mediumsnowman
-
Posts
2,073 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by mediumsnowman
-
Either could be scum, I'm just as in the dark as everyone else. I think Brick Affleck is most likely to be, though I can't rule out the possibility that Studcille is, which I why I voted for him. With a majority needed to lynch either of them, my vote on Brick was useless, as the wagon was swinging towards Studcille.
-
Spreading out votes like this is no, no good with not much time left in the day. Gopher and Brick seem to be doing a good job of hiding and staying out of voting patterns. Most suspicious, if you ask me. I would most like to lynch Brick, but reviewing Studcille's posts he is looking more and more suspicious, especially his outburst today following his previous inactivity. A successful lynch right now is pivotal, and splitting/spreading the votes is a great place for scum to hide and avoid lynching their own. Unvote: Brick Affleck (Actor Builder) Vote: Studcille B. DeMille (Khscarymovie4)
-
Not really a fan of this bandwagon forming on Studcille... I think we're on the right track with Brick and his scum mates are trying to deflect the bandwagon on to Studcille instead. Not really any concrete evidence, just a gut feeling.
-
Voting for Glenn, who delivered us our only scum so far and is practically the only "confirmed" town left, is possibly the scummiest thing you could do today. Vote: Brick Affleck (Actor Builder)
-
That's... not good. I can assume William was killed by the scum and Legonardo by the vig for his odd PM to Roger the other day. I'm rather surprised to see Rosamunde turn up town, I thought her message to William was very out-of-character for a townie. Hopefully Glenn and the block have news for us.
-
There's a difference between asking for reasoning and evidence to confirm a claim and fishing for concrete night action targets from confirmed roles.
-
Why would you want to lynch somebody if you know they're vanilla town? I don't think we're at the point to start lynching the vanillas, and inactivity does not always equal scum.
-
9 not-voting with less than 24 hours to go is highly troubling. We can't sit on our hands and wait for night action results. I think Rosamunde or Legonardo would be the best choices, but the rest of you guys really need to get involved.
-
If I'm not mistaken, this seems to contradict what's William said earlier.
-
An inactive player is just as likely to be scum as anyone else, and if I recall Audrey has a history of being rather quiet in all her other recent productions.
-
This is the third person to go fishing for night action results, and the second in public! What are you thinking?!
-
I can't seem to copy the formatting for yesterdays quotes correctly (I miss the plaintext editor ), but Thelma and I's posts, both fairly lengthy, were posted within 5 minutes of each other. Go check the timestamps if you don't believe me. While Thelma appears to have started the votes for Glenn, we both voted at almost the same time, and there is no way I could have composed my entire argument complete with quotes within 5 minutes. Therefore your argument that Thelma can't be scum because she was the first to vote doesn't really hold much weight. In addition, I outlined my reasoning fairly well, it was not a throwaway vote. Glenn had parroted many posts, and then voted for Ari with almost no reasoning. It is very similar to what Thelma had to say here, though I said it first. I don't think there necessarily has to be a scum between Thelma, Finn, and I, though I admit it is reasonable. My point being, I had solid evidence behind my vote, it wasn't a throwaway, and Glenn was acting very suspicious yesterday until she revealed that she had been contacted about Ari. I think my vote on her was justified, but I didn't hesitate to retract it when she shared her reasoning behind her initially scummy vote. For now, I will Vote: Rosamunde Bricke (Rider Raider) because fishing for night action targets is just not something any townie would have any reason to do. **fishing for night action targets from the only publically claimed power role, too!
-
William already said yesterday he made arrangements in the event that he was killed last night, so why would you feel the need to reach out to him again? As far as I know, you're not cleared either- why would William intrust you with this information?
-
Mhmm. Fishing for targets and night action results is definitely suspicious. Rosamund and Audrey have been elevated to the top of my suspicions list. That just doesn't sit right.
-
One scum rolecop + one town investigator = two total investigators William followed Ari and saw him investigating, which most likely means he rolecopped someone since Ari flipped scum today. The second investigator is town-aligned and contacted Glenn with the scum result on Ari. So, who to lynch today? I don't think there's much to see in the voting patterns from yesterday after Glenn announced the result on Ari, and we haven't heard anything from Glenn or the PR's yet. Audrey, Thelma, and Brick have been very quiet. I would be interested to hear their thoughts on today's situation.
-
That's what I'm thinking- scum could also have a standard investigator if there are two scum teams, but that is HIGHLY unlikely considering the size of this game.
-
If Ari was shown investigating, wouldn't that make him a Rolecop?
-
My apologies, the long night must be messing with my head. I knew that.
-
Brickie! Good to see Glenn's source was right about Ari. I think we need to lynch William's source today. Thoughts?
-
I would be willing to bet you're a follower mislabeled as a tracker. That would make the most sense to me, though our hosts are very experienced and I don't really see how that could slip through. The important thing is lynching Ari today and lynching one of the "sources" tomorrow based on Ari's alignment flip and whatever data our PR's dredge up.
-
That doesn't read at all like a tracker/watcher result, more like some sort of soft rolecop that tells what action they performed, but not their role. Something doesn't add up here.
-
Tracker makes more sense, thanks for clearing that up. Are you some sort of rolecop tracker? I've never seen a tracker that reveals what action the target performed as well as who he targeted. Ari as a scum investigator could mean he's either a scum rolecop or we're dealing with two scumteams.
-
How would you see him perform an investigation if you were watching to see who targeted him? How did you know he performed an investigation? Watcher is not a rolecop, wouldn't you only know that he performed an action, not what action he performed? Excerpt you wouldn't have seen him perform anything if you watched Ari, because watcher =/= tracker. And if you didn't see him investigating because you're not a rolecop, what made you sure you could reach out to him? All you would have seen is him performing an action or having it performed on him, which is hardly basis for forming a town block. I'm now suspicious of you, your source, and Glenn's source! Hopefully our PR's can clear some of this mess up tonight. And Glenn still hasn't addressed my concerns about why his source trusted him enough to act as a mouthpiece for the real cop!
-
Let's pretend for a moment Ari was recruited, which I've already given my thoughts on up above. If Ari is the cop, how could Glenn's source have investigated Ari? This is getting out of hand!
-
Something is very very wrong here, and Rosamunde sums it up nicely. If Ari was actually recruited, his win condition would have changed accordingly and he would not under any circumstances have revealed that he was recruited. IIRC, power roles can't be recruited anyways. I call bluff meant to sow suspicion about a recruit and cast doubt on future "confirmed" townies. A ballsy play, but it doesn't hold up under closer inspection. If I can go meta for a minute, Shield v. Hydra had 16 players with 4 scum and an option to recruit a 5th. Though the town won, there was quite some discussion upon the conclusion if the recruit made the game too swingy. I doubt our beloved hosts would do something similar on the heels of that game unless there is some other mechanic to balance it, which is also a real possibility. I stand by my belief that Ari is working with Burpamount and trying to bluff a recruit to discredit future "cleared" townies. Assuming Ari does flip scum, the path is clear: lynch Williams "source" tomorrow.
