AwesomeStar

Cheers folks! Enjoy the rest of the game

Okay, I don't really have the time right now to do a full write up but I'll do my best to address some of your points: Uselessness: I'll admit I'm guilty of not having all that much to add on some days but really, what am I supposed to say? I have no PR and no connection to the town core so there's not really an awful lot for a vanilla to do really, especially at this stage of the game, except for going, "Oh god, not again!" each morning. I start each day knowing absolutely nothing other than that I'm still alive. Please enlighten me as to what I'm supposed to say, given my entirely useless role. Bandwagons: Practically everyone has jumped on the bandwagon at the end of each day this game. Are you going to lynch them too? Nearly everyone in this thread must, by your logic, be scum. "Expected vote against Gordon": .... Are you kidding me? Gordon was investigated by the magic stump thingy and was revealed as scum, right there in the day thread. Not a single person didn't vote for him. Not revealing my theories: I'm not about to send them to the vig considering the disastrous rate of success Wilder has been having lately... That's all I have time for right now, I just hope you reconsider your votes. Oh and by the way, everyone just jumped on the bandwagon...

Well, you aren't prepared to get on with this then I shall step up the plate. We need to get somewhere, even if it is just anywhere. Vote: Lt Wheeler (Inconspicuous)

I'm waiting for something to post about, of course

On behalf of the living: Sorry.

Come on then! Team GB, absolutely stellar this evening. And Jess Ennis, the golden girl!

Personally although I also recognise the points made against Hornby I have to say that he has presented a pretty solid case when it comes to Holloway. I don't wish to split the vote here but I can't help but think that we should perhaps go along with the theory. If Holloway turns out to be town, then we all know who to turn too tomorrow. Vote: Ensign Robert Holloway (WaterbrickDown)

I also want an answer to this. Personally I can't see how Dragonator and CJP have managed to escape all suspicion so far in the past two days, and I'm struggling to see what method you used to clear them.

Hey, I'm not proud! in all seriousness, however, I'm keeping them to myself for now as with all the recent deaths of people I thought I could trust I'm pretty hesitant when it comes to giving anything away. After all we still don't know how big the scum team is (do we?), and there's not an awful lot of us left. Besides, how about contributing your own theories and ideas before criticizing others for their apparent lack thereof?

Same here. I've been going over the data-logs from each day since we started recording and I'm close to finishing some theories I've been formulating as time has gone on.

Crap, this is worrying. It seems that just as we're actually getting somewhere, we get knocked back three steps. The death of McAndrews is a major blow as the list of confirmed, trustworthy and cunning townies grows shorter. I really hope we get somewhere today, the threat of 'lockdown' is especially concerning.

I'm normally incredibly cynical about this sort of thing but I did watch it and I'll come clean, it put a smile on my face.

Makes perfect sense to me. Shame we didn't get the result we were looking for but it's better than nothing! Vote: Ensign Toby Rockford (darkdragon)

I was also contacted by Holloway and I agree with this. Unlike fhomess, who is trustworthy as he openly claimed vig in-thread and has worked with others to form the town core, WBD's questions and cross-referencing don't sit well with me. He has not presented any reasons as to why exactly we should trust him and the fact that he asked after PRs worries me a little. It could quite easily be a cunning scum plan to get us to open up, though hopefully everybody else he has contacted will realise this too and keep quiet.

Okay, thanks for the swift reply! I look forward to seeing it all unfold. Who knows, maybe another City/Police mafia will roll around in a few years time or something.

Just a quick question, but if there are any spots left open (though I'm sure this game will prove very popular)is it possible to put my name on a 'reserves' list of some sort? I would really love to play this specific-themed game, but if not then no worries and of course I look forward to watching all the... "magic" unfold.

Glad to see somebody remembers my atrocious attempts at playing previous Mafias games. Just call me by name: Mr. Day One Lynch

D'oh - been waiting for a City police Mafia for a long time, it finally comes along and I can't play! Still, can't complain. This looks like it'll be a lot of fun for everyone involved. Best of luck!

I second this.

Vote: Andrew Gordon (Scubacarrot). Duh.

Holy crap, I didn't see that coming! Well, this is a cause of celebration - our first scum kill! Here's to many more! *clinks champagne glass*

To be fair, as a plan it could well work, but only if a more experienced and trusted member of the crew had put it into action. With yesterday and today's suspicions of York, this was never going to happen really, and instead we've just presented to the scum how confused we are and that we've resorted to in-fighting once again

Where did I hear what? I'm just responding to what Tammo posted.

Err, holy crap am I confused. So despite whatever you want to call it, we know that York, although pitifully retarded, is town, as she declared the PRs. And we also know that Tammo is town because he recognised them. Once again, no leads, and everyone is confused. Great! The only thing I can think of is that Tammo could have bluffed recognising the PRs (if he were scum, which I don't really think he is), and told the enemy, in which case we're all in a far bit of bother. However, I think that's a bit too far-fetched.

Well this is just great Clearly all our lines of inquiry so far have been damn wrong. Perhaps, seeing as the list of the innocent and dead has grown tragically long, we should stop basing our suspicions on the events of the simulation and place more of a focus on this actual game... of life. Because it's obvious that things are not as they once were, and our incompetence and stubbornness so far has lead to these crewmen's deaths. What strikes me as odd though is how wrong we really were. Quite honestly I was almost entirely sure Burbank would turn out to be scum. But now I really just don't know.