Zandder

Must be a generational divide or something...

Hold up, this is Day 5, not Day 4.

Two down, one to go I really enjoyed the Baby Shark cover, Luxxon & Araveea

Tameekys is my prime suspect, personally, but in my spreadsheet I have Nerrio in second due to his flaky relationship with contributions to the discussion. I presently lean towards Marwyyn as town so, to prevent any last-minute funny business, I will Unvote: Tameekys Vote: Nerrio

Has anyone else only just realized that @Eeyara has gone AWOL? She's "bouta get yeeted" by penalties tomorrow if she doesn't show up soon.

Sorry... Are you going to vote for one or the other then? At the moment you definitely have the most votes. But that could change. Looking at you as well. If both Marwyyn and Nerrio voted for Tameekys, that would make three. Almost enough to put her over the top and get pew-pewed.

Maybe it's Crapowee-wah

I didn't like it when Tameekys voted for Eeyara yesterday, because hopping on the wagon was the easy option: And today she says "aw shucks bah gawd Marwyyn's halfway to a lynch already, let's see who wants to ride that wagon", and in her next contribution she shares that In other words "I'm going to see what wagon starts up that I can hop on because I don't care who gets lynched (as long as it's not me lmao) because I'm scum". So Vote: Tameekys Though before I lose my train of thought, I have the following comments: So far there appear to be Cadd, Marwyyn, Eeyara and Araveea who can be trusted. And Coralaaze who can't be trusted but she's dead. Can five people really have been investigated in the space of three nights? If I were one of you four, I would keep things close to my vest. On the other hand, bussing is a thing, and that's what justified Araveea's vote for me on Day Two, because I had voted for Marwyyn on Day One. Notwithstanding they seem to trust each other now, the notion of bussing still exists.

I thought that was implicit given the context in which Nancy said it? You know, the separate paragraph about how it may be possible for the Traveler to kill someone. I find this interesting, although I must acknowledge I've been biased against Marwyyn for a while. But down here, we are all fish. Except for Scabowee-wah. It's OK, bro.

I don't have any insight into what the Traveler thinks, but situations such as this are typically balanced 50-50 and the Traveler is supposed to be a very powerful entity. They could choose to side with either us or the Gorgons, or side with nobody at all. [youtube]qoqQnR8NOVI[/youtube] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qoqQnR8NOVI

So the investigator panned out, which means it's someone we can trust. As for whom we shouldn't trust, it's possible the Traveler reached out to the scum in the night. Araveea pointed out yesterday that they probably could win with us, but if that's the case they probably could also win with the Gorgons. And do we believe that Nancy is an Inventor? Or did Coralaaze try to pull a fast one over us? But surely she knew that that can be checked by investigation, if the investigator caught her on Night Two? Huh?

If you know that, then your scum buddies would too. Then why tell us so? Wouldn't you want to keep us in the dark? Will we? At the moment we're working on the assumption that Coralaaze is scum. And if she flips scum, what changes? Will we know what the Traveler chooses to do? This is unclear.

I agree that we need to test the investigation result. Unvote: Araveea, Vote: Coralaaze This is a weird way to put it. Why "I'd be willing to" and not "We have to"?

That's very true, and we got lucky last night that nobody died. Is this a wise thing to say, considering you've been the top candidate two days running? *used to

Araveea voted for Eeyara on Day One (and today) but not yesterday. On Day One, Eeyara started out quiet and people took her to task for that. Later in the day, Araveea voted for Eeyara for the following reasons: OK. Fine. And then on Day Two, Araveea says that Eeyara remains suspicious for the same reasons as before. She voted for me because apparently I was spooked by something she said, because Araveea has all the best words or something We're still "suspicious of Eeyara". As the votes pile up on Eeyara, though, her opinion mellows: So on Day One people—not Araveea, it must be pointed out—voted for Eeyara because she was quiet. And now being quiet is a townread—or a new strategy. OK. But this provides all the cover we need to avoid hopping on that wagon. But she's changed her mind today now that she can be the first person on the wagon. Right back atcha darling. Vote: Araveea

Going for the easiest option, I see, mother dearest? You say "ahhh I can't decide" and then quite easily vote first for Eeyara, who was the top lynch candidate yesterday. Nancy has already pointed it out about you and Coralaaze, but it bears repeating: it's not actually that hard to sheep the wagon before everyone votes for her, is it? Marwyyn has really chilled out today and isn't as hyper-defensive as she was in earlier days. It's like she's just... present.

What I mean is that if someone drops a case against someone else today, then there's a chance they're OG scum and traitor. It's nothing that needs to be kept secret and indeed shouldn't be. We must remain eagle-eyed. Correctamundo

Well, not quite. At least one thing is different: the number of scrolls in play.

Are they screwing with us or did they recruit in the night? Seeing how we vote today may reveal whether the Gorgons did manage to recruit someone.

It's a Christmas miracle!

Very true Araveea - but Cadd and Coralaaze voted for different reasons. It is the later voters who piled on with "yeah Eeyara has been quiet, let's vote for her". "Looks like scum are leading us to a lynch but I'll go with the flow anyway" It doesn't look like anyone agrees with Cadd's reasoning. It looks like he's useful to get a lynch started.

No confusion; it was fairly unsubtle. The case against Eeyara today started in an interesting place: If Eeyara were a Gorgon, why would she expect a second kill, knowing about a hypothetical vigilante? The easiest route to this knowledge, I think, is for scum to have picked the rolecop role and targeted a hypothetical vigilante last night. But then why reveal that expectation after the fact? If she expected a second kill because she is the vigilante then again: why? And then Coralaaze developed the case as follows: Eeyara spoke her mind yesterday after being crapped on for being quiet (and for voting for herself ) and now she's being crapped on for being quiet - pointed out by Coralaaze and piled on upon by Marwyyn, Tameekys and Luxxon. It seems like people are just mobilizing for a lynch. And as they say somewhere above sea level, cherchez le mouton. Marwyyn anyone?

It's because you said it early, in the midst of your obsession with the scrolls, before I started tuning you out: To me this screams that you "might be waiting for the results of night actions". OK, but what was so pressing about it that you had to come to me in the night rather than telling everyone in the new day?

Really? You're giving yourself rather much credit here. I didn't pay much attention to what you said because most of it's a crock of shite, like your theory about the night killer and your suggestions yesterday to wait for night action results to be revealed. Sorry, I guess? Yes, Marwyyn is suspicious. Vote: Marwyyn Actually Marwyyn came to me in the night to explain that she thought Luxxon was scum and Cadd was a traitor. I use the past tense because she's not really gone into it today. All we've got from Marwyyn today is "Eeyara probably wanted to bump Ronnan off". I like the crunk music, though. That's good stuff.