ADHO15

Seeing as everybody else could have done the same thing in private without me knowing about it, and you Agents all did it on the writeboard, I didn't think I should punish you because somebody posted your PM publicly. For all I know, everybody could have quoted their roles word-for-word to KDM when he was confirmed town, and I wouldn't have a clue. PS. Penguin, you sound like a behind-the-scenes DVD commentary. But seriously, thanks for posting all that and I can't express enough gratitude for all of your help throughout the game. I couldn't have done it without you!

I did contemplate whether I should confirm that there was a second scum faction that needed to be hunted down after the Agents were gone, but people did seem to be getting tired of the game and KDM made it incredibly clear that if I did that, and went against what I'd initially written as the Criminals' objective, I'd never live it down. So seeing as it was just you, I just ended it.

Thank you very much for all your kind words and compliments. It seems most of you enjoyed the game and liked playing it, which is what the main goal was, so I'm glad that worked out. I know Penguin is thrilled that you all liked his comics. I'll go into all that later when I explain each task in turn... Maybe you're right, but that is an obscure chain that isn't too obvious in the end. Ah, but Egghead wasn't technically an investigator role, so you can see how you still can't be certain when predicting the roles. Some of the tasks even consisted of recruiting people with certain roles, so this game was never meant to last all the way through without some roles becoming well known. Your character was a blocker when I first designed him, but eventually it turned into a more protective role, with a few hidden extras that I'll explain later... Why does he need to get out of it? Part of the skill in these games is coordinating the roles, which was really the main aim when it was so easy to work out most of the abilities. Organising an efficient town where the key roles are used to their maximum effectiveness is the real test of these games and I think it worked amazingly well here thanks to coordinators like def and KDM. Not only did it bring the town together, but it helped to weed out the Scum, so well done for that! Let's not get into that again. Religion is a touchy subject and people can get very easily offended by certain things, so like Tammo said, politics and religion are best kept to a minimum on international forums like this.

It seems you've forgotten how to read in your absence, CallMePie. No, that would have just got you penalty votes if the game carried on. You were just unlucky to be targetted by Croc on the last night. Like I assured CallMePie, existing stories and relationships in the comics and films had absolutely no effect on which characters were scum. I mostly organised the roles and I was not a particularly big Batman fan before starting work on this game a year ago, so I was not too aware that Catwoman wasn't really a criminal and was likely to be working for Batman. If anything, the Agents' allegiance was probably based on their roles, which isn't great, I know. In response to the complaints that the roles were predictable because of the characters, I personally don't think the game would have worked very well if the roles were random and Croc, for example, and investigator and Simon The Pieman was a serial killer. I tried to make the assigning of the roles to the players random by letting you pick your own character, but the character/role relationship was perhaps a bit obvious, though hopefully still a little hazy as many of the roles would suit several villains. Hush unknowingly protected you from all actions that Night, so people were not able to investigate you. But more on the night actions later... Yes, as you lost and The League Of Shadows' goal was going to be to detonate the missile, wiping out Gotham, I thought you could try to carry it out on your own as a desperate last attempt. Whether you died or lived and lost doesn't really matter. PS. @ Scorpiox - there's a link in the first post.

Please don't post role PMs. I'll post all of them in a short while along with some of my own comments. Here is the Undercover Agents' writeboard. The password is 'scumofgotham'. Feel free to discuss everything about the game and ask any questions. I'm particularly interested to hear what you thought about 'new elements' like picking your own role, tasks, etc. All non-players are allowed to post here too. -------------------------------------------- Winners - Baby Doll - played by KielDaMan - Criminal - Clayface - played by WhiteFang - Criminal - Harley Quinn - played by Alopex - Criminal - Hush - played by JimButcher - Criminal - Killer Croc - played by JediAnakin - Criminal - Man-Bat - played by Sirius Black - Criminal - Mr Freeze - played by Oky - Criminal - The Creeper - played by def - Independent - The Mad Hatter - played by Jedi master Brick - Criminal - The Music Meister - played by Capt. Redblade - Criminal Losers - Poison Ivy - played by badboytje88 - Independent Deceased - Catwoman - played by CallMePieOrDie - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day One - Bane - played by Masked Builder - Criminal - lynched on Day Two - Calendar Man - played by Bob_ - Criminal - killed on Day Three - The Riddler - played by sok117 - Criminal - killed on Day Three - Deadshot - played by Rumble Strike - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day Three - The Ventriloquist - played by Professor Flitwick - Undercover Agent - killed on Night Three - Simon The Pieman - played by Scorpiox - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day 4 - The Scarecrow - played by Peanuts - Criminal - killed on Night 4 - Mr Zsasz - played by Nightshroud99 - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day 5 - Ra’s Al Ghul - played by Fred Fred Burger - Scum - lynched on Day 6 - Black Mask - played by Brickdoctor - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day 7 - Two-Face - played by K-nut - Criminal - killed on Night 7 - Egghead - played by Captain Tamamono - Scum - killed on Night 7 -------------------------------------------- Confirmation And Discussion Thread Day One Day Two Day Three Day Four Day Five Day Six Day Seven

"Well fought everybody! Indeed. Let us move into the next room."

I know, but he was talking about you. Thank you very much! Nice work. I like the paint-look of the markings, but I agree with CTS, you should stay inside the lines.

So it is. That's devotion! Thanks, CTS. Welcome to EB, Sev. I'm glad you like my version of you. You should try it. You may be better than your brother at least (no offence intended there!) Thank you very much! You already have a commando template that matches your other troops, don't you? Cheers!

Whoops! Looks like I forgot again! Final vote tally Black Mask (Brickdoctor): 10 - KielDaMan, WhiteFang, Captain Tamamono, Alopex, JimButcher, JediAnakin, Sirius Black, def, Jedi master Brick, K-nut Mr Freeze (Oky): 1 - badboytje88 Poison Ivy (badboytje88): 1 - Capt. Redblade The Creeper (def): 1 - Oky Day Seven is now over. Please send in your night actions within the next 18 hours if you haven't already. Remember that you must use an ability each Night. Day Eight will begin in approximately 24 hours. Please close this thread.

"Once again I shall attack the Pirate Maid from the back row with Darkness."

Hmm, so stuff has obviously been going on in here. Is there any in-store CCTV?

Well I can't find any pictures of Corr, and no named troopers in those squads, but I guess I could post them as squads rather than individuals. Thanks. Cheers, CTS. Great job on Mute. Nice design. And congrats on becoming a citizen. I hear we've also reached 100 pages in this thread, so congrats to everyone for that! Nice to see so much interest here! Added: 187th Legion Commander (Phase II - 187th Legion) 187th Legion Trooper (Phase II - 187th Legion) 187th Legion Paratrooper (Phase II - 187th Legion) 187th Legion Snowtrooper (Phase II - 187th Legion) Updated: Ponds (Phase I - Lightning Squadron) I've no idea who 'purple-Cody' is really, or where to organise him, so I just threw him in with these other purple troops.

Current vote tally Black Mask (Brickdoctor): 10 - KielDaMan, WhiteFang, Captain Tamamono, Alopex, JimButcher, JediAnakin, Sirius Black, def, Jedi master Brick, K-nut Poison Ivy (badboytje88): 1 - Capt. Redblade The Creeper (def): 1 - Oky Yet to vote: Brickdoctor, badboytje88

I don't know. Yours were pretty good. Glad you like them though. Thank you very much! I thought that was Niner at first, but later realised it must be Fi. I thought Fi had black patterns, but I suppose it is more dark blue. I'll change that sometime. Thanks a lot, Dpaduwan! I suppose so, but I can't think of anymore so any ideas would be appreciated. Added: Sarge - (Phase I - Aiwha Squad) Di'Kut - (Phase I - Aiwha Squad) Tyto - (Phase I - Aiwha Squad) Zag - (Phase I - Aiwha Squad)

Wow. Thanks a lot, CTS! Means a lot! That Ponds looks a bit odd, but I'll give him a go sometime. Added: Niner (Phase I - Omega Squad) Atin (Phase I - Omega Squad) Darman (Phase I - Omega Squad) Fi (Phase I - Omega Squad)

"At last a hit! Let us see if I can finish off this Pirate Maid when I attack once more from the back row with Darkness."

Voting has now begun! There are 48 hours left of Day Seven.

Thank you very much, guys! I'm glad you like them! Got Delta Squad for you now... Added: Boss (Phase I - Delta Squad) Fixer (Phase I - Delta Squad) Scorch (Phase I - Delta Squad) Sev (Phase I - Delta Squad) Ponds (Phase I - Lightning Squadron)

Just one from me today. I've worked on it a fair bit, and I know it's far from perfect, but... Added: Clone Commando (Phase I - Clone Trooper Types)

Ooh great. Can't wait, dude. Marcus' house is the only one left to check, correct?

Well I'm not sure what reference that was then. Here is Fives in the Citadel arc and he clearly has that same triangle pattern. The face tattoo is fine. I was meaning on top of his helmet, which should cover pretty much the whole area, and not leave a white space underneath. Good idea. It should be more of a W shape. No problem.

Well the armour of the ARC-170 pilot isn't quite right, the pipe should attach to the bottom of the chest box, the stealth ship pilot shouldn't have an orange visor, the yellow Phase whatever pilot should have pipes attached to his helmet, not over his shoulders, etc.

It is not a typo, hence the reason it appears in the opening comic and the deceased players list.

Players only please. Day Seven has begun and will last 72 hours. You must wait 24 hours before voting. -------------------------------------------- Objectives To win the game, the Criminals must kill off all the Undercover Agents, while the Undercover Agents need to outnumber the Criminals. -------------------------------------------- Rules 1. Each player has been given a character to play who is aligned with either the Criminals or the Undercover Agents. Third-Party (neutral) characters have their own win conditions as outlined in their roles. 2. Each day you will be able to vote to lynch a player. Voting should be done in the following format; Vote: Character (Player). Similarly, unvoting is to be done in the format; Unvote: Character (Player). No other format will be accepted and proxy voting is not allowed, except in the case of a pre-notified absence. A majority vote is required to lynch a player. In the case of a tie, one of the tied individuals will be lynched at random. Voting is mandatory. 3. A game Day will last a maximum of 72 hours. You may not vote in the first 24 hours. The Day will end when all players have voted and a majority vote has been reached. After the Day has concluded, a Night stage will commence, which will last 24 hours. Night actions must be sent to the host in the 18 hours of the night stage. 4. The alignment of lynched players, as well as those that died during the night will, in most cases, be revealed at the beginning of the next day. 5. You may not quote or pretend to quote anything sent to you by the game host via PM. This includes all the details of your character and role, as well as any night action results. Role claims and reporting of Night action results are acceptable, but in your own words only. Do not attempt to use the structure of your role PM to your advantage. 6. Do not play the game outside the Day threads. Similarly, do not post out of character inside the Day threads. Game tactics and roles may only be discussed in the game threads or via PM with other players. Private discussion is done at your own risk and should be treated as part of the game. 7. If you are dead, you may not post in Day threads or discuss the game with any of the players. Any information you had becomes void, and may not be passed on. 8. You may not edit your posts. 9. If you encounter a problem or have a question, please contact the host via the role PM. 10. Every player will get an Action and a Skill at their disposal. These can only be used during the Night. These are all active; none are passive. 11. Each Night, the players must use one of their Actions OR Skills by sending the host a PM about it, stating which you want to use and also your target where applicable. 12. The Night abilities have a pre-specified order of effect. If you don’t send your night ability by the time limit I’ve started the next Day, you will miss your chance to use it. 13. By using existing characters, it is expected that players will live up to their roles and follow their characters closely. Also, any referring to players by their username rather than their character’s name will not be tolerated. 14. Violation of the above rules will result in a 5 vote penalty against you on your first offence, and the death of your character on your second offence. -------------------------------------------- Non-playable Characters The Joker - played by ADHO15 The Penguin - played by The Penguin Players - Baby Doll - played by KielDaMan - Black Mask - played by Brickdoctor - Clayface - played by WhiteFang - Egghead - played by Captain Tamamono - Harley Quinn - played by Alopex - Hush - played by JimButcher - Killer Croc - played by JediAnakin - Man-Bat - played by Sirius Black - Mr Freeze - played by Oky - Poison Ivy - played by badboytje88 - The Creeper - played by def - The Mad Hatter - played by Jedi master Brick - The Music Meister - played by Capt. Redblade - Two-Face - played by K-nut Deceased - Catwoman - played by CallMePieOrDie - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day One - Bane - played by Masked Builder - Criminal - lynched on Day Two - Calendar Man - played by Bob_ - Criminal - killed on Day Three - The Riddler - played by sok117 - Criminal - killed on Day Three - Deadshot - played by Rumble Strike - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day Three - The Ventriloquist - played by Professor Flitwick - Undercover Agent - killed on Night Three - Simon The Pieman - played by Scorpiox - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day 4 - The Scarecrow - played by Peanuts - Criminal - killed on Night 4 - Mr Zsasz - played by Nightshroud99 - Undercover Agent - lynched on Day 5 - Ra’s Al Ghul - played by Fred Fred Burger - Scum - lynched on Day 6 -------------------------------------------- Confirmation And Discussion Thread Day One Day Two Day Three Day Four Day Five Day Six