Piratedave84

NO WAY! I would never have thought! Yeah but this early? There's 50/50 chances he's scum! This happens all the time, no exception; there's always someone eager to claim to those 2 before the 2nd day is over!

Everyone claims to Simon, ALL THE TIME. It's mandatory on EB that people claim to Simon or Speedy.

I'm an F and I targeted a C due to the Z which was said during the Y phase of the H day. Yup, works perfect!

I don't get the whole code thing ... Would thee be a code-master? How would I, or any other stump, relay our roles to the master?

So nobody's concerned about Maggie's absence? Anyone?

What? Are you? No? Is this? Nooooooo? Asterix? Low light?

Confirmed through the unconfirmed via the over-eager investigator ... Yes, do claim! I want to: irrelevant-stumpvote: Maggie Magnolia-Calanon for having said exactly jack-shit today. Oops! Forgot to put my icon besides my post about claiming!

WHY DO PEOPLE CLAIM TO AN UNCONFIRMED PERSON ... People never learn ...

I want to lynch Hazel

I would hope that the investigator, if killed on day 5 revealed whom he had investigated to said person before dying; or else he/she is a stupid investigator ... Agreed :slowclap: are you for real ... this is what you have to say ... What's wrong with your text editor ?

Yes, we're discussing hypotheticals here so if the scum don't have a rolecop then a stump's claim is a huge help whereas if they have a rolecop its a non-issue but I would prefer to be cautious and not give that piece of info that they may or may not be able to obtain themselves.

I would bet you that a PR getting killed would not get his/her result the next day like it would be if they had actually died.

Hazel contacted me today, fairly early In the day, and was asking whether someone had argued with me, was attacking me or if I had any weird contacts. This was odd to me considering that the first 2 questions can easily be answered by reading the day thread. Bear in mind that this was done before the rules were clarified and before the whole "claim or don't claim" argument we are having now. For what it's worth I think the benefits of claiming publicly are outweighed by the possible repercussions and as such I think it's not a good idea.

He PM'd me before it was determined I couldn't answer; was fishing a lot.

Why did you PM me?

I REALLY hope I can stick around for more than one day!

Again going from memory, I think we janitored a townie fairly early to guarantee another townie lynch the next day.

I'm going to assume that since I can't PM you, you should not PM me and if you do I don't think I'd be at liberty to use that info. But eh! If you feel like claiming to me, be my guest!

I was in a situation with janitors once and if memory serves me well we had 2 abilities to use at our discretion (could have been 1 but I'm pretty sure it was 2).

:fishing: I'm pretty sure I made it clear earlier that saying this publicly was a bad idea ...

Got my answers and Elder said he's also post them. I can't PM the living but could PM other stumps.

Seriously though, what's the logic behind your thoughts? Have you ever seen or heard of 2 maple kill?

Maybe the janitor role was not a one-shot and as such it made sense to janitor Alistair IF he was maple; well actually if they have several such abilities, 'janitoring' an oak may be a worthwhile gamble. In terms of whom may have targeted me, I was in communication with Jack Pine (nothing was really said), Waldorf Walnut (he approached me and told me I was different and we proceeded to talk suspicions and gameplay) and Simon Persimmon (we discussed the game a bit and hypothesized whom we would target should we have been part of the block). Of these 3 I reached out to Simon and Jack whereas Waldorf contacted me; I am more suspicious of Waldorf since he reached out to me and said he thought I was playing different.

Haven't heard from elder yet; would that not be crazy unfair though? We could have a block setup within 2 hours of the second day; the balance would be crazy pro-town! As soon as I have news, I'll share them