Scubacarrot

I did not have any indication for that, no. Was there a particular reason it changed from night 1?

Hinckley, was the mustache you found a real thing?

That's a very good attitude to have! Although as a rule of thumb, I would say that surviving is not something to strive for in mafia!

Might I remind you that you lost as well.

The set-up was that I was a scum, but seperated from the other scum by the notion that I could (read allowed) only contact Darthpotato. My winning condition was the same as the other scum. I had no night action, but if I was investigated, I would turn up town. I could also be indoctrinated which made me a scum that could talk to my teammates, but I would be a vanilla scum with normal investigations.

I repeat my question...

Is it okay if I drop you a PM? I see no need to be like this.

No you were great, I'm really impressed that you managed to stay hidden so long, I don't think I could. The set-up was a pain, not you in particular. Who's in your game is your business, but I do not understand that one, I must say.

Yeah. I explicitly told DP that you should not contact Dave, what do you do? Contact Dave and tell him I told you. That wasn't very smart, and I'm going as far as that being the thing that got me lynched, but we all make mistakes. It's all good. I think there were some problems with this game, but that's absolutely fine, it's your first hosted game and it was awesome. The presentation and characters were cool, and I really liked it. I think you can look back on a more than succesful hosting job, but do hope you take any criticisms to heart for your next game (I hope there is a next one!). And Def, no heart (see what I did there) feelings, bro. I can't comment about balance since I did not know the scum team's roles and don't have a lot of experience with cults, but I will say this: My role, was not done very well, I feel.

DD, I have to ask: What was the idea behind the glasses found on me?

Actually I was the traitor that was not allowed to talk to my teammates. That's not entirely true, I was allowed to talk to one.

Guts checks for traps.

I knew it, Hinckley was just saying nonsense at the end there. Congratulations, guys!

Make that dancing through all your bad guys.

"Maurice take the Helm, Sorrow the Venom and 10 gold, Mizuki the potion and 10 gold, Nagure and Nerwen 15 gold, and I'll take 15 gold as well."

What do you mean? If someone is knocked out, we would of course revive them... There is no strategy to this.

You can autoplay it until someone gets knocked out. With the battle order I lay out below. Guts and Hlin both attack the cart twice from the front row. Battle order: Guts Mizuki Sorrow Maurice Nerwen Nagure Hlin

Elements.

This looks pretty cool. With all my dickishness, I sign up.

Nope. I asked in the past.

Darkness elemental damage does not deal double damage to heroes.

Not upset, no worries.

That is no barrier at all. You should not get free stuff for doing nothing, I hate that attitude. And I think know there would actually be interest in the classes.

Another suggestion: They get a chance (say 1/6 or 2/6) to shield every party member with their SP on damage rolls? Or something similair to what was suggested with the juggernaut: They can choose a party member which gets SP equal to theirs for the duration of the quest?

Playstyle would be the reason for having them both. Not all knights are: "Hey Friend, Need some Help? Jolly good!" And I'd understand if Black Knights don't want to go back to being a softy. Traits are usually out of battle things. That's my reasoning for it anyways, and it were just suggestions, not all of them can be winners .