Hinckley

What's the best case? vs. Is it possible? Semantics, but it stands out regardless. First time I remember hearing it referred to that way. That's different how?

Toki's response to my calling him out for fluff is to vote with no reason. He misinterprets my post as a push for him to vote and immediately votes despite just saying he thought Brand was just naive. I didn't have to apply much pressure to get out of him what appears to be panic. He's one of these "the most possible lynch" guys. If you're going to vote because the lynch seems "possible" that seems like Scum reasoning. I can't see Town thinking "Well, which lynch is possible?" Town votes for who they think is the Scummiest. Scum want to lynch any Townie or non–Scum and are more likely to be looking at which lynches are possible. "Possible" or not, I think I'll be voting for Toki today. Though Cranebeinn seems to be trying pretty hard to get in that noose. Uneasy seems a bit of an understatement considering how Scummy he's acting. And he's third on your list. It kind of surprises me. The part where you say he's going to try to get us to lynch Tarr seemed like a counterpoint to him being Scum so I do apologize for misreading it and somewhat flipping out. But, you're still Scummy.

Hey Toki! Why do you think I'm Scum and why do you feel the need to make the case behind the scenes and not here in the thread? Sneaking around in the shadows is very Scummy. If I'm Scum shouldn't everyone be warned about me? I hope you're wrong because the tracker who contacted me found someone targeting Lambi and that person claims to be our vig. So I certainly hope I'm not Scum. Ooops, sorry. More red than I thought. The more I think about this the more I think it is pig shit. Especially since Tarden is lightly defending you in private or at least steering the lynch away from you. And even moreso because I think you are highly unlikely to buy anybody lunch.

Who the hell would trust you at this point?? That's rhetorical...

That was a crucial piece of information I think you should've divulged a little earlier but hey, we have it now...

Why did he choose the two of you and what else was discussed? What did Patrekr contribute?

So, he started a group PM with him, you and the dead Patrekr?? ...

Both of who? Shouldn't he know if he's Town or not.

He contacted you about what?

So, did he contact you in private too?

What are you basing this on?

Why do you need to say something on the first page?

What was interesting about it? You pointed out that Tarden voted for Lambi, then unvoted and voted for Munud. Then you asked for thoughts. Why? And you're not trying to accuse him of anything, then why point it out? Perhaps Kapmaud was saying we know it isn't the case that Brand is Scum, but the participle is dangling. It sounded, at first, to me that he was saying we knew the Scum were not blocked. Scum!!!! I know, right? Especially to me. I did get everyone killed last time. Every...last...player... Fortunately, there's only one dummy so far.

It's hyperbole. Are you defending Kapmaud?

I think he would have said something. Or a target protected or the vig stayed home and Lambi was killed by the Serial Killer. What are you, new?

Or this topic, right here on EB.

The only case where anyone would know that is if they were Scum. So, thank you for confessing.

The Scum killer could've been blocked or the kill target protected. You've played enough I feel you should already know that. And now you're defending Tarben. Going as far as to make a case for him? Even if you didn't think of the possibility of a Serial Killer, you seem to know a lot about the Scum team's motivation for killing Patrekr. I've been contacted by the Town Tracker. If you are a Town Tracker and need to counter this claim, please inform someone you trust to post it here or by PM to me.

This is the second person to play down the fact that it's only Day Two and we have a Scum corpse. What is this?? Having a dead Scum after one night in the game is stellar.

So, are you looking at the voting pattern? Or just fluffing up your post so you look active? Ping.

Liar, you never asked Munud to lunch. Seriously, how was Munud more possible? And since when is a "possible" lynch the best way to place a vote. Who else referred to a lynch as "possible" yesterday. Was it Toki? Oh, is that so? What did you find in the voting patterns?

Damn it, OK. I see it now. This doesn't get you off the hook as you could be throwing a bus vote to throw off voting analysis. Yet you unvote him later, that's how sure you were. And in this same quote you give your odd defense of Mist. Here are the things Lambi said, in case there are any leads there. I do think it's interesting to note that Lambi and Patrekr were both in the middle of the pack for voting. Did someone see Lambi as possible Scum or as someone likely to not be watched. Same goes for Patrekr, middle of the road. Would Scum want to take him out? If this was vig or SK, did the blocker target Scum? I know you can all figure these questions on your own but I'm just attempting to focus the discussion...and also catch up since I seem to have rushed forward twice now without paying attention to all the info we've been given. Well, Jarl is Scum: How do you know which one was the vig and why wouldn't Patrekr be a Serial Kill target? Do the Scum go for quiet people on Day One, anyway? What are you talking about? Yes, look indeed. Any argument with a confirmed Scum should be looked at. Everyone knows that staple of Mafia analysis. What did you find when you looked at it? You've though way too much about how Lambi voted, in my opinion. Thoughts yourself? That's not even an accurate portrayal of what actually happened. I'm very curious to hear what you think that could possibly mean. Please enlighten us. What did you find?

This is pinging me like crazy. What exactly do you expect? Two dead Scum on Day Two? Were there going to be three dead Scum on Day Two? What's your opinion of a good day? In my opinion, it's pretty great. It's not uncommon to start Day Two with only Town deaths. Lambi made much more sense as a Serial Killer target. That's why I'd like to know how Tarden is trying to claim he knew she would be Scum. Did Tarden say even one word about Lambi yesterday? No. In fact, when I said that Lambi's "You are either a traitor or bored Townie" Tarden reacted to me, not to Lambi. I call megablocks on Tarden's supposed Scumdar.

There's a dead Scum on Day Two. That's pretty great.

Ugh, I glossed over the end of yesterday. I need to slow down and catch back up.