Piratedave84

Why are you so anxious to see how we perceive your move? For all it's worth, I am enclined to believe you are town; no scum in their right mind would pull that crap on day 1. you said you would return as Coyote if investigvated but were you told what happens if you were to be killed or lynched? Would we then be able to assert your true allegiance?

TRISTAN! LEAVE MY WALLET ALONE! GIVE IT BACK! It has not even been 15 minutes and we have a claim. I cannot conceive that claiming such a role, without provocation, this early would be a lie or a ploy. Sheridan why is it exactly that you decided to claim this early?

Patrick confirmed; avatar to follow

Yes! More mafia!! I'm in! 1. Recently: EB I, Pearl, EB II, Sorcerer's balls, Mafia Mafia; my whole history is in my profile 2. Yes; I always have time for some mafia 3. I was SK recently an it was quite enjoyable!! I would however love to have a chance to be the cop!

About that, Rufus also contacted me to ask where the chart was. What has happened there was that a new version (not intended to be shared at that point) had been saved under the same file name and consequently replaced the original file on BS when uploaded. When I realized that, I moved the new file to Flickr not realizing it also meant that the original file was gone as a result. Should penalty votes have been issued, I would have accepted them as it was my error. More on balance: We can say all we want about the pills and the randomness but seeing how the game ended and was almost won by all 3 parties, I say the balance was pretty good; random at times but all things considered, it was pretty well balanced.

You mean the choices offered when selecing the new rule? if so, I have to agree.

Thank you Zepher, this was an awesome game to play and watch!!!! Personally I don't really have any complaints about the setup, it was pretty clear from the get-go and we were asked for our input when the sign-up thread was posted. The pills sure kept things interesting; I have to agree that in the end, results and actions had more to do with 'luck' than with strategy but it made the game uncertain; up until the very last minute, it could have went any which way SK, scum or town could have won this game! Personally, it was (IMO) my best game; I had so much fun compiling results and trying to analyze them (4 out of 7 scums/neutral pegged in my first one and 5 in my second one).

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That was fun! Thanks Zepher!

Have a poutine; it'll fill you up!

In Québec our stapple food is called Poutine, it's fries topped with cheese curds and smothered in hot gravy; it's trully decadent and is arguably the best hangover cure!! Although it can now be found pretty much anywhere in Canada, I believe this is the most well-known French Canadian food! Curds: Poutine: Tsin Tsao is a chinese beer but I believe it was originaly brewed by German settlers

Illustrious werewolf .... I count 13 votes for the Usurper based on your tally; mine was counted twice, even then there would be 14 votes ... PGO has yet to vote, so does Snake ...

It's a placebo

Originaly I suggestes that we lynch a lurker/inactiveplayer and gave Stump as an example and mentionned that we may want to lynch him as part of my analysis. At that point we did not have any other solid lead, so to me lynching a lurker was a good idea. I never pushed for a lynch; I don't know where this idea comes from. Several people then pointed out that it may not be the best idea and I agreed with them; this is ehat I think you are referring to as me no longer wanting to lynch him (even though I never actually pushed for his lynch). I think be may be town based on how scum have voted for him in the past. He was also cleared by role player earlier; I don't understand why you want me to prove he is scum. Where in my post do you see Me referring to Stump as scum?

How did you come to that conclusion?

I see that now! Thanks for voting ... Once called out!

I did not see it, I went back and cross-read the thread and I can't really see it ... maybe I'm blind. I went back and analysed voting patterns and noticed that NPC had voted outside the 'norm' on both precedeeing days and that today he was the last one (as of this post) to vote; a change in my analysis may be waranted; NPC may be scum. Here are the voting charts for day 1, 2 and 3 Here's the pill list, their effects and whom picked what when: Why have the goon and PGO not voted yet? Based on the events of today, we need every vote we have and they know it, so why not vote? Royalty is in fact a Placebo Further to my assertion that Witch is scum, she has voted last (second last for today), on both lynch; she in fact voted dead last on the vote for Male Lover. I just went to his profile and it shows last active as "private"; he also has truned of the "visitor" option; metagemey as hell but it sure looks scummy to me! Trying to hise something?

By mistake; his behaviour seems town plus he appears to be trusted by the more vocal townies so I say town. In french it's oups; force of habit!!

Vote : Usurper (TrumpetKing) oups! Here it goes: Took me about 2 hours to red the thread and here are my comments: I am town -I know this as per my PM from the werewolf NPC and Talking animal are likely town seeing asd they were both accused and scrutinized by known scum - Unconfirmed Female Lover is likely town based on his leading the charge against Legodad - Unconfirmed Cult Leader and Role Player are 'confirmed' town PR's Stump may be town; Male lover had voted for him day 1 - Unconfirmed FDL & Role Cop appear to be town and seem trusted by Role Player - Unconfirmed This leaves: BONAD, PGO, Witch and Goon as being "really unconfirmed". Based on my building a case (or truing to) against PGO and FDL's willingness to follow me, I theorize that PGO may be Town leaving the scum team as being: BONAD, Witch, Goon, Usurper and Snake Charmer along with LegoDad As of when I started to type this, the Goon and PGO had yet to vote.

Sigh! I have very little time and cannot discuss the events of the day until later; sorry! unvote: Snake Charmer (Darth Potato) vote: Ursuper (Trumpetking)

@ First day lynch, I'm super busy today, but I'll address your concerns tomorrow (RL time). Let me just say that I was not opposed to the lynch of the stump, I was trying to explain how I thought he waranted scrutiny. Don't try to shift the focus towards me. @ Kdm; I revealed my pills, both of them, to Male Lover and it was also public in my chart. vote: snake charmer (Darth Potato) *female lover; I revealed my pills to Hinck

royalty pill for me please. I am SO down to lynch the snake charmer! I would also support a lynch of the stump! The fact that Charmer has 2 penalty votes would enable us to lynch him with only our town votes; then again, anyone not voting is scum. I think that lynching Charmer will give us a lot of insight for the next days!! Also Vote: Yes for Reveal All Plan

I'm TOTALLY down with the idea of sharing our pills and ensuring that known town PR get them. Both my pills were placebos, i will update my chart and post it here tomorrow with all the new info. RL has me swamped tonight an I applogize for my absence. The cult leader's claim is very bold; how certain are we of the aliegance of the other inventor?

You quoted an old post there .... So you are not going to address the case I made against you? Did you read it? I would call my decision to vote for you as pretty informed unlike your decision to just pile on the bandwagon of ML; would you not say? How is fake voting not working? it has generated leads and discussion which led to accusations and subsequently real votes, I would say that it works. Feel free to come back and address thes points any time you want ... oh! you disapeared again!

There's one guy in Gramby (rapidos or something like that) that sells a ton of Lego, including older sets; he's a bit far though As far as play value goes, totally worth a detour! Thay also carry the largest assortment of Playmobil I have ever seen!