Tamamono

Wow, great game as usual, Hinck! The sets were superb, the characters unique, and the storyline very creative! Congrats to the scum! I have to admit, I was pretty lost at times (), but I still had a great time following along.

"Yes, lets... do... whatever it is Sam wanted us to do." "Err, with all this falling-down-skull-marked-doors-and-killing-members-of-the-League-of-Invision, I forgot what we were doing."

Okay, thanks, I'll keep that in mind! Flipz, I bet you could write a book on good roleplaying.

I have to admit, my roleplaying for Tomas is pretty nonexistent. An artifact might help, now that I think about it... This is a problem with lots of multiplayer games these days. One person gets a special item from a quest or whatever, and then everyone wants one. But if everyone had one, it wouldn't be special, now would it?

Meh, in my opinion, artifacts should be exclusive to quests. Make 'em as complicated as you like, they'd 'lose the magic' so to speak if they were made readily available. I think of them almost like 'spoils of war', and the fact that each one is unique makes them all the more special. Docken's Dread Hat and Nur's Loaded Die are both incredibly unique artifacts that really only seem 'right' when they're exclusive to that particular character. Just my two cents.

"Yes, I think this would probably be the best idea. We can go and hunt for all the ingredients we need, and then, when we've found all we can, we can get the rest from the Guild. Perfect."

Exactly. I find it very likely that 3PO is performing a last-second bus to try and put Master Monn in the clear.

"Absolutely. Let's go."

I don't know, I'm just making silly assumptions. Don't mind me.

To be perfectly honest, I don't care if the SK keeps killing off quiet, inactive townies. He/she will probably even hit a Sith at some point. No, the Sherlock will be using his investigator action for the remainder of the game. If we need to kill/shrink the SK in order to win, then we can do that at the end.

Yes, I trust that Sherlock told no one but us about his results. No, Zane is not the protector, Totoro is the protector. I don't consider Zane a possibility because I find it unlikely that he was the source of the leak, because I don't think Sherlock would have told Zane anything if he suspected Zane was scum.

My thoughts exactly.

To be perfectly honest, I have no idea. Sherlock never explained it to me in great detail. All I know is that he's a shrink who finds red lightsabers. In any case, that's still useful, right?

Well, thank you for your trust, but from your point of view, I must be scum. The fact that you're ignoring that means that you're not trying to find scum which means you are scum. Game, set, and match. However, if you truly are town, I promise that I will do everything in my power to go on and win this thing for the town. I find it laughable how you think you're in a position to call others scummy for buddying 3PO. Aren't you the one who's been insisting that he get investigated before lynched? I think it's likely that 3PO is the Godfather after all, or the Sith have a Tailor that will make 3PO appear innocent to investigation. Don't be so obvious next time, Euna! It's not just because Master Corobb suspected him, it's because Hugar Sith should not have known about the shrink. Knowing about the lightsaber, sure. The scum usually have an action that messes with informative actions, and it may be that lightsaber colors are the MO of investigation this game, and the scum knew that. However, it was never stated that the cop and the shrink were the same person until Hugar said it himself. Where could he have gotten such information? From me, Master Corobb, 3PO, Sherlock, or Zane. I certainly didn't give out the information, and Master Corobb said that he didn't either. Zane's a possibility, but Sherlock claims to have not told anyone - and I assume that includes Zane. So, who does that leave? That leaves 3PO.

The way you voted with the person under the most scrutiny today is duly noted. With all due respect, 3PO, the only thing you can do at this point is try to take me down with/instead of you. I find it absolutely hilarious how you're trying to take the 'high road' and not FoSing me.

I really think this is the right thing to do today. Vote: C-3PO (Brickdoctor)

Tomas hands the Leader the list of items they need. "Would it be possible for you to give us some, if not all, of these?"

Even if Master Corobb's death wasn't the work of the scum, the fact that he flipped town still meant that if one of us Three C's was scum, it's you. All other explanations for how Master Sith knew about the shrink and the lightsaber are incredibly far-fetched. Exactly. If 3PO flips scum (which I think it's very likely he will), those who have been trying to distract us from him will be under scrutiny. Yes, I see no reason for him to bus two of his fellow scum in the same day, so it's very likely that he was converted. It actually makes perfect sense, to be honest. Was there anyone who really believed what Windu said? Anyone at all? I think his plan was to pretty much clear a townie with his accusations, and then to convert that townie. Obviously, someone who the scum tried to claw at as they were dying would become a trusted townie in no time, right? Corobb wanted him to check to see if he was insane. Please note for the future, guys, that sanity tests should only really be performed when you don't have someone being lynched whose affiliation will pretty much confirm your sanity. I've talked to Sherlock about it, and he said he's told no one. As for Roron, why would he accuse me and 3PO of being scum if he had told other people about the shrink and the lightsaber?

"You didn't want this? Then what did you want?"

The protector (Totoro) has said that his target was not attacked on either night. And, as far as I know, the blocker didn't block anybody important night 1. I think a conversion is very likely, and I think it was performed on 3PO. This too is a possibility, hence why I'm wary of having him investigated (he'll turn up innocent if he's the Godfather, after all). However, I find it more likely that he was converted on Night 1. When did I ever say that you had contact with him outside the thread? Slip! You're pushing the idea that we should have him investigated awfully hard - if you think he's been converted, why not kill him now? You are absolutely reeking of scum, and you better bet that if 3PO flips Sith, you'll be next. That doesn't change the fact that you were presenting them when it was obvious that the no-kill pact had been broken and one of us needed to come forward with Master Corobb's information. At first, you even acted like nothing had happened, and only started to accuse me when it was obvious I was adamant about you. Face it, scummo, you've been caught.

The way you suggested not one but three suspects immediately after we learned of Master Corobb's death definitely made it look like you were trying to distract me. I'm currently talking to Sherlock, and if he was the leak, we'll know soon. I don't like how you're shrugging off the 3PO case as a 'gut feeling' (even when there is real evidence that he's scum) and continuing to tunnel on Master Vos. If 3PO is scum, then you are too.

Yes, I am quite sure of Sherlock's 'towniness'. Why would he have brought forward an investigation result on a member of his own team? Yeah, it would've been. One thing you need to learn is that scum don't fake investigation results this early, especially not on their own teammates. That's a good point, but if you had been there in our private messages when Master Corobb had first died, you'd think differently. He acted like nothing had happened, and, like I said before, brought up all sorts of other suspicions even when it was obvious that the 'no-kill' pact had been broken. If I had been scum, and 3PO was responding like that, I would have let it be and gone on with the day. Sherlock investigated Master Corobb.

Did I ever say that they were weak or didn't make sense? No, I did not. These are very good suspicions, and I think at least one of these people is likely to be scum (if not all of them), but you were throwing out suspicions that were fairly irrelevant when it was obvious that you'd be the one under scrutiny when Master Corobb died. So that you could use that WIFOM. It's another case of reverse psychology. But, in all seriousness, Master Corobb was obviously suspicious of the both of us, and I suppose you were feeling threatened. There's no other real explanation for why you killed him. And which "facts" am I missing? Sherlock said to Master Corobb that he hadn't told anybody. If he had, I can only think of one person he would have told - Zane. Now, of course it's possible that Zane is scum, but I'm talking to Sherlock, and I'm inclined to believe that it is, in fact, you who's scum. Okay, well, I must admit, that statement by Rover Master Monn is pretty troubling. Not only does his speculate on the number of scum, he does it in a sort of way which suggests that he knows for sure how many there are. However, I'd much rather deal with 3PO today. Not only do the facts point to him, but his squirming under pressure pretty much guarantees his guilt. When did I say you were grasping for straws? That's right, never. You're inferring too much from my statements. I said you threw other, perfectly good, suspicions in front of you even when it was obvious you'd be under scrutiny today. Yes, Master Vos has been incredibly unhelpful thus far, but don't worry, I'm working on getting him and several other people checked out and cleared. You doubt he's scum, huh? Could it be because he's your teammate? An investigation might not actually be that bad of an idea, though. However, there's always the small possibility that Windu was telling the truth and 3PO is the Godfather. Please, if anyone investigated him (with a role cop action, a tracker action, or whatever) after Windu's shocking 'revelation', please step forward and tell me in private as soon as possible. Yes, I suppose that's possible as well. Very often in these situtations, the investigator will claim to be in contact with the 'investigator' to protect himself. Good thinking. However, that still does not change the fact that Hugar Sith knew about the shrink and the lightsaber, and the only logical explanation for that is that 3PO told him. Of course you have a say! The daily vote is for each townie to have his or her say in the lynch. If you don't think 3PO is guilty, you can vote for someone else. Even though I strongly believe 3PO to be scum, I respect that others may not share the same sentiments as me, and that's perfectly fine. I just want to convict scum again. And, to borrow some of 3PO's WIFOM, why would I be this bold as scum? If I were scum and 3PO was town, I'd know he'll flip town after he'd been killed, and I know who's next on the chopping block if that happens. No, I assure you, Master Corobb was not Sherlock. In fact, Sherlock just got in contact with me earlier telling me his results. They're not particularly good results, but at least he's still alive. Nah, I think Jedi Vebb is town. He wouldn't have defended Windu so actively if he was scum too. However, good point about Master Monn and Jedi Vebb not being on the same team. It's interactions like this that give us the most information.