Scubacarrot

Yes that is correct. York also learned of the other two PR's from Donna.

You should read the previous page.

But it will get us a scum.

Believe me, if Donna was still alive, I'd have thrown her out of the airlock for this.

Now that's fishing. It's irrelevant. But since the scum already knows. He told me when I asked for the PM, KoTZ, aka Donna, told him. He did not tell me something I did not already know. Nor something McAndrews did not already know, by the way.

Don't treat me as stupid. It's insulting.

Why else would they kill Donna except if they knew her role? She has not exactly been vocal or insightful in the thread...

Don't play me, they already know, because you told them. Nothing you say has yet to make me think you might be town, quite the opposite.

Nope. If you want to know what is going on, apparantly he had been talking to someone, who knew the PR's. This someone trusted John Paul for whatever reason, which is why it's true when he says he knows the PR's, more or less. But: This does not prove anything about his allegiance, now does it? If anything, it does the opposite. You see, John Paul knew the identity of the Watcher. You know what's funny? Donna, occupation: Watcher, mysteriously died last night. Right after he was told her role. Yeah, coincidence? Hell no. I think he has been using the fake sting as a defense. His reasons "why she is town" are massively flawed. I know where my vote is going.

Ok I got the PM's. McAndrews is an idiot, the PM's don't prove anything at all.

What PM's prove you are town??? If we are just going to have McAndrews word. Yeah... He has been wrong before. Do freaking better. Send me the PM you send McAndrews, if you want to convince me.

Where did you hear that?? I have just heard he bluffed saying he knows who the power roles are. Not more...

York is not the vig. Just saying. And I don't know. If that was really a town's attemp at trying to get scum to talk to you, it fails pretty damn hard. Making empty threats to the town is generally not a good way to do that, as well. I don't see why Mcandrews is vouching for York, to be honest. Holloway, let me get this straight, you are defending York on the basis she has created too much confusion today to be not-town? And let's be honest, she does not know shit.

What part of "could (or can) join up with scum" do you not understand?

I'm certain because he claimed, he said he COULD join with the scum, which was reason enough to kill him, in my opinion. In the simulation by the way, the neutrals (two of them) joined up with the scum, if I'm told things correctly. I said something like that, yes, but this in particular seemed similair enough to how it was in the simulation, don't you think? I don't see why you are pushing this, it's not imporant.

Pewter was a way to do it right. Guys, don't complicate it more than it is. Wright was a neutral cop whose winning condition probably included joining up with the scum. If this is anything like the simulation, he has a partner. For all we know, he had or is now already joined with the scum.

He was neutral.

I've been rereading yesterday's events a little bit, and all that strikes me since your current subconcious took over, is that you have been desperately trying to save your own skin. With Burbank being town, that's even more apparant. Now, the way you were saying it does not make you look like a townie in my eyes, exactly. I'm going to have to do a little more rereading to get something tangible together, if anything, though. I've got an eye on you.

No, this is the other way around. You do it.

Well this is annoying. So we got someone that is not town, that's the first good thing? York's defense would be appreciated. And Wright was quite obviously an alien. Obviously.

No... nor when a mage uses it.

Guts shakes Docken's hand, and says: "Very well. Glad to have you aboard."

Guts put his drink on the table with a loud sound, halting the conversations around him for a second. The elf with the bow would come back on her promise of going with them, litterally moments before the Questers would be announced? Hmpf, perhaps it was for the best something like this happened now, he would not like to be in a fight with her when she had a change of mind. Weak, that's all it was. When Guts started walking down to the Questboard to take off the sign-up he had written, and he now needed to take down, the Raider saw the elf sitting with the foolish mage. Figures. Annoyed, mainly because the woman had not even bothered to inform him, Guts spoke loudly: "I need a brave soul to go with me, and the skilled Hybros here. We have no use for those that can't hold their own ground, but know that you won't stand alone."

That's just offensive.