We didn't lynch a known SK and look how well that turned out).

Crud. Now that the poisoner's kills are coming in, this is looking a lot more urgent. I still say Wheeler is our best bet because of the points I outlined yesterday (sheep-y, compliant, wishy-washy, bad logic).

I totally did get Michael confused with Boris. Sorry about that! Yeah, what I meant was that Boris has been very much a sheep, and there was the metagame thing, and his quickness to Unvote Jessica looks like he's trying to avoid confrontation - scummy! Unvote: Michael Thompson (Mencot) Vote: Boris Wheeler (TheBoyWonder)

We're in agreement. This is weird - he sheeps me, then turns around almost immediately. Did he realize it wasn't going to bandwagon and not want to be an outlier when voting analysis comes round tomorrow? Michael, you've been acting weird all three days and you've contributed nearly nothing of interest to any discussion. Unvote: Jessica (jamesn) Vote: Michael Thompson (Mencot) At least Jessica has added ideas to the discussion.

Right now, I'm actually interested in Jessica. I find it odd that the extent of her contributions today is jumping on the Connie wagon without bringing anything new to the table, in essence just sheeping, and then she comes in and makes some post about a metagame tactic and then leaves? It looks to me very much like she's trying to appear helpful without actually pointing any fingers anywhere but where they're already being pointed. Therefore, I will Vote: Jessica (jamesn).

I'm pretty sure third party reads third party when they flip, so I think it was probably a poisoner and that Zachary's allegiance will be revealed tomorrow morning when the lynch and scum kill are. Or it was a mod kill and the allegiance will be revealed tomorrow. But I don't think you can janitor a day kill, at least not from anything I've read.

He seems to think that a miller claim=scum, so he's either dumb or trying to get Sheridan offed because he's scum.

With unlimited unvotes, FoS's really aren't needed... Anyway, I'm reluctant to believe in the idea of a cult just because Captain Minnow is pretty new to this sort of situation, and cults tend to only appear in towns run by incompetent or experienced sheriffs, and I don't think Minnow is incompetent. With how Zachary is acting, though, I wouldn't put Jester beyond him, though!

Thank you. Keep talking. This makes sense. I think that scum probably split between being on the Esther bandwagon and not on it, because there's always the "I-told-you-so" route but there's also the fact that the Esther bandwagon was so dang big it was easy to hide there. In my opinion those who jumped on after supporting Esther once she claimed should be scrutinized, a sort of 'easy way out' of analyzing other players presented it and they took it. That could be lazy town or nervous scum.

By Flutterdash spans the boundaries of rivaling toy companies to bring love to all the rainbow-colored and yellow/pink creatures alive. It cannot be denied.