Amoreternum

Well, getting sets from Lego does not necessarily mean lack of neutrality - from what I've seen, both channels did get sets in the past they did not like, or sets with things they did not like, all of which was openly and clearly shared with the viewer while also making it clear that the sets had been provided. But of course, in the end it's just an opinion, and there is no way bias can totally be avoided. I just think that from what I've seen in their test videos that both Sariel and RacingBrick have a very empirical way of testing things, numbers, statistics, comparisons and so on, while in most train related videos that I have seen (Jang being an exception that has to be mentioned) I get the feeling that most information shared is based upon observations and personal impressions that cannot be replicated. That does not mean it's worse, but considering we're talking about batteries, motors and other stuff from a growing mass of manufacturers, I'd prefer numbers and solid info to keep somewhat of an overview. Both Sariel and RacingBrick did very good reviews on the Keybrick One for example.

I'd actually love to see a reviewer like RacingBrick or Sariel check out and compare the different brands and systems. There are a few reviews, but I'm not certain if they're 100% neutral, and definitely not as thorough and meticulous as the two.

Hm, yeah. You got a point there, I have to admit - guess I thought about stuff like the Crocodile or the Disney train with Lego, but yeah, the regular City train is a bit lacking compared to some of the BB stuff.

What kind of competition are you thinking of? I don't really think the high-end kits offered at BTD, BMR and Brickmania are competition, since they're costly and too niche - on the other hand, companies like Bluebrixx will be in business either way, since what they lack in quality both in design and material, they make up with their cheap prices, so their customers will still buy their stuff. Lego puts itself in a spot with no real competition in a sort of a medium price range, I'd say. I'd prefer a new steam loco myself, but I hope for one with a somewhat realistic solution for the rods.

Try uploading to an external host - the space eurobricks provides for images is actually meant for your avatar, not pictures in your posts.

Oh, don't get me wrong - my comment might've sounded a bit more angry than I am, because for a fact, I am not. I do think this model and kit is a fantastic piece of brick, and if someone is willing to pay the price that is asked for, that's just fine and I am happy that this hobby seems to get the traction (pun intended) it deserves, to a point where kits like these are possible to make. I was just wondering about the price, and did and do not want to come across as being more critical than I am, not only because I am more or less new to the train part of the Lego hobby. Just wondering about the difference between the prices of the kits that are being offered and would like to get a rough guesstimation on how these two and a half thousand dollars come together, since the second most expensive loco I have seen offered as a kit is a thousand less and I can't spot a difference in quality. But I have to say, great work on the loco. The longer I look at it, the more I can appreciate it, fantastic job Glenn. I hope this one opens the path for more kits in the future, it's great to see what the high end of these kits can look like, when all you are familiar with is the bottom end with locos from BlueBrixx and alike.

Great model, but the price tag is outrageous. If I remember correctly, BMRs Reading was around 800 or so(most likely more, not sure anymore) and the kits you can get at BTD are around 1500 - which is still far cheaper than this one, and to be honest, I don't see anything that justifies the difference. Would love to read something that clarifies why this one is so expensive.

The new straights are molded as well, and I guess sooner or later Trixbrix will switch to that for all they offer. But on the supllier of the BB tracks, I am curious as well, chinese is for certain though I'd say.

I think I'd still prefer ordering from Trixbrix and the others - while I have to admit that the buildings BB put out look alright or nice even, I can't and don't want to ignore the continous copyright-stuff and MOC-stealing going on - I mean, you can cleary identify a Gundam in the background, and I doubt it is licensed by Bandai. Pretty sure the tracks we are used to are of higher quality, also a lot of development went into those.

Wow. This is sending shivers down my spines, and I know that sounds ridiculous. 23 Euros, or around 30 I think with shipping for 256 cm of track is quite the bargain - I'll definitley order some this weekend, especially with the discount. Still, I doubt that Lego itself will change too much in the near future, I just expect the pack with curves and flex track to retire due to the negative feedback. Official tracks like the ones from TrixBrix are just too niche, I guess.... but since the Krododil appears to be very popular, who knows what's next?

I'd swap the M-motor for a L-motor, looks like the engine itself might have some weight to it, but if you want to use it to pull or push some rolling stock, I think you'd need just a bit more power.

Ah, that's just too cute! Great model as well, must look great on a layout :D thanks for sharing it, as well as your thoughts, does sound like the motor is just enough for what you need it to do. Great!

While I love the model as it's really close to it's prototype, have you tried to build this in the brick? I own a micro motor and as far as I can tell, it's neither fast nor strong, I'm not sure if it's enough to propel this little guy around the track.

Not an expert in anything british, but from what I can see on Google and the blueprints I find there, I'd say the proportions are a tad bit off. Try looking those up, and do not hesitate to try to recreate what other builders have done - the Mallard has been built before from basically every level of builder in different scales. One thing that definitely catches my eye are the wheels - not only is it missing the rods on the larger wheels, but every single wheel is flanged. I doubt that it could pass any curve no matter the radius, maybe grands or 104 but nothing smaller, at least the middle ones of the 3 big axles should be without flanges.

Ah, saw that too but that must have slipped my mind. Thanks alot, especially for the render! Will definitely try that one out.

Now these are interesting - would love to know how they are connected to the loco and cars, and how stable the connections are.

But the Wuppertaler Schwebebahn runs on a single rail, it's an entirely different concept to both monorails and regular railed traffic.

If you do not plan on using the inside of the car for detailing etc, you could try to constuct a powered bogie yourself with a suitable motor and gearing. That would allow for some more prototypical looks and might result in a speed that is more fitting for an old tram. Which you captured really nicely!

Welcome to the community! You won't regret joining. For starters, I'd recommend getting a complete set with train and track, 60198 definitley is a good place to start I'd say - while I do enjoy both the Crocodile as well as the Hidden Site Train, they could not be more different - the Crocodile was designed with adult collectors and trainiacs in mind, the ghost train on the other hand obviously is for younger audiences. While it might not be too much of an issue at this point, maybe some time in the future you'll lean more towards more realistic looking trains, like the famous PennLUG does (do check it out on Youtube for example, totally worth it!), or towards a more casual approach. If you have Instagram, there a quite a few lego train guys on there as well worth checking out! But I'd say, in this forum you'll find both sorts of builders. One thing though, 60198 comes with the newest system for motorizing, and the systems (12V, 9V, Power Functions, Powered Up) are limited in their compatibility with each other - for example, the Crocodile can easily be motorized with Powered Up, but other systems require some modifications.

Thanks alot! Really helps, really interesting design. Not sure whether this has been asked before, but how sturdy is this design? Been fiddling around with a different design that uses the 2x8 with holes on it to keep it together as well, but it seems to warp a bit.

Nice work, especially on the trucks and the couplers - but what part is it that holds the axles in between the wheels and the gearing? Can't really make it out, it's a tad bit too dark with all the black.

Because that gap does not exist in the prototype - and some of us just want to get sth running on their layout that looks as realistic as possible. It's just a matter of taste, perspective and finally depends of what you want to do or achieve with your layout.

Nah, not really - paid around 150 € for my Croc, including the Powered Up stuff I ordered from Bricklink to motorize it from the get go, but that's roughly around the price of a medium sized H0-locomotive, some costing quite a lot more. Then again, I really like to take a look at their catalogues and products in general, it's almost like having a tiny prototype in your hands. Building a DR/BR 81 right now and I do own a H0 version of it (back from a Märklin starter kit from the early 2000s), and it's a blast to not have to google everything. But Peters videos are a blast in general.

Just thought of the exact same video - great model, and Märklin is one of the best if not the best manufacturer with great attention to detail and mechanics, apparently only a bit lacking in the sound division. I think it's as close to the prototype as a model can get, the real ones are rarely driven.

These mods look great, so far the best ones I've seen. Have to try them!