Alright, let's finally get down to it!
Alexis - I was a little worried picking Alexis for this quest. There have been times in the past where I've selected her, or seen her selected, and she's sort of fallen off the face of the earth. I think, however, that Alexis was a great choice for this quest. While the rest of the party built a bizarre layered hateful/fearful dynamic, Alexis remained aloof the entire time. She was impossible to predict (much like Purpearl) but the fact that she appeared to genuinely have no vested interest in any side what-so-ever really made her the MOST neutral character in the party, and the fact that she was also the most powerful balanced nicely with that. It is terrifying to know that the person with no feelings towards any happenings is also the one that can have the most effect. Even that final battle proved it - if any other single hero had sided with Chauncey, he'd likely be dead now. I think there's sometimes a complaint in PvP that the longer playing players could steam-roll players who have played for less time, but I think it's a dynamic we must preserve because of characters like Alexis. I think it is IMPORTANT to her character that she can strike out alone and do whatever she wants.
I also liked playing up some of her previous interactions. It was a little hard to tell how she felt towards XX - in theory I don't think she'd like him because of 53, but they really didn't cross paths THAT MUCH in that quest upon re-reading it. He respected her abilities for sure, and was the only hero he knew, but you keep Alexis so neutral even he didn't know what to make of her. I like that. Her dismissiveness over Arthur and Althior is also awesome - a good way to have her transformed character be shaped by events that no longer make sense for them. Instead of ignoring them you use them as a tool to show where she is now, and I really dig that.
The issue the others raised with battle issues is something to note, it really does make it look like you're not paying attention. I repeat often too because I also have a character who wouldn't chat too much in battle, but sometimes a little flourish adds a lot, and proves to everyone else that you're still really playing. But over all, I really like Alexis.
Nerwen - Well, it was my second quest in a row hosting Nerwen, and I think before that I was questing with her and debating religion and free will and punishment and all that, so she's sort of become a Nyx to me - it's easy to watch a character grow if you're forced to read every line they say for that long. Nerwen is awesome. I'm sure I said it at the end of 88, but she's complex because her strengths and weaknesses are the same thing. Nerwen is resolute, and does not allow bad things to happen, but because she is so resolute once something is "bad" in her mind it will never and can never be good.
Nerwen's interactions with just about everyone was great. It became clear early in the quest, I think, that Nerwen and Purpearl would not get along. But, and this is why I like long quests, watching their relationship fall apart over a week, all the hidden resentment... it was superb, and really did culminate in the final battle with Russel and Pigley - Nerwen would NOT allow them to die, and Purpearl wanted to take some down because she's a raging lunatic.
I enjoyed everything Nerwen did. I really do think that she and Purpearl and Alexis are three of the best played elves in the game - you often talk about how their perception of time makes them so unbudging (they're just moving slowly in our opinion). I think it stood out in this quest, and they all played with it well together: the hastiness, the superiority, the certainty of actions. It was great to see, and I think Purpearl and Nerwen are prime examples of rivals within Heroica. You also never neglected to show her softer side. Just as she is steadfast in her opinion on evil, she is likewise steadfast on her friends. I could never see her abandoning Russel and Pigley, and her dedication to XX just for Nyx's benefit shows her incredible willingness to stick by those she is loyal to. Another reason I love her and Guts, and feel I will love Matthias and her in the future: once she has chosen someone, there can be fights and disagreements but they will always be someone that she sticks up for. The conversation with Samuel, Raguel's apprentice, was lovely too. Nerwen can feel regret, but she still stands by what she has done.
Purpearl - I also really genuinely loved Purpearl. She was a terror, and I had no idea what way she might bend. I was incredibly pleased that she was the party leader. The power went to her head almost immediately, but I think that's because that's how Purpearl is. She actually reminds me a little of Zelphie, without the perverse charity side of things.
Purpearl and Nerwen were awesome together because they both have strict moral codes that don't have anything to do with traditional moral codes, but also don't have anything to do with each other. Purpearl is brutal. She does not spare many people. I'm not entirely sure what she wants right now, on a higher level, if anything. She seems prepared to live the life of a full out mercenary, but she has so much drive that I feel she is striving for something more, something bigger. But maybe she doesn't - that'd be quite the character too, an incredibly driven unflinching character with no exact end destination, just a forward push.
Purpearl and XX have that in common, for the moment at least. They both just want gold (though XX wants it for booze and bombs) and aren't too squeamish about getting it. The two bonded over it quite a bit, so much so that XX is fairly certain that Purpearl saved his life in that final fight. I was really glad that they got a side quest together. It was fitting, and they clearly gelled together. If XX hadn't met Nyx first, he may have been making eyes at Purpearl instead. Of course, Russel and Pigley are terrified of her.
Matthias - I didn't design the quest for anyone in mind, Avery is a character from a previous quest which WAS designed for the aforementioned four. Debts didn't have a particular audience in mind, but I'm incredibly thankful I got Matthias. Matthias is awesome. I'm glad that he was the outsider in this quest: three women who live five times his lifespan. That's scary.
So yes, Matthias played a different game, but I think it was a good one. Matthias was trying to find a powerful ally to stand with him against the bad things in the world. But he doesn't have complex thoughts on good and bad, like Nerwen and Purpearl - for him, good and bad is very simple, and I love that. This quest served to show him that the rest of the world doesn't think the same way, but he's already started to learn how to navigate it. Sure Nerwen and Purpearl and Alexis didn't conform to his ideas of "good" and "evil" and he wasn't powerful enough to exert his will alone, but he found he could draw out allies, make smart choices, navigate these dangerous waters, in other words, and still have a good effect on the world.
Matthias also served as a great companion to all the NPCs. Russel and Pigley trust and adore him. XX is fond of him too, even after they're many arguments, there's something about two men with guns that XX just can't give up. I think he likes Matthias' "simple" view of a black and white world.
But I really do think that Matthias grew without giving up his core being, and I think that's a powerful statement. He learned that there is much darkness out there in Olegia, AND some dangers in the Hall, but he didn't up and leave. He stayed. Because he's just as committed as the fearsome Nerwen and Purpearl, because he may be a small player now but I think Matthias knows if he continues to work hard he may grow strong enough to spare Sam and Keith or to protect the little man. He has learned that being good isn't going to be easy, that the Gods aren't always automatically on the side of good, but he has still decided to keep the course, and that's a powerful statement very few players have made with their heroes before. Matthias has doubt, but he also has faith in himself and that what he's committed himself to is right, and that's a strong character who has all but vanished from the story of Heroica. I think we need more of them.
The allies and enemies and nuances that arose over 5 months was incredible, and made me really happy to have picked this long of a quest for such a strong party.
That's it,
Would love to discuss if anyone has any more thoughts on the quest, but if not I'll just be sitting around tinkering with my next few!
-Zeph