Piratedave84

Are yout trying to see if you can shift the lynch away from your buddy??

There was a quote of a quote here... Can't seem to quote the quote of the quote. This seems forced and does not reflect at all him telling you to be wary. Wait ... Is it him telling you to be wary or you telling him ... Looks like these PMs don't really reflect what you told us ... Just saying. That's exactly what I thought of when I saw the PMs, seems forced, staged. I'm pretty sure mike and I made fake PMs together in one of the last games as well. So I would not put it past him to do it again.

If I may; how do you know Foorth did not claim? He posted he'd be away but has since logged in and seemingly would have had enough time to claim to Molly. Also Vote: Anthony (jluck)

Sorry guys, RL has been nuts this weekend. I'll be more active day 2.

Hey I'm here. Sorry I got sidetracked by RL. An early observation is that the vote is crazy spread out; not a typical day one voting-wise. I think we need to organize our thoughts a bit better to reach a lynch today. I read a couple of things that seemed odd but I really need to thoroughly read the thread before casting a vote. I'll be back later with some thoughts.

I was sure I had confirmed here .... maybe I forgot to hit post or something .... I'm sooo sorry I'm here

I'm in! 1.) Have you played in a Mafia game before? If not, do you get how it works? This my first game ever 2.) Will you be pretty free to play for however long this plays out (excluding the week of the 22nd, of course)? Yes 3.) Rate, from 1 to 5, with 5 being the highest, how upset will you be with me if I don't get these pictures and days out on a totally prompt schedule (these pictures take a long time to edit)? 4; mafia must run on time! 4.) If, in case you get angry, take it out on Danny, yea? Sure 5.) If you were in a plane crash, what magical destination (like in Lost) would you prefer it crash on? North Pole; we could see Santa! 6.) Is Scotland, or is it not, the most peaceful and beautiful place in the entire world? I'm pretty sure it's not ...

Common you cant just say that! What's the theme? Teaser picture? Anything? Pleaaaaase!

Classes could randomly named, perhaps using names like Schooner, sloop, etc. and giving a few examples of previous builds to get a sense of what the ship can do/look like. Then you assign a value to this ship which is it's "strenght" and roll the dices! You could just name the classes, assign strenght ratings and let builders loose in terms of what the ship looks like. The constant would be the rating and not the ship per say. This would allow you to pit a micro build against a 100 stud SOTL

Overhang will be normal, we can use the "top" of the hull sections to determine the lenght. Anyways, one stud will not really allow for the placement of an additional cannon so it may not be advantageous to do so.

Agreed, sections were just an example; we know one section is 8 studs so we can easily convert this to stud lenght.

Do you mean which official set falls under which category? Could we maybe divide classes by hull sections, mast counts or armament? Hull sections could be a great way to simplify the rating of our ships: 1 section: sloop 2 sections: Schooner 3 sections: Brig 4 sections: Frigate 5 sections +: SOTL or armamant-wise: 2-4 Cannons: sloop 5-8 Cannons: Schooner 9-16 Cannons: Brig 16-24 Cannons: Frigate 24 + Cannons: SOTL Thoughts?

Why didn't you guys kill me?

... Told you DF was scum! So how would you guys have handled the claim? I also have a question about Medium; I had investigated her night 2 and knew she was town. I'm not sure my play was optimal but I could not just sit there and let her be lynched. How would you have dealt with this?

I'm not sure about this move; I'm not ready to let Derrick live seeing he's scum. From my point of view Derrick is the only confirmed scum. This will turn into a no lynch and we will lose. Derrick is convinced I'm scum and I that he is so we will naturally vote for each other and Theo and you will vote for Lynn. Lynn will obviously not vote for herself. We can't afford a no-lynch or a mis-lynch. I don't know what to say to settled this. I'm ready to incur the penalty and share my role PM with you.

Derrick will not vote for his scum buddy.

It's fine, just throw your stick at Derrick!! Lynn's silence through all this is deafening!

This whole thing is crazy I don't even know where to start ... From my point of view, it's not. It's you or Lynn, well technically both, but for today as far as I'm concerned it's you. No, no; you said Theo was town because you know he is due to your being scum. Don't try and say otherwise; you slipped. You could have used player, person, participant, suspect, human, etc. you chose townie because you know he and I are town. Of course town, what did you think we were discussing here? I really don't understand your statement here ... I don't know that you're town, I know you're scum based on your fake claim. Please clarify what .... did I not say 50 times I know you're scum? How did I ever imply, say or quoted that you were town? Again please clarify.

sorry, it's (well was at this point) an "or" situation in the context of the lynch. You're right that's it's an "and" situation in the context of who's scum. No, I was suspicious of Matthew's lack of contribution, his not wanting to take control and his general attitude in the situation. He did come across as particularly scummy BUT he was suspiciously low key. huh ... if we're all town then WTF are we doing here exactly?? This sentence is weird ... so we're all town although some of us are town ... but really you're scum? right? Theo is closer to being confirmed than you are ... just saying. What would you rather do? Play the odds and survive another day or give the game to the scum? See above Why Lynn? as far as I'm concerned anyone was good. realistically there is a godfather BUT like I said earlier, at lynch-or-die we need to play the odds and lynch the most suspicious person (Derrick) that has yet to have any PR results on them. You may well be the godfather, or Derrick, or Lynn BUT we can't afford to lynch on a hunch here. Derrick lied to us by claiming cop; I am the cop. The bottom line is simple; lynch me and town loses, lynch Derrick and we have a shot at winning.

BOOM! There's no way for you to state that Theo is town unless you know he's town. You didn't investigate him so as such you can't know. I knew you'd slip eventually!

I claimed because I knew we could not afford to lynch town again today. I decided that the best way to handle my results was to come out as the cop straight away. I didnt handle Desiree's result as I should have but iNhad to do something without claiming; it was weak but I had nothing else. I investigates Desiree because she was the second most suspicious person. I investigated you because of your relative inactivity; I didn't find you particularly scummy but you usually are way, way more up front and bold when you're vanilla. Regarding Lynn or Derrick; Theodore is 'cleared' by virtue of not having been seen killing, like I said earlier it's better to play the odds at this point. Since I'm the cop, Matthew is cleared by my investigation and Theo is not a suspect right now; yeah it's Lynn or Derrick. Derrick is scum, his claim is not legitimate and if we fail to lynch him, we will lose this game. vote: Derrick (Dragonfire)

Keep digging your hole buddy! Lynn will vote for you to save her megablocks; it's you or her ... So yeah you're screwed! I have to give you credit for your high post count and your eagerness to contribute in this game. You could probably have swayed my vote today had it not been for your fake-claim. I didn't cop you because I was pretty sure you were town until today; your scum game was on point. Good job! Too bad you won't get to win this time!

HA! You're toast buddy!!! Thanks for outing yourself like this; it makes our job much, much easier. There is no way, that you would have cop'ed Alec on day 2 because he was under no scrutiny. The goal here was to catch scum and with such a little pool of candidates to pick from, you HAVE to pick the second suspect. Your justificatiopn for the investigation is weak; you will be lynched! There's no way our second suspect (Lynn) will not vote for you so we already have majority! :happydance: (I wish this existed!) Read: "There is a godfather and no strongarm killer" Thanks for the headsup!

You are by no means confirmed so yeah we can suspect you BUT in your hurry to defend yourself, you failed to notice (or chose ot ignore) that both Matthew and I were willing to trust you and lynch Derrick or Lynn. Speaking of which, who'd you rather? From your previous comment it seems you'd be willing to lynch me .... I 100% agree with this; it was an intense struggle of to claim or not to claim ... I saw a weak opening in building a case on Trenton and thought I could pull it off without incriminating myself. Had Desiree not claimed, I would have. The dilema was letting a know towny (known to me) die versus staying alive and possibly netting a scummo.