Okay, first off, so sorry I wasn't here during this very heated conversation! I was taking a short rest.
While I was resting, I had a stroke of genius - a way to get around the no-unvotes rule. Instead of voting like we normally would, we can simply put our votes in this format: FoS: ____ (____) much like Master Clickity-Chirp has done. Once the majority has agreed on a FoS, we can simply pile our votes on like we would if we could unvote. This lets potential PRs (power roles) claim before their fate is sealed. So, what does everyone think? Yes? No?
Also, I think it would be wise for us to all be very liberal with our FoSes and accusations - if you suspect somebody, call them out. The more interactions we have between people, the better chances we'll have of catching the scum.
You said before that you wanted to not lynch, but here you're saying that voting is our best weapon against the scum, yet you don't want to use it? A lightsaber is also a very useful weapon, but you don't just stand there waiting for your opponent to fall on your blade when you're fighting, do you?
If you've read the archives, then you'd know that this 'to vote or not to vote' issue has been discussed to death. Why bring it up? You know it'll get shot down, and even if it doesn't, you know we'll end up lynching anyway. Nobody ever goes through with those plans of not lynching.
FoS: Ahsoka (MacK).
Your lack of new discussion is disturbing.
Yes, this is definitely possible. Master Corobb's initial suggestions were pretty ludicrous, but 3PO has been actively siding with him and defending him. However, I get the feeling that 3PO is loyal because of how proactive he's been, so that negates the theory of him defending his scumbuddie (if my reads are correct, that is).
This statement isn't very 'pro-town'. Yes, we understand that Master Corobb threw out some weird theories and started metagaming began acting paranoid, but you (and several others including Nahdar) continue to push him. Surely you know that scum wouldn't put their necks on the line so early? No, I think it's very likely that Master Corobb is town who was simply trying to help.
I too have read through the archives, and I've found a very interesting trend. Time after time, one loyalist puts his/her neck on the line by being too radical, and then the scum jump on him/her like a pack of rabid dogs. I believe this is what's going on here. Plus, your statement is incredibly fencesitty. "Well, this thing about you isn't very town... But you could still be town. I don't know." Scum like to stay fencesitty so they can jump to whichever side is the most convenient at the moment.
FoS: Mace Windu (Nightshroud99)
Yes, I cast a second FoS.
Actually, if nothing else comes up, I would love a Master Windu lynch today. He has been tripping my scumdar all day.
Let's wait and worry about night actions after we've sorted out today's lynch, please.
This statement strengthens my FoS on Ahsoka.
Nahdar, I find it disturbing how you and Master Windu seem to have teamed up on Master Corobb. Like I said above, scum doesn't put their neck on the line this early - nevermind ask for investigators to contact them. Why are you pushing this?
Discussing hypothetical situations helps no one.