jluck
-
Posts
1,335 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by jluck
-
That’s a fair question that can be asked of all of us. We weren’t all as fortunate as Stephanie to have game long protection. However, this argument is a logical fallacy. If I were killed hen someone else would be here instead answering the same question. Simply stated, some town members still half to be alive for the game would be over, and I’m one of them. The scum have only had two successful night kills, on nights two and four. The other two Night kills we’re at the hands of the vigilante or SK I assume, though they could be the rival mafia as well. Therefore not being targeted on 2 nights isn’t that unusual.
-
If you recall this was in reference to this statement that I made: Don't go throwing away your PR on someone you don't totally trust, obviously. But I really felt that went without saying. So what your saying Stephanie is that you think only experienced players know to not role claim to someone they don't trust? The reason I bring this up is because of the word "experience". It seems to be your go to criticism every time you attack someone: For example... This isn't an all-inclusive list of you meta-referencing players' (most often me) experience. It seems to be your go to argument and I feel it's time you are called on it.
-
Huh, my list yesterday was 3 people, posted for everyone to see. My list today is still substantial: Stephanie and Jared are my current top thoughts. However, at this point of the game I'm jumping at my own shadow. I've chosen to work on the hypothesis that Gary is town (though protecting the same person for several days was likely not the best idea), but everyone else looks pretty scummy. I think my vote is currently on Jared. His ability to fly under the radar has really started to become apparent as our numbers dwindle.
-
Ok, so it seems to me we need to take Gary at his word. here’s what I’m wanting to hear about: Gary, who’d you target each night? I wanna be sure that the every other night kills are a game mechanic and not good luck. I certainly am watching for Anthony but Jared and Tina are both much more interesting to me at this point of the game. Neither has done anything to stand out. A townie juror has nothing to lose and therefore is willing to boldly take risks. A scum player hides in the chaos. But not that a lot of that chaos has died down I realize they both have stayed pretty clean. In fact, they seem to be the only two remaining players to not end a day with votes (though Tina did have the penalty votes)
-
I kinda assumed that from the beginning, but it is truly interesting that your alive. I imagine I'm not the only one who figured you were the doc. Even if the scum thought you were just the mouthpiece you'd be worth shutting down... If it seems safe to you, would you mind sharing your targets from the first 4 days? We've been working under the assumption of the killing mechanism being in place every other night, but this could help clarify.
-
If you turned up town I'd probably something like this:
-
Come to think of it, the dead townies did say a lot on the topic of Stephanie: I don't find this conclusive but if we feel like we can trust the dead more once we know their allegiances, then we have to at least give credence to their words.
-
Don't go throwing away your PR on someone you don't totally trust, obviously. But I really felt that went without saying. But how would that not guarantee a scum lynch? If a PR gets the info out that Player A is scum, the outcome would be as follows: 1) Their confidant shares with the town and we lynch the scum 2) Their confidant does not share, thus revealing they're scum too, so we lynch too 3) They're actually lying, thus revealing that they are scum Yep, it got Dez lynched and we see how that turned out. Your not so veiled threat isn't helping. I'm not asking to be let in the block, I'm asking for something to work with (if it exists). We're in day 5 and you know all we've learned? That the Doc targeted you on night one and there was no kill. But given the every other day mechanism that has since emerged that result means literally nothing. We are literally hoping to get lucky on a lynch as well feel around in the dark.
-
If they have a recruit action every other night then I don't see much a path to victory, we're nearly outnumbered as it is. Best case scenario is what, 4 townies? If that's the case, we're reliant on all townies voting as a block or we'll need some help from the Moletti in voting. That's why I pushed above for night actions to get out. We need a sure thing. If you have a PR don't claim in-thread but PM someone you trust if you have info that will lead to a guaranteed scum lynch. We don't have the luxury of being wrong again.
-
So...
-
Trial by Jury - Confirmation and Discussion
jluck replied to mediumsnowman's topic in LEGO Mafia and Role-Play Games
@LegoMonorailFan please play again! You’re the type of player we need to keep this great part of the forum alive! -
At this point are there any more than 1 Ballagio member? There can’t be more than 2 or else this game would be hopeless. Here was my first thought on things: sucks that we missed on Amanda, we so not have that luxury of being wrong at this point. Secondly, the every other night thing n very consistent. But my main thought is this: were in day 5, there are 6 of us left. We need info. We’ve literally gotten nothing from our PRs. Maybe we’ve been unlucky, but at this point any valuable info needs to get out. If you know something PM someone you trust or something, because we can’t risk being wrong again. (also, Clifford, you played a good game. Hope you keep coming back! We need more guys like you)
-
The Chinese websites seem to indicate the statue will be around $100. The preliminary photos that are floating around look really interesting, definitely different from the typical architecture sets.
-
Ya, I'm really gonna be interested in seeing how they pull these off. Will they be released this year? We've only had skylines announced so far. No pictures but I found the rumored prices here: https://www.brickmerge.de/21041-1_lego-architecture-great-wall-of-china Looks like the wall is 50 Euros and the Statue is 100 Euros.
-
Game mechanics-wise, if she’s lynched she’s done. No dying breath actions will go through. Also she was on 30 minutes ago, but gave us nothing.
-
As I’ve said elsewhere, I’m fine with this lynch. Amanda was my number 2 suspect. I’ll go on record with y’all: unvote: Anthony (Actor Builder) Vote: Amanda (@Khscarymovie4)
-
Also, Amanda @Khscarymovie4 has been online. Last timestamp was 5 hours ago.
-
What bothers me is that Anthony throws around comments like which don't do anything to help. Kinda like what his predecessors did. The whole has not done much of anything. Is that scummy or just plain useless? And Amanda (calling @Khscarymovie4 ) won't be bothered to show up and contribute. So basically the town is forced to deal with uselessness, which makes it very easy for the scum to hide. Scum can look active all day attacking these 2, and if they flip town it's hard to blame anyone. I'm just not sure what to do with them.
-
Small typo, Anthony has 2 votes.
-
I’ll join the Amanda lynch if that’s the route we go. Anthony or Amanda either way, unless one of them give me a reason to look elsewhere.
-
There is so much to unpack here, I'm going to have to do it a bit at a time: Let's look at what was actually said, not your interpretation of it: Clifford had changed his vote with 2 hours left. I told him he was preventing the lynch that he and I had worked towards, as at the time we were only one vote short. He asked a very valid question, one that no one even attempted to answer. This post sums up why I didn't agree with the way everything happened. I wanted a lynch, but forcing Clifford to vote for someone he didn't suspect and away from who he was sure is scum was not the way to go about it. With the vote and 5 to 5 literally anyone could have hammered either vote. Forcing Clifford to do it against his judgement was not the right way. Ain't this the pot calling the kettle black?! It's almost laughable. I've actually been instrumental in raising suspicion on two of the primary candidates today, Amanda (I built the case on her yesterday) and Anthony (I built a case on him from day 1 and added to it today). But that doesn't fit your narrative. In fact, your a distant 3rd on my list, behind the afore mentioned pair. On the other hand, you have been focused on me since day 2, which interestingly why your only 3rd on my list. If you are scum, then you know I'm town, and killing me will raise a lot of suspicion on you once my allegiance is public. What about my analysis? I believe you'll find a particularly pointed analysis in this earlier post. I literally called out Anthony and, to a lesser degree, you based off of the vote. Anthony was mighty fast to jump on that early wagon as soon as it got going. It doesn't sit well with me given my past suspicions of him. based off of that my vote will be: Vote: Anthony (Actor Builder) As I stated on my post, my top 3 are Anthony, Amanda, and Stephanie. The reason I am not voting for Amanda is because her silence makes it hard to read her, but at some point that will come back to bite her. The reason I'm not currently voting for Stephanie is I feel she is too focused on me, which would be a bad scum tactic to put all the effort into killing one townie.
-
@Lady K I literally addressed your concern within my first post of the day, long before you asked. I thought it would be just as easy for someone to join us in the vote for Amanda as it would have been for Clifford to go against his gut and vote for Dez. Your turn to stop avoiding real questions. First, a real analysis of the bandwagon you were part of yesterday. We know scum must have been a part of it. Second, everyone has been self congratulatory about finally getting a lynch “because it gives us valuable info” but so far I’ve not seen any of that valuable info. The only thing I’ve heard is we can now trust Dez had the best intentions of the town at heart so we can trust his posts. Dez thought you were scum.
-
Dez thought you were scum. also, the bandwagon on Dez was very interesting to say the least. Care to comment?
-
Look how fast the bandwagon on Dez started (check the time stamps). In 16 minutes he got 3 votes. The first two are suspicious because of timing, but they are so close I assume they cross posted. But look who was quick to get in early on the bandwagon with the 3rd vote...the same character that I've been accusing since day 1. Also, Stephanie was the 4th vote, after Dez accused her. It's all a bit strange and extremely fast.
-
I'm just going to let the dead speak for themselves. That's fair enough, let's dig in!