Brickelodeon

If Dragonator's mask really was an investigator that is.

And this is what your entire argument is based off of. We don't even know if there IS an insane cop. You are just conveniently assuming that there is one, and that it is blackbeards shag instead of Dragonator's mask.

Humor me here: Assume that Shadows is scum and lied about what Dragonator said. Give me all of the evidence saying that blackbeards hat is the insane cop.

I'm not arguing that there weren't multiple cops, in fact I'm pretty sure there are at least two (blackbeards hat and the flavor cop). I'm arguing that we have no reason to think that blackbeards hat is the insane cop.

Wait, it's all coming together now! Except for your argument, that's falling apart. You're entire defense is that you know that you are town. Well, let me tell you, every scum someone manages to "know that they are town". We have NO REASON to think that I was insane when I investigated you, you have just manipulated the town into thinking there is. You and your scum buddy Shadows have been conveniently putting two and two together to make five, and "prove" that you are innocent. Your entire defense is based on the lack of evidence to prove or disprove that you are scum Why are we to believe that you are town when you were investigated as scum and we have no reason to doubt the investigation? Let me just say: If Tammo is town (which I don't think he is), we will lose one townie and one hat that could potentially be used by the scum for a TON of evil. If he is scum, we have a clear path to another scum (Shadows), and we also gain the knowledge that we have the real cop hat. The pros far outweigh the cons. Don't get me wrong, I never want to lynch a townie, but I think the chances of Tammo being scum are much higher than they are of him being town.

Wait, so your entire theory relies on the fact that "you know that you are town"? That's the biggest load of bull I've heard since I was Alaster Pear. Also, why would Shadows lie about it? He's one of your scum buddies trying to save your skin.

Okay, pardon me, but WHY THE HELL DO YOU THINK THAT DRAGGY WAS THE REAL INVESTIGATOR AND I'M NOT? This "overwhelming" evidence is nothing but guesswork and you believing Shadows when he says that he was contacted by Draginator. I really think that you and Shadows are working together to save your scummy skin. If you turn up scum tomorrow, Shadows is almost certainly scum as well. There is not evidence that I was the insane cop, there just isn't any evidence that I wasn't either.

We need the watcher to be on the cop tonight. I can guarantee that the scum will try to tamper with it somehow.

Investigate me Dave... If I turn up town, then the town will know that one of us is scum. If I turn up scum, we will know that Tammo is innocent. (that, or we are both scum).

*sighs* Tammo has me here. I admit it. I think he is scum because of the investigation and gut feeling. I have been trying to organize this town and come up good ways to prevent the scum from getting the PR hats. I will still be voting for Tammo when voting opens, but I have shown all of the evidence I have. Before I sign off as town-leader wannabe, I would like to quote Darth Vader. Tammo is scum, "search your feelings, you know it to be true". If it turns out that the investigator isn't insane tomorrow, I hope you (the town) aren't blind enough not to lynch him.

Oh! Is that how insane works? Okay, I didn't know that. I thought everyone just came up as scum with insane.

If we lynch Tammo today, the investigator wont have to waste the action on themselves. We will know tomorrow. Unless of course, it is the insane investigator but Tammo just happened to be scum. That would be weird...

Okay, here is why I think Tammo is scum: Even from Day 1, I have been PMing with him. I thought it a bit suspicious that he wasn't trying to organize the town like he had in previous games (Yes, a meta, I own it). The more I talked with him in PM and in the main thread, the more suspicious I got of him. I even told some of the other people I was PMing with at the time that I was suspicious of him (they can verify that if they wish). Naturally, since he is such a good mafia player, I wanted him to be in the inner townie circle or else dead, so I investigated him first. He came up scum. Now, even though we have some concrete evidence, you are saying that he is innocent? I admit that I MIGHT have been insane, but I think it much more likely that I wasn't. Furthermore, if I wasn't, I think that Shadows is also scum. Notice how Tammo grabbed Shadows' item instantly when day 2 started? That leads me to think that Tammo knew what it did. How else would he know unless Shadows was scum, or had told him. Secondly, as I said before, Tammo is a pro mafia player, that's why I wanted either to clear his name or kill him. Since he has so much experience, it doesn't surprise me that he hasn't left a huge trail of scummines behind him.

With this many claims, I'm willing to accept that I had the insane cop. But I still think we should lynch Tammo to be sure. It would be stupid to just ASSUME that I was insane, and not lynch Tammo.

Dave, I'm getting pissed off at your poetry. But it's because I'm jealous.

I don't think we should get rid of the vig just yet. As long as we have the cop hat, and we can confirm townies, I think it is to our advantage to keep it around. Dave has the cop today, so we should probably have the doctor use his action on him tonight. The watcher should probably use his ability on either me or Zepher.

I would like to say, if Tammo turns up scum tomorrow, Zepher is most likely town. Unless Tammo lied about trying to kill him, why would scum try to kill their own?

Well guys, I gotta go. For God's sake, make a good decision about the vig hat. The scum can't be getting that every time!

Since I was the cop, I find this unlikely. There is the possibility that I was the insane cop, but I honestly don't think this would be fair to the town. We need to vote on who should be the vig and who should be the cop. What is everyone's thoughts on this? Dave has already suggested himself... Looks like the cop issue has been resolved... I guess....

Defend myself? I'm concerned about finding the scum! I guess people were saying that they are suspicious of me, but that's because they didn't know all of the details. I'm trying to clear the air a bit by telling everyone exactly what happened. Now, hopefully, all of the BS about Draggy being the cop and my investigator lying can be dismissed.

Do you guys want the truth? Here it is: I was the cop. I said that someone else was the cop to avoid the scum from grabbing the cop hat and preventing the town from using it. I don't know if Dragonator really had a cop hat or of someone is lying. I sincerely hope that it is the latter. As for my grabbing of the Flash Hat? I did it so that Tammo couldn't. If he grabbed it, he would take it to his grave and we would lose it. This might not have been a bad thing, but I was in a rush, so I didn't think about every option.

Just woke up today, and before I go over anything I would like to say: In my opening post, I said "let's lynch this bastard". I hope you all know that I said that in the spirit of this game. I respect Tammo as the great player that he is, and I would never want to breach my friendship with him by calling him rude names.

Okay here is what I think: War Machines Helmet is the vig role, simply because there was no counter claim. Why would Tammo have risked being counter claimed by saying something that wasn't true? If my cop is telling the truth, he is either insane or the true cop. I don't really see there being an insane cop role in this game because that would be really unfair to the town. We will see tomorrow though, wont we? I think that Tammo is scum. If he is not, then we should lynch me or my cop for lying to the town. But what if Shadows is scum, and redirected the cops action (used on Tammo, who we will hypothesize as being town) onto a real scum. If Tammo turns up town, we should look VERY closely at Shadows, since we know he was able to redirect last night. I'm going to think about this more overnight, goodnight all.

If you are town Tammo, why did you grab that headpiece so quickly? Guys, my mind is spinning right now. Give me a moment to gather my thoughts.

Me too!