Since you are keen on getting 110% feedback, here's my 2 cents - even though I wasn't personally required to comment (phew):
I only rarely glimpse at the SW forums because I am not and have never been a LEGO Star Wars fan. That said, I sometimes see MOCs that are totally creative / mind-blowing, regardless of one's liking for LEGO SW or lack thereof. I did end up checking out your thread though because I found it weird how someone could have come to version 9 (!) of the same MOC - and was wondering what your progress so far has been. I looked at those two photos, saw the way you seem to be telling off absolutely anyone who isn't waxing lyricals about them, and voted "Terrible".
In short, I'd much much rather stare at LEGO's X-Wing fighters than this one, if I had to. Obviously, you're a sucker for proportions and realism but you're definitely taking it all way too far. Swooshability and sleekness aside, this fighter simply looks too unfinished even for a WIP, period. I don't see the point in posting a WIP just to show the solutions you've come up with regarding how to get a couple of angles right - not when you react like you've been hit by a bullet every single time someone posts a suggestion on how to do things otherwise, dare I say, better. So if you wanted an honest unbiased opinion by someone who just appreciates the beauty of the models, there it is.
Now, regarding your comments - I don't know which would be the nicest way to put this, but perhaps you really need to step back, have a glass of milk and generally cool down. Your overtly negative attitude is not helping anyone around here - but that thing about "all Asians looking the same to some people" was by far the most pointless comment (to say the least) I've seen recently. I am an average "netizen" to whom most of this space stuff looks the same - but there are MOCs that totally stand out, which this one, at this point, does not. Your endless stream of negativity about it, however, definitely does - and if this average non-Asian netizen is absolutely offended by your comments, then I can only guess how the not-so-average guys around here feel about that.