Finally got a chance to see the movie on a discount day. In just the 4th week it's already quite difficult to find a showing where I live in a major east coast city. A bunch of theaters have already taken it out of the rotation. Seems like it's doing quite poorly money-wise.
Scattered thoughts:
I would say I enjoyed the movie. I think everyone at the screenings going, basically, "it's fun" is about correct. Low stakes are okay.
It definitely does feel like a stitched-together TV special with a few episodes, although obviously Lucasfilm has denied that any of this was written for TV. On one occasion it felt like we were about to go to commercial.
Mando being a one-man army is a bit uninteresting in some regards because it trivializes most combat situations, but I guess Mandalorians are supposed to be the coolest dudes.
That arena fight has, like, 4 more monsters than it needs to. It's overwhelming to try and follow. Cool creature designs, though.
Overall hugely respected how many creatures there were. Extreme commitment, in a good way, to showing Star Wars full of aliens.
I hate celebrity voice-casting. Jeremy Allen White was actually okay, but a bunch of the others were not great.
The best vocal performance in the movie is Zeb because he's voiced by an actual voice actor. Nice seeing Steve Blum's name in the opening credits for a big movie. Superb anime dub guy.
The Anzellans rocked.
The solo bit with Grogu is probably one of the strongest sequences and is one of the few times the movie took a breather.
I think in a few years this will be considered an underrated film in the Star Wars canon. This is a decent movie that came out when Star Wars needed a great movie.
Unvarnished hater take:
Dave Filoni putting himself in this movie as "Trapper Wolf" is loser behavior, I'm sorry. The cut to him looking cool in his OC-megablocks outfit as they bring Janu Coin in is eye-rolling. Kathleen Kennedy may have had no plan, but at least she had the self-respect not to cast herself as Killer K le epic Imperial Hunter in Episodes 7-9.