As a big Lego SW fan like most of you guys, it's really hard to choose between the older and the current SW sets, it's like choosing which of your kids is your most favorite. The most simple answer is that I simply love all SW sets, from the first ones to the current ones.
Though, in the context of comparison, of course the current SW sets are much better looking, because of the introduction of new pieces that weren't available during the early years of Lego SW. But still, you gotta admit that during the early days, the first SW sets (X-Wing, Y-Wing, TIE, etc) were very much appreciated by most fans.
Regarding the CW sets, I agree that the only major criticism is the cartooney faces of the minifigs, but you have to admit the sets are still pretty cool.