Hello, my name is John Cromwell, the former Earl of Wolf. I have finally become a member or Eurobricks, after lurking for quite a while.
For my first topic post, I wanted to share my opinion of the long-going dispute of whether the Black Knights and the Dragon Masters are the same. Now, as a huge Black Knights fan, I am going to be biased. There, you were warned!
Are the Black Knights and the Dragon Masters the same faction? I have to answer that question with a "No, they are not", and here is why:
The main reason (to my knowledge) why people claim the Black Knights and Dragon Masters are one and the same faction is the similarities in their shields:
Dragon Masters: And the Black Knights: Both use the same print of a wyvren and both use similar colors: the Masters using green, red, and yellow, and the Knights using blue, red and yellow.
However, the Dragon Masters use a red outline and the Black Knights use a blue, the same primary color of their dragon.
That's basically where the similarities end. The Black Knights have been shown to attack the Dragon Masters and vice versa in official Lego catalogs such as here:
And here:
So... I'm not sure why the Dragon Masters and the Black Knights would attack each other if they were on the same team? Also, If you take a closer look at the top of the second image, the symbols for the two factions are different not just in color but in design as well.
This also brings up something else. The Dragon Masters received 3 completely new torso designs and a new helm to boot: and the new helmet:
I can understand the claim that both are the same faction if the Dragon Masters just re-used the chainmail, breastplate printings, and the visored helm of the Black Knights, but they didn't.
Besides, the first catalogs states: "Here ye, Here ye, The Dragon Masters have arrived! Led by Majisto the Wizard and his glow-in-the-dark wand, they control the fierce flying dragons. Can the powerful Black Knights and the cunning Wolfpack stop their reign?"
Now, I'm open to the idea that the Dragon Master's soldiers and 'generals' (the guys with the ostentatious helm and plumes) are disgruntled Black Knights who were fed up with a boring job or low wages and were found by Majisto and offered a job, but I don't like the fact that some people just combine the two and pretend they are one faction.
My conclusion: Lego was just being lazy and re-used the same shield print with different colors. But I will never equip my Black Knights with DM shields.
I'd love to see other people's opinions and why they think the factions are the same.
P.S. If you read that whole article, thanks for listening to the mad rant of a Lego Classic Castle fan!