Hi everyone
Well guys, I don't want to be rude, but I think that the POTC sets are not really good, and I can't understand how in the world can someone consider that theme very interesting, if that person knows something about Classic Pirates.
Yesterday I saw a thread with a poll, wich asks what theme we prefer: classic pirates, POTC, or both of them. I thank God the winner option are the Classic Pirates, but nearly 50% people voted for the other options. Can't believe it.
The reasons why POTC are far worse than Classic are evident looking at the sets, if we consider the number of minifigs, pieces contained, variety of sets, etc. Ok, there are some new minifigs, some new pieces, etc. Nothing really important.
However, that's not the main reason I think POTC doesn't rocks at all. The main reason is that these theme is absolutely unplayable, because is unstructured. Let's check it out... what we got? A bunch of sets, representing some scenes from the four movies, most of the sets have nothing to do with the others. There are no complete factions, only three or four british soldiers, three or four indians, etc. No bases, no armies, etc.
What makes a theme playable? A logical structure: Different factions, with their own "armies", boats and bases. Like Classic Pirates have. We know other examples: Castle, Star Wars, etc.
POTC are a bunch of isolated sets, "look-at-me-but-don't-play-with-me", with a lack of possibilities to create new adventures (except making the movie scenes).
Excuse my ortography, english is not my native language.
Thanks everyone.